makeawish

she has a very dialled in fanbase but this is not a reach out to the general public sort of album, i didn't think it would do that well tbh

songs like rein me in make me want to have a rule when they just chuck it out after 6 months and who cares what anyone thinks about it, it's gone on long enough now

i don't think ME! is a bad song, it just has a lot of musical theatre energy which was never going to survive contact with the wider world (esp ATRL). you need to calm down has a much stronger case for being an actual bad song

long time since i dug this out (not sure if the comic sans on the album sleeve adds or detracts)

honestly i think she released rock music to flop, it's easily the worst of the three, barely has a tune, doesn't even crack 2 minutes, i suspect it's bothering ATRL a lot more than charli

yet another record breaking week for rein me in (yawn), lots of football there's a few random oldies popping up, largely football related, no new entries to speak of https://www.officialcharts.com/charts/singles-chart/20260717/7501/ https://www.officialcharts.com/charts/albums-chart/20260717/7502/

what's her take, was it just a vibe she was going thru or did something go actually wrong? (there's a pic where she has full 80s shoulderpads as well and as alarming as it is i can at least see the vision)

continuing with the annie zaleski book, taylor's hair wasn't good during the lover era. there's something kinda femullet about it? it's making me uncomfortable

back on 1996, long time since i heard this (worse than i remember it tbh)

i loved secret of us cos it's so hooky but also full of all that anxious perspective so i was a bit wary of this but i'm a third of the way thru and...it seems alright? i wasn't expecting it to be full of tunes so actually the fact that it's got some is a bonus, could do with more bangers but i can see myself enjoying it a lot once its played in, agree that she could do with moving on from dessner (why do these girls always use the same half a dozen producers?!)

a few more, some obvious, some a bit lost to time

this is the whis thread we've been waiting for, i'm in awe

maybe they just aren't very nice?

scream more of a rep now, michael was already falling off commercially at that point for fairly obvious reasons tho personally i think MATM is a bop and better than its numbers