rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

August 28

7 minutes ago, Miles. said:

All jokes aside, Loser has six good songs that keep it from going down like the Titanic, it's true:

Cruel Summer

Miss Americana

Lover

The Archer

Daylight

Afterglow

A missed opportunity for a great EP!

My EP would look more like:

Cruel Summer

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince

Cornelia Street

All of the Girls You Loved Before

Afterglow

False God

Death by a Thousand Cuts

August 28

Ballots Received (106):

Spoiler

1. terrorblade

2. tb6591

3. SlyMacPer

4. PaloSanto

5. greento

6. NordicGuy

7. Forever Winter

8. The Music Industry

9. Solaria

10. pinkbowvintage

11. 1989

12. Peroxide

13. DevilsRollTheDice

14. NEX

15. Live To Tell

16. Teen Spirit

17. sanzo

18. MidnightsAtPeace

19. Avrileon

20. CamiloPg_

21. 4Real

22. KillingYourCareer

23. a_d_22

24. Namigo

25. llikeh

26. 305

27. Arrows

28. skizzo

29. Soobin

30. Tusk

31. Riverbank

32. theluckyone

33. LastKiss

34. itsjem

35. Hurem

36. Life Savers

37. folkloreking

38. gagacasanova

39. Vespertine

40. freakum.

41. chosensparkles

42. reputation1989

43. D-@-N

44. badidearight

45. Velvet Night

46. Enrique523

47. Mr. Duff

48. AshleyLovescats887

49. ChapelHooker

50. Gorjesspazze9

51. halcyonday

52. iamanearthling

53. AbeHicks

54. Axolotl

55. jacobhalkohit

56. PerfectSacrifice

57. Frankvert

58. Venice B

59. vinicius

60. Fitzswiftie

61. Yog

62. Ampersand13

63. Feanor

64. wastedpotential

65. Prismee

66. idkwiam

67. Schami66

68. Støned

69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey

70. djcalpal

71. Great Username

72. Tedwards

73. tjspy

74. Mezik

75. LVP

76. Miles.

77. NextBish90

78. liam13

79. SLUTTVFTV

80. Sad Beautiful Tragic

81. Losing my ground

82. GuyNextDoor

83. ??????

84. burninredhot

85. americanlife

86. Supernatural

87. Terylee

88. Mocha

89. Modern thing

90. TaylenaStan

91. Nein

92. Ger.vaz

93. fridayteenage

94. ONOPKA

95. makeawish

96. Holy Ground

97. LovaticSwiftie

98. RihannaLoverrr

99. Dear Reader

100. roso

101. Catch22

102. holyground13

103. creativity.

104. Strawberry Bubble

105. brokee

106. paulyyyozd

August 28

My Lover EP:

Cruel Summer

Miss Americana

Paper Rings

Cornelia Street

Death By A Thousand Cuts

False God

All Of The Girls You've Loved Before

Two of these songs got a 10, one got a 9.5, and the others all scored above an 8. :clap3:

The rest of the album? Well

:suburban:

August 28

5 minutes ago, 1989 said:

My Lover EP:

Paper Rings

:pukey: :pukey: :pukey:

And if I said Paper Rings was a ME!th sized crime against art?

August 28

Just now, Miles. said:

And if I said Paper Rings was a ME!th sized crime against art?

Jail

:khalyan2:

August 28

9 minutes ago, Miles. said:

And if I said Paper Rings was a ME!th sized crime against art?

You'd just be saying absolute ****! :khalyan2:

August 28

I can't believe I'm defending LOSER but I'm extremely alarmed seeing all of you leave The Archer off your EPs.......... when it's far and away the second best song on that bloated sickly sweet mess.

August 29

1. Cruel Summer

2. Lover

3. Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince

4. Paper Rings

5. Cornelia Street

6. Death By A Thousand Cuts

7. All of The Girls You Loved Before

8. Afterglow

-

9. Need (From The Vault)

And I would have forced her ass back into the recording booth to make the rest of the album.

:suburban:

August 29

4 hours ago, Miles. said:

I can't believe I'm defending LOSER but I'm extremely alarmed seeing all of you leave The Archer off your EPs.......... when it's far and away the second best song on that bloated sickly sweet mess.

