Jump to content

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page


Recommended Posts

Posted

I forgot how good Birch was :jonnycat:

  • Like 2

  • Replies 10k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Brooklyn Baby

    1241

  • wastedpotential

    837

  • Dear Reader

    463

  • Klein

    375

Posted

Oh, here we again... looks like we'll have to suffer another TS related ranking, courtesy of this site's tragic taste, well generally speaking since the majority usually overpowers the few ones that actually taste... the last discography rate was really fun but the results were disastrous, hopefully these rules can help a little to counter the inevitable exaggerated scores to the usual overrated songs, same applies to the over-hated ones.

 

Also, considering the remix when rating Lover is offensive to the original song :toofunny2:

  • Haha 3
Posted
5 minutes ago, Michael196 said:

Oh, here we again... looks like we'll have to suffer another TS related ranking, courtesy of this site's tragic taste, well generally speaking since the majority usually overpowers the few ones that actually taste... the last discography rate was really fun but the results were disastrous, hopefully these rules can help a little to counter the inevitable exaggerated scores to the usual overrated songs, same applies to the over-hated ones.

 

Also, considering the remix when rating Lover is offensive to the original song :toofunny2:

I included it there just for consistency when combining songs/remixes. Nobody is actually gonna rank the Lover remix and Karma ft. Ice Spice above the originals I fear. :dies:

 

:suburban:

Posted
15 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

I included it there just for consistency when combining songs/remixes. Nobody is actually gonna rank the Lover remix and Karma ft. Ice Spice above the originals I fear. :dies:

 

:suburban:

Lol yeah I know, but a certain someone will definitely do it :dies:

 

Sparks_Fly_-_Single.png

  • Haha 4
Posted

looks like i like midnights now? however bad the end results are, the work on this rate has been fun and surprising already

  • Haha 1
Posted

Update- knocked out 4 albums today. As A plot twist: folklore got a higher score than I thought it would, some songs really grew on me even after four years. It actually went up my ranking of her albums.

Posted

I will definitely be participating. Guess I'll finally have a reason to listen to TTPD. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Time to start :jonny: Streaming SPEAK NOW (OG) FIRST

  • Like 2
Posted (edited)

Debut got 6.2 average after my initial ranking (rep got 8.9:deadbanana4: but ill revisit after i've done all the scores)
i noticed that  half the tracklist got  >7.5 (one 10 even) and the other half got <6
so the 6.2 average makes sense its not a bad album just really inconsistent.. if she cut the fat and put some of the unreleased tracks that clear them on it (like I'd Lie for example.. BIG hopes for the debut vault) it could have been way better

Next up: Midnights :suburban: trying to alternate between listening to her older and newer work

Edited by TaylenaStan
Posted

But we need @WeFoundWill to participate!

Posted (edited)
On 8/2/2024 at 12:11 AM, Forever Winter said:

I included it there just for consistency when combining songs/remixes. Nobody is actually gonna rank the Lover remix and Karma ft. Ice Spice above the originals I fear. :dies:

 

:suburban:

 

On 8/2/2024 at 12:29 AM, Michael196 said:

Lol yeah I know, but a certain someone will definitely do it :dies:

 

Sparks_Fly_-_Single.png

@Magickarp you know what to do sis! Support Shawn today. :clap3:
 

We both know Lover is a 0 without H.I.M. :clap3:

Edited by Taylor fanboy
  • Haha 3
Posted
1 minute ago, Taylor fanboy said:

But we need @WeFoundWill to participate!

I might :bird:

  • Like 2
Posted

Hey guys, make sure to leave comments for songs. It can be praises or drags, anything. There are a few so far but not enough :giraffe:

Posted

well i guess its time i gave TTPD a listen after all...

  • Haha 1
Posted

This is totally rearranging my personal discography ranking. My list was pretty outdated anyway :laugh:

  • Haha 1
Posted

Can we finally knock cardigan and Enchanted out of the Top 2?!?!

