Which pop icon has the superior discography?

Taylor, easily

‎

Taylor duh! Britney's albums are horrible. Brit doesn't even sing some of her own songs lol.

For me Britney has four standout albums (Oops, ITZ, Blackout, Circus) while Taylor has eight (Speak Now, Red, 1989, reputation, folklore, evermore, Midnights, TTPD) so Taylor

I feel like we have this thread like every 6 months.

Taylor fans will vote for Taylor. Britney fans and OTHs will vote for Britney. There will be some back and forth trying to establish some objective metric and people arguing against those metrics based on "impact and vibe". In the end there will be another 10 page thread.

Britney has far more classics that are embedded in the DNA of pop music.

Overall Taylor. But Blackout is better than any Taylor album.

Taylor , voted for Britney by mistake

I guess Taylor for full albums cuz I'm sure Britney's biggest flaw would probably be lack of "depth" or whatever (never heard a full album of hers) but if we're talking about fun, she clears Taylor in the feel-good bulletproof pop department

Britney's top 5 classics alone torch Taylor's discography

Baby, Oops, Gimme More, Toxic, Circus - the fact they each are from different eras are a testament to how iconic her discography really is

Britney has the bops and the WW classics but she looses because i've never heard Taylor put out something as truly horrible as these... "albums" (?)

2 minutes ago, naval23 said:

Britney's top 5 classics alone torch Taylor's discography

Baby, Oops, Gimme More, Toxic, Circus - the fact they each are from different eras are a testament to how iconic her discography really is

You mean Womanizer instead of circus right ?

even though her last three albums werenʻt great, Taylorʻs is way stronger...

Britney

5 minutes ago, Wewee said:

You mean Womanizer instead of circus right ?

Womanizer is #5 and Circus is #6 but ya either one

Taylor obv, but Britney has the higher peaks

Taylor

britney wins

I love both, but for songs like The Archer and Mirrorball alone, Taylor

17 minutes ago, Alyssa Edwards said:

Britney has the bops and the WW classics but she looses because i've never heard Taylor put out something as truly horrible as these... "albums" (?)

She had limited artistic control over those 2 albums, basically was pushed to release it by her family and management to promote Vegas

Edited December 15, 2025Dec 15 by Gottasadae

Even in the fun bops department Taylor wins

And then she has albums like Red and Evermore.. it isn't close at all

Britney has more iconic classics, but as a whole Taylor's discography is better

1 minute ago, Icarus said:

Even in the fun bops department Taylor wins

terrible day to have eyes (or ears whenever one of those "fun bops" comes on the radio)