OH babe I'm sorry to tell you that The Archer's only qualities are: coming right after The Man (which elevates the song by proximity) and... that's about it.

I hope this rate is finally the time for the much needed wake up call regarding this song. Just because it's a track 5 should not save his ass. :ryan3:

August 29

5 hours ago, Miles. said:

I can't believe I'm defending LOSER but I'm extremely alarmed seeing all of you leave The Archer off your EPs.......... when it's far and away the second best song on that bloated sickly sweet mess.

The Archer is her WORST track 5 :dies: the humpty dumpty line alone :dies:

August 29

Actually let me make my Loser EP too.

--I love my London Boy--

1. Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince

2. Lover

3. All Of The Girls You Loved Before

--Anxiety slowly rising--

4. Cruel Summer

5. Afterglow

6. False God

7. Cornelia Street

--So Long, London Boy--

8. Death By A Thousand Cuts

Oof I fear I've been cooking cause that storyline is giving (EP)OTY. :ryan3:

August 29

I was tagged yesterday and didn't know this was happening until then :toofunny2:

There's only two days left, it's so much music to rate and I only know like 60% of her discography... Don't think I'll join but so many people already sent their ballots so I'm sure it'll be fun :giraffe:

August 29

@Forever Winter Ballot submitted

August 29

1 hour ago, ellis-bell said:

@Forever Winter Ballot submitted

Received. Thank you!

August 29

Hi everyone!

