Seated for the mess this thread will be!

Walking on Air is better than anything that try hard Charli put out, so yes there is a difference. Katy is better.

and yet I can't name even one similarity 

I'm really sorry for your loss (of hearing)

Quote

Surprised?

I would say so... I've only heard the 143 singles and they sound nothing like anything on brat.

Can we get examples of how it is apparently the same album? 

Great synths, beautiful synths

delete @katara it's for your well-being

Let me find one...

 

 

Oh! There it is

Considering that the difference between Brat's and 143's MC scores is higher than the total MC score of Smile I'd beg to differ

You've said this twice already in the Metacritic thread, diva. Here's my lovely response if you missed it. Hope it helps.

 

 

Praying for your lack of taste.

Lots of difference, but one similarity.

Brat, I'm sorry.

143: I couldn't even be her if I tried. I'm opposite I'm on the other side.

 

Edited September 20, 20242 yr by Contessa

True

 

The only sonic similarities present are because Dr Who attempts a few anemic impersonations of AG with the production on a few of these songs and couldn't pull it off at all. Where a song like Gone by Charli sounds massive & energetic, 143 sounds flat & dull. Lyrically, brat's detailed, personal, specific, passionate. 143 fr reads like char GPT! I imagine Charli seeing this would feel like when an ugly person calls you twin

 

 

Even if you inversed the score of brat it would be almost a whole 25 points higher

I see the similarities in that they're both cartoony attempts at making music for the gaze

Instead of turning another fandom against Katy, you should give the album a few listens, She needs them.