Posted
4 hours ago, Tusk said:

Can we finally knock cardigan and Enchanted out of the Top 2?!?!

 

Posted (edited)

Finally finished scoring the Big Machine albums :gaycat4:

 

Spoiler

Genesis - 7.3

Flawless - 8.3

Sermons Now - 8.8

Redemption - 8.4

Swift 19:89 - 8.0

Resurreputation - 7.2 

 

:ryan3:

 

At first I got mad at myself for having really high scores (an order of magnitude higher than my last ballot for the last rate), but then I realized I literally stan this woman, and artificially scoring songs lower than they deserve for the sake of objectivity serves no one except the puta losers who will find a way to sabotage everything else :gaycat4:

 

Spoiler

idk how much y'all care, but so far SN is the album with the most 9< scores (13 of them nnn) and Rep is the album with the most 5> scores with 3 :gaycat4:

 

Spoiler

I've tried to distribute my 0s and 11s so there isn't more than 1 of each per album, but as of right now there's only one album with both

 

Spoiler

Take a guess which one that might be nnn, it's apparently known for having very high highs and very low lows:gaylorcat1:

 

 

 

 

Edited by wastedpotential
  • Like 1
Posted

This looks fun! Add me on the ping list! I will try to finish it in time thanks!

  • Like 1
Posted
43 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Finally finished scoring the Big Machine albums :gaycat4:

 

  Hide contents

Genesis - 7.3

Flawless - 8.3

Sermons Now - 8.8

Redemption - 8.4

Swift 19:89 - 8.0

Resurreputation - 7.2 

 

:ryan3:

 

At first I got mad at myself for having really high scores (an order of magnitude higher than my last ballot for the last rate), but then I realized I literally stan this woman, and artificially scoring songs lower than they deserve for the sake of objectivity serves no one except the puta losers who will find a way to sabotage everything else :gaycat4:

 

  Reveal hidden contents

idk how much y'all care, but so far SN is the album with the most 9< scores (13 of them nnn) and Rep is the album with the most 5> scores with 3 :gaycat4:

 

  Reveal hidden contents

I've tried to distribute my 0s and 11s so there isn't more than 1 of each per album, but as of right now there's only one album with both

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Take a guess which one that might be nnn, it's apparently known for having very high highs and very low lows:gaylorcat1:

 

 

 

 

So excited to see your Lover average :jonnycat:

  • Haha 1
Posted

I promise you'll have it 

Posted
On 7/29/2024 at 10:25 PM, Forever Winter said:

Pinglists

 