Spoiler

@PoisonedIvy @Klein @State of Grace. @Badgalbriel @Heldenzeit @FolkLover1989 @Folklore89sm @Cruel Summer @Goaty @taylor__fan @vale9001 @Kyle-x @Popboi. @Saint James @Gladiator @Ms. Togekiss @Great Username @Lille @LostInStereo100 @Cleanromantic @Michael196 @MardinBeksloy @cruelhprince @RideOrDie @YR. @Buffy @PrismaticOwen @Chris @OnlyManInTheWorld @Taylor fanboy @KatyPrismSpirit @Starchild @By the Water @Raphy23 @19SLAYty9 @Squall @mael @Bosque @Save-Me-Oprah @YellowRibbon @AndThenTheCocaine @Timeless @IBeMe @Achilles. @Fama @G.U.Y. Gaga @drivers license @UnusualBoy @Taylor Sniffs @DesiredConsternation @Kavish @Bussea @SleepingTigers @byzantium @Taylena @TayDuaStan @Hunter_13 @Shendelzare @Lorenzo22 @feelslikeadream @Rev8 @TheArgonaut @Jaay @Fifteen @doonerr @P!NK2LOVE @xfreshkidxx @inshadesofcool @Indie Go Mind @GreatestLoveofAll @Ayanaa @JoeAg @Sanguine @Legend E @Quicksand @ChrisTheLoner @Walk_Away21 @wehavetostan @MissedTheTrain @bluebirdsforever @Juánny @woohoo @Bloo @KeshaSwift @Miss Americana @Trent W @ariananext @blown away @Maroonx @Sabrina Carpenter @Kimi @Safe&Sound @enchanted0 @aesthetic bih @My Tears Ricochet @rebeltwat @LoveInStereo @dussel_06 @Kyungsoowift @diemoehre @Clauss @Flower @WeFoundWill @jacklovesyou1 @Edge Of Glory @nostalgic @AdrianNicki @yourfaveisaflop @Taemira @roso @Alldeezy @djcalpal @Doogle @TMRA @Virgos Groove @BlackAura @Britney Jean @TaggedGalaxy @Bad News @olivethetree @taylorrrr @TaylorNation @KOMH @SoulKiwi @skwonderfactory @FlyOnTheWall @Pheromosa @Frogger17 @Carrie-is-no-1 @Rep2000 @UNNAMI @alestevens @NoOneDiesFromLove @Jude @Miss Fortune @houndsoflove @Life Savers @Danial @Ramona16 @VeniceBeach @sleepevaded @oceans @Gam @romas_ld @MusicLoverDude @kyoshi @PurrKaty @Mellark @Lemon @Starkboy @pavi @BeenTheShit @KnightOfAllRealms @Finkypop @Lightbringer007 @Maroon legacy @chiliam @Sailor Moon @Hitchhiker @Sweeftie13 @siegetheday @dreamofyou @Saintlor @HappierJealousy @greeneyedsoul @queenoftheclouds @Nico Robin @Bonicap @Mandalore @cruelcooper @cat1867 @BabyBenzz @touch @2NE1 @Underdogs @Better Mistakes @Monster Queen @Arcade ring @Nashe @TaylorFantasy @Illuminati @youreyesgocold @Wonderland @Ruben @Dragonfly @xXavril @Jai @danielins @mypaintoyou @Trainwreck @swiftawaywithme @Fastlane @Aiya @Ken Lee @naval23 @Isaiah @EtherealCat @Rider @evtimow @chaeyonce @Bindi @sparrowblue @All Too Well @Wolf Alice @eli's_rhythm @BloodLuster @dreampop @aotearoa @Finish Ticket @ALittleGauche @RoyalT @willmcclure9 @blueberries @K$Ellie @Jenlisa @Josh @Mighty Oaks @foundwonderland @ronelmaano13 @Ithinkforme13 @Everyperfectsummer @Aquamarine @dwuw @AM98GJ @JosephT @discotitzz @OhMyAlf @taemin @GiftFromGod @GambleBreauxNews @Hephaestus @DatChickDoe @simmnfierzig @wren @Ramona16 @BtDecember @LaFlaca @SwiftLover @JawBreaker @beagle @Lazuli @Donquizote @Sprawl @TayGod @Jaspurr @Meeko @fromily @Digitalism @evermore. @If U Seek Amy @fememeist @JustHoran @mileytayIor @Diarrhoea @ChatshireCat @sexyback007 @tombiz @diamondsky @venuss @Delusional @keerbyriri @MusicLoverDude @Finny @shookspeare @katyslut @Kristen @Matchatea @piotrert @Meev @Mark! @YourFavoriteWeapon @TayRianaPH @BlackoutZone @NorbertMinaj @SwiftBoy @Swiffer @Swift_Fenty @Britney Is Fierce @Flames2Embers @Calvin @Cornelia Street @ttds @Tiziano's Boy @style17 @EndofASadMovie @Mdawg @Da Vinci @scottstreet @ang @TeamThiem @JorgeM @PatrickGray.12 @justin464 @ohjulia @saintjude @Raspberries @Everyperfectsummer @RoseBud @Lulento @soulsearcher @zuzufruit @Listentoyourheart @Kuntmonster @taylordswift13 @PiperHalliwell @Technicolor @MerveAksak @Mike95 @twoheadlightshine @Verge of Obscene @Tal_reputation @ugo @visions @Archie @antihero @Mitsuki @NewStanner @dietmtndew @cowboy like 1989 @All Guns Blazing @LongLive @KarmaCat @RandomName @TayDine1989 @Kev @Alena @Pop_Music_Lover @Taylor Swift @Finny @mrpartyrocker @FireBomber @Twilish @Støned @AvadaKedavra @TaylorsSquad @Paddy @niiall @King Dan @RadioactiveLights @kexin @Misty2412 @Tedwards @cartierdelrey @Bartender @RobynYoBank @timothymincer @ErnieSwift @C_Colstead @RebelQuad @nasa @Fire Bomb @POPTART @Scheissex @family.guy123 @Iaintsorry @BOAZ @Purple Land @fab @smgupdated @Lachlan @WiddLe @Brycee @PieceBy @torontowest91 @penguintim @stevenisFADING @Ratviolo @Breakdown @emailmyhearts @campelo @Delicate @insomniac @Jglj @anastaciabby @Rence @watermelonshake @furlevan @Liafen @The Slayer @LovingDays @Jack! @troubled water. @tiagol88 @HeddaO @Cocetti @shark_heather @levi_valvi @Asscatchem @Feetree @Encanto @Jpkun @ALA @touchofmyhand @Redstreak @plum @Indie @Club classic @Blood Magic @FameFatale @Pink Whitney @bunton @LittleFreak @KarlosVzla @Veis @AdamRiver96 @Shazbaz13 @Homebrand @Halcyon Days @Opulence @SoSickOfThatSOL @tokito @WonderstruckFR @BlowYourMind @Rob_Matteo @Greg @Aleks @rivingtonrebel @AlfonsoVM @kellysclarkson @oscarscheller @Brodie @Julián @ADMKHN @Bibliotheque @hindsight @zuper @Tortue @Hooker Barbie @MatiRod @dietmtndew @TOKYO. @Style. @MAGIA @AnitaFalafel @wwshooter @extra_ordinary @Sensation @elincomprendid @sasashite @Redstreak @joannna @Beyonnaise @Scandalous @Flashbackwhen @nintendude666 @ChooseyLover @WildHeart @Kirby Kirbs

The rate deadline will be extended to Sunday, September 1 (one extra day).

