Peroxide

Well Olivia delivered a good album. Taylor did not.

Not you moving the goalposts. Girl. Your original claim was "Beyoncé ignored it since it got released + Beyoncé has never performed it live" - both false!

Telephone was huge upon release. What is this answer?

What a horrible story. This kind of stuff seems to be happening more and more frequently these days too. RIP to this poor man.

He looks fine? Sure… he's not "celebrity levels of hot" anymore but 2009 was almost two decades ago… people are allowed to age.

Good. Poets will absolutely get its moment in the sun further down the road…

Debut - C+ Fearless - B Speak Now - A Red - A 1989 - A+ Reputation - B+ Lover - C+ Folklore - A+ Evermore - A Midnights - B+ TTPD - A+ TTPD: The Anthology - B+ TLOASG - E

Rachel is spitting facts over here…

Probably one of the most disappointing listening experiences I've ever had for an album I was looking forward to. I was sort of cat-fished by Ophelia and everything just got progressively worse until we hit Eldest Daughter and at that point I knew we were in trouble… I couldn't fathom the same woman who gave us songs like Loml and The Prophecy just the previous year was giving us a chorus that started with "but I'm not a bad ***** and this isn't savage"… it felt felt like I was undergoing some sort of psychosis. From the standard edition, the only two songs worthy of being released were Ophelia and RTF. Everything else ranges from average to utterly diabolical.

Showgirl is by far her worst album but the 11th spot is a little harder to place. For now… I would say it goes to debut. Lover still has Cruel Summer, Death By A Thousand Cuts, Afterglow, Soon You'll Get Better, I Think He Knows, the title track, Miss Americana etc… I think Lover is probably her tenth "worst" album but I certainly don't think it's bad. Just not amazing.

Certain users make being both a fan of Gaga and Taylor on this site next to impossible.

… coked-out circuit gays? Miss girl this isn't Charli or Slayyter. If you're going to drag, drag with accuracy.

I completely understand why there was such a backlash when it came to Showgirl but Poets is absolutely sublime and deserved a much warmer critical reception. Possibly my favourite Taylor album and I've been a fan since Speak Now. 10/10 Tracks: Fortnight, Down Bad, But Daddy I Love Him, Fresh Out The Slammer, Guilty As Sin?, Loml, The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived, The Prophecy 9/10 Tracks: The Tortured Poets Department, So Long London, Clara Bow, The Black Dog, imgonnagetyouback, I Hate It Here, I Look In Peoples Windows 8/10 Tracks: My Boy Only Breaks His Favourite Toys, I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can), I Can Do It With A Broken Heart, The Alchemy, Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus, The Manuscript 7/10 Tracks: Who's Afraid of Little Old Me, The Albatross, How Did It End?, Thank You Aimee, Cassandra, Peter, The Bolter 6/10 Tracks: Florida!!!, So High School, Robin I think if we'd had gotten The Anthology a little further down the line the album would been received more favourably… and the lyrics people choose to make fun from the title track aren't even bad. It's a gorgeous body of work…

ROM > ALY > DWAS > Flowers