11 tracks vs 11 tracks, who wins?

 

 

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

Here For It All wins for me but I love Caution

Caution wins for me but I love here for it all 

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song (tie)

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

Tie! 

Caution

Caution .

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

C: 7

HFIA: 4

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

 

Oh this legend  Could go C&C's way in the future too

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

Caution.

Caution was surprisingly fresh and fun. I don't know if I feel the same about HFIA 

Caution sweetie

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

Caution

Love the singles from HFIA but the rest of the album lacks replay value in comparison 

 

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song 

Caution vs. Type Dangerous (tie)

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

35 minutes ago, conatus said:

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

Caution

OMG choosing Type dangerous over that gorgeous Caution is wild to me

Caution

for now, Caution of course

 

…however! Here for It All has already grown on me a lot and I can see it continuing to grow 

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

so for now, that's 8 vs 4

 

but yeah like I said Here for It All is far more subtle in terms of sound palette so it'll be a grower for everyone for sure  I'm already really loving it 

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

Caution sweetie

Caution for all except vs HFIA title track

From what I've heard so far (Sugar Sweet, Type Dangerous, Jesus I Do are terrible) Caution is miles above HFIA. It's not even comparable.

Caution is actually great.

 

Here For It All is if you asked AI to make a Mariah Carey album. Everything about it is typical core fanbase service and nothing for everybody else to grab onto. Can't believe Gamma had the audacity to claim they aimed for her 20th number one with this record. Mariah's voice is shot beyond salvation too.

 

Edited September 29, 2025Sep 29 by slowednreverb

omg the poll results...

Caution is such a great album that it's hard to be surpassed. But Here For It All is not too bad, better than I expected (after the first two singles)

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

Caution is superior but they're both so good