After listening again I've come to the conclusion that Taylor is clearly still the biggest artist on the planet and even I myself as a stan did too much on it's initial release. All of these tracks are perfectly fine and if she wasn't Taylor they wouldn't cause all of this negative discourse.

My only real criticism at this point is that while the songs are decent they're definitely unnecessary (if that makes sense). However I do appreciate that she attached them to TLOASG instead of holding onto them for TS13 which is a good indication she's planning to switch it up.

Edited 9 hours ago9 hr by dman4life

RED score on metacritic. Whew and she still has to show up to the vmas for that made up award chile

39 on metacritic.. RED.

No grammy wins for Taylor...

7 minutes ago, YR. said:

RED score on metacritic. Whew and she still has to show up to the vmas for that made up award chile

1 minute ago, Plasticdoll said:

39 on metacritic.. RED.

No grammy wins for Taylor...

Nobody cares lmao... truly. Her Metacritic scores have been decreasing since Midnights and yet her popularity is intact. Maybe you can get a more interesting conversation in one of the Reddit snark pages that you likely visit.

TLOAS is filled with songs that will stand the test of time with the fandom.

The Fate of Ophelia, Father Figure, Ruin The Friendship, Wi$h Li$t, Honey, Patient Zero are all unique entries into the catalogue.

Pink Clouding, Babylon are classic Swift deepcuts.

Back to positive news! I hope the CCP lets her do some cute shows in Shanghai for the next tour

4 minutes ago, YellowRibbon said:

Nobody cares lmao... truly. Her Metacritic scores have been decreasing since Midnights and yet her popularity is intact. Maybe you can get a more interesting conversation in one of the Reddit snark pages that you likely visit.

Maybe she can ask the Grammys to make her own award or she wont attend

The 3 new songs are actually good. Damn. Pink Clouding is on repeat today

16 minutes ago, YR. said:

RED score on metacritic. Whew and she still has to show up to the vmas for that made up award chile

when they uninduct her from the songwriters hall of fame after hearing cleveland

A rolling 30-day sample of 674 Pitchfork posts, updated September 25, reveals Pitchfork's median post gets only ~45 interactions. Over the same period, its posts about Taylor Swift received an average of 8,900 interactions, 197x the typical Pitchfork post.

Edited 12 hours ago12 hr by RobynYoBank

50 minutes ago, Calvin said:

That's why I don't take her haters BS seriously.

Her snark page having 1 million visitors per week. What did she do to get such lunatics hate her so much?

I wish people would finally understand that the internet is FAKE. People just like to ride waves but it doesn't correlate to actual life.

Twitter is not real. Tik Tok edits are facades. Reddit users just snark to snark.

15 minutes ago, Plasticdoll said:

39 on metacritic.. RED.

No grammy wins for Taylor...

Swifties were the ones who criticized Katy Perry's 143 the most, and now there's a Taylor album that's going to match it in Metacritic score.

Karma is a cat.

39/100

Why are random haters bringing negativity into the base? The obsession is astonishing

7 minutes ago, ttsmu said:

Swifties were the ones who criticized Katy Perry's 143 the most, and now there's a Taylor album that's going to match it in Metacritic score.

Karma is a cat.

39/100

Babylon alone is 1000 times better than Katy Perry's entire 143 album.

Just now, Calvin said:

Babylon alone is 1000 times better than Katy Perry's entire 143 album.

Like... Cleveland alone is better produced that anything #that woman has done in a whileeee

VMAs and Patient Zero MV tomorrow, so excited!

7 minutes ago, YellowRibbon said:

Why are random haters bringing negativity into the base? The obsession is astonishing

It's Saturday night, they have to do something to entertain themselves!

Hate stream Cleveland for the hundredth time today while you're in here checking up on us, besties

Edited 11 hours ago11 hr by Cruel Summer

@alestevens clocking ATRL

25 minutes ago, RobynYoBank said:

TLOAS is filled with songs that will stand the test of time with the fandom.

The Fate of Ophelia, Father Figure, Ruin The Friendship, Wi$h Li$t, Honey, Patient Zero are all unique entries into the catalogue.

Pink Clouding, Babylon are classic Swift deepcuts.

right, just like her classique least-deserved aoty midnights with 31 songs total racking up, i guess, around 2-3M streams daily.

i dont see how a worse album could stand the test of time, except ophelia since its the only great song and a smash hit. also the fact that without a deluxe, showgirl was streamed like 4 or 5M daily, there's even a thread about it, shows that no, this album won't stand the test.

which is fine, tbh. no discography is perfect.

How do I bribe the CCP into hacking Reddit and taking it down

27 minutes ago, ttsmu said:

Karma is a cat.

39/100

You watch her stans yt channels too? what a ******* loser i can't.

TTPD really deserved AOTY for midnights… midnights AOTY win was just a win for the eras tour

i dont see her winning another until she cleans her act up, because what critics think of her completely does rub off on voters

TTPD standard edition kinda eating up all her other pure pop albums combined when you think about it...

9 minutes ago, anastaciabby said:

You watch her stans yt channels too? what a ******* loser i can't.

it's viral on twitter sweetie. People can't believe the fake gag those girls be doing to Taylors album

2 minutes ago, Cruel Summer said:

TTPD standard edition kinda eating up all her other pure pop albums combined when you think about it...

TTPD standard is brilliant. Never liked Anthology.

That Metarcitic thread, damn 2019 & 2021 fads stans are mad af there, they really thought their fav gonna replace Taylor as the biggest star of this decade.