This is to give you the entire weekend to start and/or complete your ballots.

The reveal (first day) will start on Monday, September 2.

10:00 AM - PST

1:00 PM - EST

6:00 PM / 18:00 - GMT+1

We have 117 participants so far, which is amazing. Thank you all to have submitted so far.

I encourage you all to participate to make this even more eventful as these rates only happen once every year or two.

REMINDERS (PLEASE READ!)

Google Form

The discography rate is being conducted via Google Form. See link below:

https://forms.gle/bNn6wDEC2wz4mkPc7

The Google Form autosaves your results even if the form is incomplete.

You may go back into the form at any time to edit, even after submitting.

Your ballot will NOT record onto the Excel spreadsheet until you click Submit at the bottom of the form.

Please ping me in this thread to confirm your submission.

Ballot Reminders

- Please use the remaining three days and relisten to songs to give accurate ratings. ~~Some of you guys BS'd your ballots (I can tell ).~~

- All 260 songs must be ranked for your ballot to qualify.

- Troll/sabotage ballots are NOT allowed. Please see the rules below to check if your ballot qualifies.

- Remember to strategically use your five 11s and 0s, 0s especially for sabotage.

- Don't waste 11s on All Too Well and 0s on songs like ME!/You Need to Calm Down!

- Add comments next to your scores to make the rate more entertaining!

𝐑𝐀𝐓𝐄 𝐑𝐔𝐋𝐄𝐒

Spoiler

1. For Prompt #1, make sure to enter your ATRL Username. Your scores will not count towards the rate unless a valid ATRL Username has been submitted.

2. Rate every song on the form from 1-10. Decimals are allowed (only one decimal place).

Examples: 9.1 is acceptable; 3.6654 is unacceptable.

3. You may rate up to FIVE songs with a score of 11, and FIVE songs with a score of 0.

4. Troll scores are not allowed.

Anyone who violates this rule will be disqualified from the rate and your ballot will be removed completely.

Examples:

Rating every song on reputation or Lover scores of 1 or 2.

Rating every song from one album scores of 10.

5. For songs with original and Taylor's Versions, base your scores on the better version of each song.
Examples:

Rate Sparks Fly, We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together & Style based on the original versions.

Rate The Way I Loved You, Red & Treacherous based on the Taylor's Versions.

6. Comments are optional but they're encouraged to make the rate more entertaining (add them in the text boxes when entering your scores).

7. The following songs will be combined and counted as one song each. Rate the best version of every song:

Forever & Always / Forever & Always (Piano Version)

State of Grace / State of Grace (Acoustic Version)

All Too Well / All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Babe / Babe (Sugarland feat. Taylor Swift)

Bad Blood / Bad Blood (feat. Kendrick Lamar)

Lover / Lover (feat. Shawn Mendes)

Anti-Hero / Anti-Hero (feat. Bleachers)

Snow on the Beach (feat. Lana Del Rey) / Snow on the Beach (feat. More Lana Del Rey)

Karma / Karma (feat. Ice Spice)

8. Do not post your ballots in this thread. Please message me here on ATRL (via reply or DM) once you have submitted your ballot to ensure that your results have transferred onto the Google Sheet.

𝐁𝐀𝐋𝐋𝐎𝐓𝐒 𝐑𝐄𝐂𝐄𝐈𝐕𝐄𝐃 (110):

Spoiler

1. @terrorblade

2. @tb6591

3. @SylMacPer

4. @PaloSanto

5. @greento

6. @NordicGuy

7. @Forever Winter

8. @The Music Industry

9. @Solaria

10. @pinkbowvintage