By the Water

8M in a few months then another 4M in 12 years?

143 managed to double its first week sales so I guess it's a bigger success

Liddos pretending they weren't gagging at The Dud Dance's numbers before it started to free fall Day 9: Elizabeth Taylor - #4 - 6,709,544 (Saturday) Abracadabra - #9 - 6,269,827 (Tuesday) Disease - #48 - 2,249,424

The coke rant. Y'all started the comparison and now can't handle it. And it's funny coming from the fanbase that's constantly comparing their fave to Katy Perry to cope with the fact that no one cares about solo Ga Ga songs in 2026

Hive, liddos and Kats seem pretty adamant about calling this a flop. Let's see if things change when those leads drop

Patient Zero (Day 9): #2 - 4,032,462 (Saturday) The Dead Dance (Day 9): #14 - 3,142,795 (Thursday) The Dead Dance second Saturday: #30 (-15) - 2,523,493 Liddos really can't have **** omg

Is "that's what friends are for" an easter egg?

Biggest first years for female solo songs: BOAF - 2.5B Espresso - 2.1B TFOO - 1.708B Flowers - 1.700B

The concept of Beyoncé and Ga Ga fans trying to call this a flop

After Hours

Debut and 1989

Must be an Olivia thing

No shade, but what does Tinashe know about fame?

So what I'm getting from this thread is that the TS13 lead won't perform better than this. Is that right? It's giving "Red TV is basically a new album, her next studio album won't pull bigger numbers"

Honestly, I don't think there was anything that screams smash on TTPD so Fortnight as a lead is fine

I mean, we all know how fast she moves on from her releases after the first week, so it's not impossible for her to release debut tv next month. And since she already has her masters back, there's no need to make it a big release

Video now on youtube. Available in 4k as well

He's not a hater but he clearly isn't having a discussion

You can read the reactions to Midnight Rain upon release for yourself. And you can't use streams to prove your point while mentioning Question and closure. Besides, people don't mention Question's bridge specifically because the entire song is bad, no one talks about its verses or chorus specifically either. You can keep calling people cupcakes for not blindly agreeing with your nonsense though

Midnight Rain, Question and closure aren't the best examples of songs that aren't/weren't hated

The "only focus on the men" thing is funny considering all the "Travis is a bad muse!!11!!" comments

Indeed, Ga Ga and Mariah wish

All those replies from THOTS and liddos

I can't belive we're not gonna get a MV for the title track. I wish she'd do multiple MVs during release week again like with Midnights

XD