🧐

Because it didn't.

Seems to be doing better than some of the most recent Millennial pop girl acts' latest albums (from 2018):

In the United States, Liberation debuted at number six on the Billboard 200 chart, selling 68,000 album-equivalent units (62,000 in album sales), becoming Aguilera's second lowest-peaking and lowest-selling record in the United States. In the second week, it fell 90 positions to 96 with sales of approximately 3,000 copies, a 95% drop compared to the first week

She did outsell recent-ish tour bundle assisted liberated albums' entire runs with her first week alone, there's that.

Please seek treatment

You're the flop.

didn't she outsell most of the pop girls with her first week? would hardly call a top 3 debut a flop

No Legend X collab

It didn't flop. Hope that helps!

latina excellence xtina wins i fear

You can barely make a thread without causing some ego trauma

It's actually smashing for Hilary's standards. Some girls haven't experienced smashing since the iPhone was invented.

Hilary is an actress and artist last singing was never serious for her.

DMF hates to see a blonde, non-vocalist, 2000s pop girl coming

That user is a troll

you wish it flopped miss dmf

I mean I am pretty sure we all expected it to have no longevity and tank immediately after the first week

She did the kind of first week numbers some millennial acts dream of achieving these days so I'm not sure where the flop is?

Oh! Found her:

A nerve was struck

Did Hilary Duff piss you off... or something?

leave xtina alone

Luck or something week 1: 84k, BB200 peak #3

AGUILERA total: 4k, BB200 peak N/A

Let's do the math:

84k - 4k =80k more or 2000% more

3 - N/A = Undefined