Why is this place so dramatic  

Demi's window for the big breakthrough was 2015-2019. She did ok during that time. I don't think a big smash is in the cards, especially solo, but she can still have a solid era, solid tour, solid career etc

Demi has been over commercially since about 2018. It's all been downhill since she dropped her magnum opus Tell Me You Love Me.

Was she ever a thing? 

She was in a chart limbo for years, so expected? the numbers were cute, actually 

she had a solid career from 2008-2020 and who knows this era might pick up steam it's literally only day 1. 

 

all the disney girls are flopping rn 

Unfortunately yes. Her "comeback single" debuting lower than Muddy Feet was not on my bingo card 

 

Idk who she is trying to convince with this brat try hardness but it seems like she's always going through some sort of identity crisis 

Demi never was the big back to back charttopping pop Princess and she just returned after a rock album and a rock re-imagined greatest hits era.

 

Anyone expecting her to smash right after one day of release is really not serious.

 

It would be cute if she gets a top 40/top 20 hit out of this in the end.

Edited August 2, 20251 yr by J-esper

It's just the lead single wait until the second single yall see &nbsp

i don't think so it was just a bad lead single choice. fast should've been a 1 minute interlude or something 

yeah lol

I thought she was over since like 2010 already

ATRL has literally made this thread for her every era now. 

15 minutes ago, 305 said:

Idk who she is trying to convince with this brat try hardness but it seems like she's always going through some sort of identity crisis 

You come in every thread and say the same thing, are you a broken record. Bye 

She just scored her second biggest debut on Spotify, she ain't over.

 

there is still demand for her wether you like it or not

Demi never even started lbr.

They are about to release their tenth album and they are like 34. That doesn't look like "over" to me.

Edited August 2, 20251 yr by ChooseyLover

32 minutes ago, Trip said:

all the disney girls are flopping rn 

Hilary Duff created them all and is coming back to show them how to do an era again. 

 

Ot tho I don't think she's over, that song is just not meant to be a smash. 

 

Idk but Fast is a bop so maybe it'll climb 

she's BEEN done for

20 minutes ago, KBax said:

You come in every thread and say the same thing, are you a broken record. Bye 

And I'll keep saying it

She has the coins, her fans and she's just minding her business, so no. 

Leave her alone.