2023 Results (So Far):

 

ATRL VERDICT: WE DISLIKE IT 

Morgan Wallen's "Last Night": 34% LIKE / 66% DISLIKE, 79 VOTES TOTAL

 

We now move on to the #2 song on the Hot 100 YEC of 2023. Miley Cyrus' "Flowers"

 

 

2024 Results:

Spoiler

 

ATRL'S FAVORITE SMASH HIT OF 2024: CHAPPELL ROAN'S "GOOD LUCK, BABE!"

 

 

 

RESULTS OF INDIVIDUAL THREADS >>>

ATRL VERDICT: WE LIKE IT!  (14/20)

SZA's "Saturn": 90% LIKE / 10% DISLIKE, 77 VOTES TOTAL

Chappell Roan's "Good Luck, Babe!": 89% LIKE / 11% DISLIKE, 129 VOTES TOTAL

SZA's "Snooze": 89% LIKE / 11% DISLIKE, 96 VOTES TOTAL

Doja Cat's "Agora Hills": 88% LIKE / 12% DISLIKE, 146 VOTES TOTAL

Zach Bryan's "I Remember Everything (feat. Kacey Musgraves)": 85% LIKE / 15% DISLIKE, 71 VOTES TOTAL

Taylor Swift's "Cruel Summer" 84% LIKE / 16% DISLIKE, 171 VOTES TOTAL

Billie Eilish's "Birds of a Feather": 82% LIKE / 18% DISLIKE, 162 VOTES TOTAL

Sabrina Carpenter's "Espresso": 79% LIKE / 21% DISLIKE, 152 VOTES TOTAL

Tate McRae's "Greedy": 74% LIKE / 26% DISLIKE, 88 VOTES TOTAL

Tommy Richman's "Million Dollar Baby": 70% LIKE / 30% DISLIKE, 73 VOTES TOTAL

Hozier's "Too Sweet": 66% LIKE / 34% DISLIKE, 59 VOTES TOTAL

Kendrick Lamar's "Not Like Us": 65% LIKE / 35% DISLIKE, 104 VOTES TOTAL

Future, Metro Boomin & Kendrick Lamar's "Like That": 58% LIKE / 42% DISLIKE, 53 VOTES TOTAL

Sabrina Carpenter's "Please Please Please": 59% LIKE / 41% DISLIKE, 140 VOTES TOTAL

 

ATRL VERDICT: HUNG 🍆 JURY 50/50 SPLIT) (1/20)

Jack Harlow's "Lovin On Me": 50% LIKE / 50% DISLIKE, 76 VOTES TOTAL

 

ATRL VERDICT: WE DISLIKE IT  

Benson Boone's "Beautiful Things": 31% LIKE / 69% DISLIKE, 162 VOTES TOTAL

Teddy Swims' "Lose Control": 43% LIKE / 57% DISLIKE, 86 VOTES TOTAL

Post Malone's "I Had Some Help (feat. Morgan Wallen)": 44% LIKE / 56% DISLIKE, 88 VOTES TOTAL

Shaboozey's "A Bar Song (Tipsy)": 46% LIKE / 54% DISLIKE, 103 VOTES TOTAL

Noah Kahan's "Stick Season": 49% LIKE / 51% DISLIKE, 88 VOTES TOTAL

 

I started liking it much more once I quit my night shift retail job.

Heavy dislike.

I never put it on myself but I enjoy it if it's on the radio or whatever. 

Overplayed as hell but I don't think it's a bad song. Like!

Strongly despise, it's so boring and bland. 

And hate how this is her most recent smash considering all hit worthy songs in PH. 

It's cute, but it's far from her best work

Yeah it's overplayed but it's also overhated. It's just a cute breezy bop that's nice to hear on a summer day.

Out of all the amazing tracks she has, I'm shocked this is the one that impacted charts and the GP so heavily. Probably one of my least favorite modern Miley tracks.

 

 

Edited August 2, 20251 yr by Cole

i hate it with a passion. Its just like Happy or Dance Money for me. always did btw even on day 1 before it got overplayed.

river & jaded deserved! 2 great pop songs, she delivered. 
funny cuz after flowers i also dislike UTBY, so i dislike the 2 hits (flowers smash and utby a cute little hit and i love the 2 flops River and jaded) 

Edited August 2, 20251 yr by Selegend

Everyone knew where they were when this global smash got released! 

 

Breaking Spotify records day by day and week by week, fastest song to cross 1 billion streams, debuting at #1 a few weeks after hosting a New Years Eve special.

 

Then winning a Big 4 Grammy - talent won here! 

like this easily . my favorite Miley song and one of my favorites this decade so far. 

Dislike 

i like it 

Dislike. River deserved Flowers' flowers.

It's a very minimalistic song, but it works. I love the lush disco violins-strings and funky instrumental, and I also love the empowering theme after all those depressive billie-olivia-taylor songs from 2020-2021 


I just want to say that here in my Latino Southamerican country, when I go out, anglo pop girls don't have the same presence anymore. Now it's all about Shak, Bad Bunny, Karol G, Rosalia, Feid, and the local latino urban scenes booming. In the past, it was much more common to hear English-language music and the popgirlies being played by people here...today is harder.

 

But guess what????
Lately, every time I've been out or traveling to different small towns with my family I've heard this song so so many times played by the people or business-radio.  This is honestly the English song I've heard the most in recent years  Thats real globalness.... A realworldwide smash
From a male singer the one  i heard the most is justin bieber STAY


 

My favorite part of this single is the video. I live for glamorous videos shot in big maisons-expensive places
Does anyone here know the location in The L.A Hills? i wanna live in that house

This is definitely one of my favorite songs of the decade  and her redemption after so many years of people downplaying her
i also feel like this song suit well that carefree postpandemic barbie colorful 2023 atmosphere. Before the messy 2025

im sad her new album underperformed but her career path is very strange-variable*
So i just hope she keeps makin cool music and exploring herself*

Edited August 2, 20251 yr by AvadaKedavra

overshadowed the deserving smash hit River 

I like it!

Love it! People hate it only because they're jealous of the massive success of this song. ROTY winner for a reason. 

it's still a fun song

 

nothing wrong with fun songs

An absolute SERVE  One of her best singles

Love this ROTY winner. Instant classic!

not crazy about the song but i like that it was a smash for her, the video is good too

Neutral leaning towards dislike tbh.

Edited August 2, 20251 yr by ChooseyLover

overplayed