Genuinely surprised she is doing Charli XCX/Gracie Abrams numbers on Spotify.

11 minutes ago, Lord Vetinari said:

Genuinely surprised she is doing Charli XCX/Gracie Abrams numbers on Spotify.

This is actually incredible. Like Music, Fashion, Film did 10.5m...

the outro of Liberty Tree is the definition of perfection

I think Bobby is my favourite

STUNNING

Haunted turns out to be my favorite. So beautiful

Maybe I'm in a different place mentally, or maybe it's a weaker album, but this album doesn't have much of a hold on me.

There are a few tracks I'll definitely keep in rotation though.

Haunted is such a dud, that one and Lost Boys are so cheesy

I feel like this is gonna one of those West End Girl albums that I try to listen to because of the acclaim but it's simply just not for me

Given, I haven't even started the album besides the first song so I will report back. I can appreciate the Imogen Heap vibes from the first track at least

Beautiful immaculate timeless album on arrival

This has replaced Sweet Fortune as my AOTY. Even Lost Boys feels euphoric when you loop back to the beginning.

Shame she is losing the #1 spot to a children's album.

It's kinda funny but I don't want to listen this masterpiece everyday. How can I say it? Like, I don't wanna consume it every day? Will never ever forget my first listen. Full body chills.

You may say I'm exaggerating but yeah.

On 8/16/2026 at 9:28 AM, Rotunda said:

Maybe I'm in a different place mentally, or maybe it's a weaker album, but this album doesn't have much of a hold on me.

There are a few tracks I'll definitely keep in rotation though.

I feel the exact same way.

Liberty Tree is about a mall very close to where I grew up and is very niche and that's lowkey my fav part of the album lmao.

I'm so obsessed. As Above, Still Standing and Other Plans are my trinity but Lost Boys, Kill Me, Lost Weekend, Lost Weekend (Reprise) and Liberty Tree are not far behind. The whole thing gets better with each listen

Kill Me is a SOTY contender

I just can't stop listening to this the run from Kill Me to Still Standing is knockout after knockout, and then the last three being emotional devastaters

Edited August 18Aug 18 by Redstreak

On 8/16/2026 at 11:00 AM, shookspeare said:

Haunted is such a dud, that one and Lost Boys are so cheesy

omg WHAAAAAT im obsessed with that one!! the ending makes me so emotional when she says "you wont have to open, a heart that's broken, waters gonna flow in, either way, my heart is growing either way" so so good

Bobby is such a banger

This is one of those special albums that makes me love music and writing so much. It inspired such an insane, existential feelings in me, I have been injecting it into my blood, listening all day every day, driving, on the train or bus, walking, working (when I can get away with it), before going to bed, when I wake up in the morning, etc.

It's an AOTD contender for me, even an AOTC tbh. She's been a favourite of mine since I discovered Punisher, that album serving a very special purpose for me for many years, but this is something else entirely.

I've only felt this way about a very select few albums in my life, Lux by Rosalia, Javelin by Sufjan Stevens, and Melodrama by Lorde. Just an all-encompassing record that I'm so grateful to have the privilege of experiencing in real time.

Thank you Phoebe xx

It's so hard to determine if I prefer Punisher or Lost Weekend.

On the one hand, Lost Weekend is so solid as a full album. I basically only listen to it from start to finish, never individual songs.

On the other hand, no song on LW is as strong as Moon Song.

She really outdid herself with this one. Can't remember the last time I was this touched by an album

Bobby is such a grower for me. First listen I definitely didn't think of it that much but it really stands out as I listen to this album more.

so boring, I'm struggling to get through it I've always found her quite mid outside of a few songs but she literally sounds bored on this album fff

Still AOTY and As Above is still SOTY oh to think a month ago I almost cried in front of my classmates when listening to As Above for the first time