Which purple-themed album that starts with the letter S is better? 

 

While we're at it let's do a track by track comparison:

 

Mine vs brutal

Sparks Fly vs traitor

Back to December vs drivers license

Speak Now vs 1 step forward, 3 steps back

Dear John vs deja vu

Mean vs Good 4 U

The Story of Us vs enough for you

Never Grow Up vs happier

Enchanted/Better Than Revenge vs jealousy, jealousy

Innocent/Haunted vs favorite crime

Last Kiss/Long Live vs hope ur ok

Peak Now sweetie..

Self-written one. 

Enchanted >> Sour. 

Mine vs brutal

Sparks Fly vs traitor

Back to December vs drivers license

Speak Now vs 1 step forward, 3 steps back

Dear John vs deja vu

Mean vs Good 4 U

The Story of Us vs enough for you

Never Grow Up vs happier

Enchanted/Better Than Revenge vs jealousy, jealousy

Innocent/Haunted vs favorite crime

Last Kiss/Long Live vs hope ur ok

 

now when you put cute next to gorgeous.. tbf this was tayLord’s 3rd attempt and at this point she truly had a persona and things to say and respond to and she encapsulated it all perfectly on this record - enchanted or speak now as the album title, she couldn’t go wrong- the album was her speaking singularly and candidly, embracing wholeheartedly the naive fairy tale dreamy young girl persona and camping it up even more, upping the dramatics and the stakes and not missing a beat! ugh, if olivia can manage to draw upon even a fraction of such excellence for her third effort…

Sour

I've always found SN as overrated

Mine vs brutal

Sparks Fly vs traitor

Back to December vs drivers license

Speak Now vs 1 step forward, 3 steps back

Dear John vs deja vu

Mean vs Good 4 U

The Story of Us vs enough for you

Never Grow Up vs happier

Enchanted/Better Than Revenge vs jealousy, jealousy

Innocent/Haunted vs favorite crime

Last Kiss/Long Live vs hope ur ok

 

Peak Now wins

Speak Now for all.

Mine			brutal
Sparks Fly			traitor
Back to December			drivers license
Speak Now			1 step forward, 3 steps back
Dear John			deja vu
Mean			Good 4 U
The Story of Us			enough for you
Never Grow Up			happier
Enchanted/Better Than Revenge			jealousy, jealousy
Innocent/Haunted			favorite crime
Last Kiss/Long Live			hope ur ok

Mine vs brutal

Sparks Fly vs traitor

Back to December vs drivers license

Speak Now vs 1 step forward, 3 steps back

Dear John vs deja vu

Mean vs Good 4 U

The Story of Us vs enough for you

Never Grow Up vs happier

Enchanted/Better Than Revenge vs jealousy, jealousy

Innocent/Haunted vs favorite crime

Last Kiss/Long Live vs hope ur ok

 

I like both albums but Peak Now is the superior album

Speak Now

 

Mine vs brutal

Sparks Fly vs traitor

Back to December vs drivers license

Speak Now vs 1 step forward, 3 steps back

Dear John vs deja vu

Mean vs Good 4 U

The Story of Us vs enough for you

Never Grow Up vs happier

Enchanted/Better Than Revenge vs jealousy, jealousy

Innocent/Haunted vs favorite crime

Last Kiss/Long Live vs hope ur ok

 

Landslide…

Mine vs brutal

Sparks Fly vs traitor

Back to December vs drivers license

Speak Now vs 1 step forward, 3 steps back

Dear John vs deja vu

Mean vs Good 4 U

The Story of Us vs enough for you

Never Grow Up vs happier

Enchanted/Better Than Revenge vs jealousy, jealousy

Innocent/Haunted vs favorite crime

Last Kiss/Long Live vs hope ur ok

SOUR. Speak Now is overrated

Mine vs brutal

Sparks Fly vs traitor

Back to December vs drivers license

Speak Now vs 1 step forward, 3 steps back

Dear John vs deja vu

Mean vs Good 4 U

The Story of Us vs enough for you

Never Grow Up vs happier

Enchanted/Better Than Revenge vs jealousy, jealousy (it's close tho)

Innocent/Haunted vs favorite crime

Last Kiss/Long Live vs hope ur ok

Speak Now. SOUR is overrated.

 

 

This one will be studied as one of the finest pop/country/rock/alternative songs of all time, and how it was possible to create a genre of your own, in a single song.

I love SOUR, but Sparks Fly alone is enough to make SN a better album 

Speak Now sweetie..

Mine vs brutal

Sparks Fly vs traitor

Back to December vs drivers license

Speak Now vs 1 step forward, 3 steps back

Dear John vs deja vu

Mean vs Good 4 U

The Story of Us vs enough for you

Never Grow Up vs happier

Enchanted/Better Than Revenge vs jealousy, jealousy

Innocent/Haunted vs favorite crime

Last Kiss/Long Live vs hope ur ok

ones awful while the other isnt

 

I can’t decide.  I love them both.  Probably Speak Now, but I am not sure Olivia can handle more rejection.  

I'm sorry but enchanted alone > sour

Haunted alone obliterates all

 

Speak Now but this comparison makes no sense 

4 hours ago, Envy said:

Mine			brutal
Sparks Fly			traitor
Back to December			drivers license
Speak Now			1 step forward, 3 steps back
Dear John			deja vu
Mean			Good 4 U
The Story of Us			enough for you
Never Grow Up			happier
Enchanted/Better Than Revenge			jealousy, jealousy
Innocent/Haunted			favorite crime
Last Kiss/Long Live			hope ur ok

Cutting literally just Dear John . . . you're sick!