m

15 minutes ago, Starkboy said:

You all will say anything huh

I say what I see

For an EP called Wild this is pretty tame. Dream scenario is that they take a break after this tour, somehow get Manon to agree to rejoin, and give us something that isn't pandering to tweens.

UnloveU is cute though, here for them letting the girls have more input in their sound

1 minute ago, punisher said:

idk why people want them to do vocal-heavy songs… it just doesn't resonate if they can't sing about individual experiences, and their vocal skills are very overrated

like they need to keep making bops and stop trying ballads

Never said anything about ballads, but they're very flavorless as vocalists anyway

44 minutes ago, ThousandMiles said:

the team behind Katseye is truly the worst in the business, my god.. it's like every move this group makes works against them, and it's so obvious?? like at this point i'm convinced it's some sort of self-sabotage going on behind the scenes

The EP is absolute garbage, pinky up being the only listenable hit, even though it's hated by many, the other 4 (laughable amount) songs are so bad it's beyond me they took 4 months after announcing this EP to release this trash

Sophia obviously left because she was too embarassed to be associated with this and petrified of the inevitable lashings they're about to receive. Just disband for the love of God.

They're actually good in the sense that this is a girl group for kids, like 10–12-year-old girls. It's very juvenile

4 hours ago, GRETCHEN said:

They're so mediocre, seriously. The A&R work here is basically nonexistent, they're just passing around bad, dated, old demos

And vocally, they don't help either. Their voices are extremely basic and generic

Pinky Up is kind of a serve. I like the Hootie Frootie video. But you are so right, they're just one big product placement for Hybe, and music comes last

31 minutes ago, GRETCHEN said:

Never said anything about ballads, but they're very flavorless as vocalists anyway

yeah i was expanding on what you said with my personal opinion

Bel Air & That Way are great Give us those generic pop bops iktr

Bel Air's production wasn't what I thought it would be based on one of the Charli mixes I heard. Thought it would be one of the upbeat ones

this is def their best EP overall but they're still struggling to find a sound

I actually like their take on Bel Air, also really liked That Way even tho they're blatantly trying to make us think it was a Pharrell production

ops its bad

EP OF THE YEAR FOR ME

I mean I agree with some of the sentiments about the music itself. But I personally still can't get over the cover of the EP. The "Let me talk to the manager" wigs while releasing visuals like Pinky Up and Hootie Frutti. The Wild World photo is so much better

Already selling more physicals than some girls' first week sales

The EP is ALL OVER THE PLACE 😂

It might be for me the first time I've seen someone to struggle so much to have an identity

Having that said i prefer pinky and Hotie than the EXTREMELY generic and boring Animal and That Way . Bel Air floats somewhere in the middle

1 minute ago, shark_heather said:

Having that said i prefer pinky and Hotie than the EXTREMELY generic and boring Animal and That Way . Bel Air floats somewhere in the middle

Listen to unloveu

The cover is giving Doll Domination (Mini EP) just that the PCD one was iconic with better songs:

Anyway I was excited for the EP because I really like Pinky Up… but it was a letdown.

The only other fun is Hootie Coochie or whatever and it doesn't have that spark, besides that they sound bored in Animal; and Bel Air sounds like a demo and like it was the slo-mo base of Rihanna's 'Who's That chick'; That Way is just there.

I think they also need a cute ballad here and there, the Spice Girls and PCD had great ones and it gives more depth and flexibility to their music, Katseye needs to find a good producer or something because they feel aimless.

3 hours ago, chris1991 said:

But you are so right, they're just one big product placement for Hybe, and music comes last

As opposed to the rest of k-pop that is done for art and art only

It's unreal they are still releasing EP's.

I've been a pop fan over 25 years and have never seen a girl group mismanaged this bad tbh.

16 minutes ago, Vorfreude said:

It's unreal they are still releasing EP's.

I've been a pop fan over 25 years and have never seen a girl group mismanaged this bad tbh.

Is the mismanaged in the room with us? They're selling out arenas in major parts of the globe and have had huge global hits. Some girls would wish to be in their position

Just now, The Prophecy said:

Is the mismanaged in the room with us? They're selling out arenas in major parts of the globe and have had huge global hits. Some girls would wish to be in their position

Girl, this group has been in the industry for like what, 3 years? They've had multiple worldwide smash hits. At this point, you gotta release an album, not EP's.

I stan for them but something is ain't right. It's obvious.

3 minutes ago, Vorfreude said:

Girl, this group has been in the industry for like what, 3 years? They've had multiple worldwide smash hits. At this point, you gotta release an album, not EP's.

I stan for them but something is ain't right. It's obvious.

I mean, they're a k-pop adjacent group This is a pretty common thing.

Yeah in the end they signed up for KPOP; long days and short eras.

However with all of the succes I would have thought they would pivot more.

Overall a solid EP. I do like that they are creating a signature sound.

Hootie fruit, fruit, fruit, fruit, fruit, fruit, FRUIT

PINKY UP and her brazilian sisterrrrr

Hate that Charli's original lyrics were changed so much…