Master Pinglist

  Hide contents

@1989 @PoisonedIvy @Klein @State of Grace. @Badgalbriel @The Music Industry @Heldenzeit @fridayteenage @Dear Reader @wastedpotential @FolkLover1989 @Folklore89sm @Cruel Summer @Goaty @taylor__fan @Enrique523 @vale9001 @Kyle-x @Popboi. @Saint James @MidnightsAtPeace @Gladiator @Feanor @Ms. Togekiss @pinkbowvintage @Great Username @Lille @LostInStereo100 @Cleanromantic @Michael196 @MardinBeksloy @Tusk @cruelhprince @RideOrDie @YR. @Buffy @PrismaticOwen @Chris @OnlyManInTheWorld @Taylor fanboy @KatyPrismSpirit @Starchild @By the Water @Raphy23 @skizzo @19SLAYty9 @Squall @mael @Bosque @Save-Me-Oprah @YellowRibbon @Peroxide @Prismee @AndThenTheCocaine @Timeless @IBeMe @Achilles. @Fama @gagacasanova @G.U.Y. Gaga @drivers license  @UnusualBoy @Taylor Sniffs @idkwiam @4Real @DesiredConsternation @Kavish @Soobin @Bussea @greento @KillingYourCareer @SleepingTigers @Velvet Night @byzantium @AbeHicks @RihannaLoverrr @Holy Ground @Taylena @TaylenaStan @TayDuaStan @Hunter_13 @Shendelzare @Lorenzo22 @feelslikeadream @Rev8 @TheArgonaut @Jaay @Fifteen @Mr. Duff @doonerr @P!NK2LOVE @xfreshkidxx @inshadesofcool @Indie Go Mind @GreatestLoveofAll @creativity. @Ayanaa @JoeAg @Sanguine @Legend E @Quicksand @ChrisTheLoner @Walk_Away21 @wehavetostan @MissedTheTrain @bluebirdsforever @Juánny @woohoo @Bloo @Ryan @burninredhot @KeshaSwift @Miss Americana @Trent W @ariananext @305 @blown away @NEX @Maroonx @Sabrina Carpenter @badidearight @Strawberry Bubble @Kimi @Safe&Sound @enchanted0 @aesthetic bih @My Tears Ricochet @rebeltwat @terrorblade @LoveInStereo @dussel_06 @Kyungsoowift @Riverbank @diemoehre @Clauss @Flower @llikeh @Arrows @Avrileon @Teen Spirit @CamiloPg_ @sanzo @Live To Tell @a_d_22 @Solaria @NordicGuy @SylMacPer @tb6591 @?????? @Namigo @WeFoundWill @ithinkheknowsoutsold @makeawish @Yog @Mocha @jacklovesyou1 @halcyonday @Mezik @Edge Of Glory @PaloSanto @nostalgic @AdrianNicki @modern thing @holyground13 @Hurem @yourfaveisaflop @Wonbin @Taemira @roso @Alldeezy @djcalpal @Vixen Eyes @Doogle @TMRA @frankvert @Virgos Groove @BlackAura @Britney Jean @TaggedGalaxy @Bad News @olivethetree @taylorrrr @TaylorNation @KOMH @SoulKiwi @skwonderfactory @FlyOnTheWall @mercurialworld @Pheromosa @Frogger17 @Carrie-is-no-1 @Rep2000 @Theluckyone @UNNAMI @alestevens @NoOneDiesFromLove @Jude @Vespertine @Miss Fortune@houndsoflove @Life Savers @Magickarp @Danial @Ramona16 @VeniceBeach @sleepevaded @oceans @Gam @romas_ld@MusicLoverDude @kyoshi @PurrKaty @every1blinks @Mellark @Lemon @Starkboy @pavi @BeenTheShit @KnightOfAllRealms @Finkypop @Lightbringer007 @Maroon legacy @chiliam @Sailor Moon @LovaticSwiftie @folkloreking @Hitchhiker @Sweeftie13 @itsjem @siegetheday @dreamofyou @Saintlor @HappierJealousy @greeneyedsoul @queenoftheclouds @Nico Robin @Bonicap @Mandalore @cruelcooper @cat1867 @BabyBenzz @HBK-79 @touch @2NE1 @Underdogs @Better Mistakes @Monster Queen @Arcade ring

