56 minutes ago, slowednreverb said:

Caution is actually great.

 

Here For It All is if you asked AI to make a Mariah Carey album. Everything about it is typical core fanbase service and nothing for everybody else to grab onto. Can't believe Gamma had the audacity to claim they aimed for her 20th number one with this record. Mariah's voice is shot beyond salvation too.

 

Caution is Mariah Carey on absolute auto pilot like please, all mid tempo r&b tease

 

Here for it all has actually exciting soundscapes

GTFO vs. Mi

 

With You vs. Play This Song

 

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

 

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

 

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

 

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

 

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

 

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

 

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

 

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

 

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

5 vs 6 - i'd say it's very much a tie

The landslide  

Caution 

Caution by a landslide 

22 minutes ago, Melancholy said:

Caution is Mariah Carey on absolute auto pilot like please, all mid tempo r&b tease

 

Here for it all has actually exciting soundscapes

The poll disagrees mwah 💋

GTFO vs. Mi

With You vs. Play This Song

Caution vs. Type Dangerous

A No No vs. Sugar Sweet

The Distance vs. In Your Feelings

Giving Me Life vs. Nothing Is Impossible

One Mo' Gen vs. Confetti & Champagne

8th Grade vs. I Won't Allow It

Stay Long Love You vs. My Love

Portrait vs. Jesus I Do

Runway vs. Here For It All

 

Just now, Clonger said:

Giving Me Life

THIS alone is better than any song on HFIA 

Caution

1 hour ago, Musicmajor said:

omg the poll results...

I mean, is it shocking? Caution is objectively in the upper tier of her discography and HFIA at the bottom (her discography is stellar so impossible standards)

Caution was just an insane album... not one skip  one of her best albums

With You, Giving Me Life, and The Distance are some of her best tracks

2 hours ago, slowednreverb said:

The poll disagrees mwah 💋

Mariah agrees and that's all I care mwah 💋

Edited September 29, 2025Sep 29 by Melancholy