By the Water

He's not a hater but he clearly isn't having a discussion

You can read the reactions to Midnight Rain upon release for yourself. And you can't use streams to prove your point while mentioning Question and closure. Besides, people don't mention Question's bridge specifically because the entire song is bad, no one talks about its verses or chorus specifically either. You can keep calling people cupcakes for not blindly agreeing with your nonsense though

Midnight Rain, Question and closure aren't the best examples of songs that aren't/weren't hated

The "only focus on the men" thing is funny considering all the "Travis is a bad muse!!11!!" comments

Indeed, Ga Ga and Mariah wish

All those replies from THOTS and liddos

I can't belive we're not gonna get a MV for the title track. I wish she'd do multiple MVs during release week again like with Midnights

XD

How would they engagement farm then?

VOTY wins: 1989: 1 Lover: 1 (2 nominations) Midnights: 1 TLOAS: 1 rePUTAtion: 0 (0 nominations)

Ophelia VOTY winner LWYMMD ha revenge

The video really is stunning though. Why couldn't Opalite have something nicer?

We were so close to having no dialogue

The way y'all have been talking as if Debut TV is some sort of acclaim bait

She said she skips RTF but not ED

Is she really gonna make us watch a flop award show for a music video? In 2026?

The way I went to the spotify thread to curse at people for not streaming Pink Clouding but they gave me a reason to drag Ga Ga

Would it really be much better if I said last 8 years?

So the second biggest single from TLOAS will soon surpass Ga Ga's biggest solo hit from the last 15 years?

Honey (least streamed song on TLOAS) - 218,100,129 The Dead Dance - 214,723,444 Patient Zero - 14,877,500 (1 day) Kill For Love - 13,539,090 (1 year)

So Ga Ga's biggest solo hit in the last 15 years is a Patient Zero-sized hit?

Wait, who in here found the ME! thread? I wanted a good cackle but I can't seem to find it

I feel like Aaron still has so much more to give. I feel like this is the best she ever managed to take her country-level songwriting into a pop production. I know we kinda made up our minds about TS13 being country but I was kinda hoping it would be a country-pop mess like Red

I think the last time I read a review was in 2020, maybe I read some Midnights ones but I don't remember. It just felt pointless tbh. There's only so much you can get out of an album after 1 or 2 listens. The discussions we have in here are more much interesting to me and have actually offered me some different perspectives on certain songs.

The concept of Gorgeous and Paper Rings being better than Ophelia and RTF I've even seen people claim that the worst song on Lover is better than the best song on Showgirl Y'all really expect us to take these hyperbolic statements seriously