Incomplete/No Submissions

  Reveal hidden contents

@PoisonedIvy @Klein @State of Grace. @Badgalbriel @Heldenzeit @fridayteenage @Dear Reader @wastedpotential @FolkLover1989 @Folklore89sm @Cruel Summer @Goaty @taylor__fan @Enrique523 @vale9001 @Kyle-x @Popboi. @Saint James @Gladiator @Feanor @Ms. Togekiss @Great Username @Lille @LostInStereo100 @Cleanromantic @Michael196 @MardinBeksloy @cruelhprince @RideOrDie @YR. @Buffy @PrismaticOwen @Chris @OnlyManInTheWorld @Taylor fanboy @KatyPrismSpirit @Starchild @By the Water @Raphy23 @19SLAYty9 @Squall @mael @Bosque @Save-Me-Oprah @YellowRibbon @Prismee @AndThenTheCocaine @Timeless @IBeMe @Achilles. @Fama @gagacasanova @G.U.Y. Gaga @UnusualBoy @Taylor Sniffs @idkwiam @DesiredConsternation @Kavish @drivers license @Bussea @SleepingTigers @Velvet Night @byzantium @AbeHicks  @RihannaLoverrr @Holy Ground @Taylena @TaylenaStan @TayDuaStan @Hunter_13 @Shendelzare @Lorenzo22 @feelslikeadream @Rev8 @TheArgonaut @Jaay @Fifteen @Mr. Duff @doonerr @P!NK2LOVE @xfreshkidxx @inshadesofcool @Indie Go Mind @GreatestLoveofAll @creativity. @Ayanaa @JoeAg @Sanguine @Legend E @Quicksand @ChrisTheLoner @Walk_Away21 @wehavetostan @MissedTheTrain @bluebirdsforever @Juánny @woohoo @Bloo @Ryan @burninredhot @KeshaSwift @Miss Americana @Trent W @ariananext @blown away @Maroonx  @Sabrina Carpenter @badidearight @Strawberry Bubble @Kimi @Safe&Sound @enchanted0 @aesthetic bih @My Tears Ricochet @rebeltwat @LoveInStereo @dussel_06  @Kyungsoowift @Nein @diemoehre @Clauss @Flower @WeFoundWill @makeawish @Yog @Mocha @jacklovesyou1 @halcyonday @Mezik @Edge Of Glory @nostalgic @AdrianNicki @modern thing @holyground13 @Hurem @yourfaveisaflop @Wonbin @Taemira @roso @Alldeezy @djcalpal @Vixen Eyes @Doogle @TMRA @frankvert @Virgos Groove @BlackAura @Britney Jean @TaggedGalaxy @Bad News @olivethetree @taylorrrr @TaylorNation @KOMH @SoulKiwi @skwonderfactory @FlyOnTheWall @mercurialworld @Pheromosa @Frogger17 @Carrie-is-no-1  @Rep2000 @Theluckyone @UNNAMI @alestevens @NoOneDiesFromLove @Jude @Vespertine @Miss Fortune @houndsoflove @Life Savers @Magickarp @Danial @Ramona16 @VeniceBeach @sleepevaded @oceans @Gam @romas_ld @MusicLoverDude @kyoshi @PurrKaty @every1blinks @Mellark @Lemon @Starkboy @pavi @BeenTheShit @KnightOfAllRealms @Finkypop @Lightbringer007 @Maroon legacy @chiliam @Sailor Moon @LovaticSwiftie @folkloreking @Hitchhiker @Sweeftie13 @itsjem @siegetheday @dreamofyou @Saintlor @HappierJealousy @greeneyedsoul @queenoftheclouds @Nico Robin @Bonicap @Mandalore @cruelcooper @cat1867 @BabyBenzz @HBK-79 @touch @2NE1 @Underdogs @Better Mistakes @Monster Queen @Arcade ring

Please let me know if you'd like to be added to/removed from the pinglists. I will send weekly reminders for you all to complete your ballots.

 

 

I have decided against partaking in this rate. I would be very grateful if you removed me from the pinglist.

Posted
40 minutes ago, Yog said:

I promise you'll have it 

 

1 minute ago, ithinkheknowsoutsold said:

I have decided against partaking in this rate. I would be very grateful if you removed me from the pinglist.

Omg I was editing the pinglist and didn't realise it notifies if it's edited. Sorry besties! 

 

And yes @ithinkheknowsoutsold I'll remove you.

  • Like 1
Posted
8 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Omg I was editing the pinglist and didn't realise it notifies if it's edited. Sorry besties! 

 

And yes @ithinkheknowsoutsold I'll remove you.

No worries, thank you!

Posted

I'm in. THEE Peak Now will prevail :clap3:

  • Like 2
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.