Both albums are 2 of the most talked about and hyped albums of the year. While one was talked about and hyped upon release, the other has gotten more and more hype as the year has gone on. Which album is bigger? Which one is more impactful? And which one is better?

Edited July 24, 20242 yr by ericcartman

Until Cowboy Carter can dominate a whole season, the answer is going to be BRAT I'm afraid

 

CC is excellent but lbr there are many skips, BRAT on the other hand is all killer no filler. it also saved American democracy

 

This feels like a set up because you know ATRL is going to choose brat and find a way to include a Beyoncè lashing

Brat sweetie...

2 minutes ago, itshyolee said:

This feels like a set up because you know ATRL is going to choose brat and find a way to include a Beyoncè lashing

Well there is a large fanbase that probably dislikes both 

Edited July 24, 20242 yr by ericcartman

Brat is a much stronger body of work

CC for all by far

COWBOY CARTER

brat

brat

 

the fact people voted brat as more commercially successful than CC is actually diabolical.

1. CC

2. brat

3. idk. CC lead way for Shaboozey to get a #1 song in the country by granting him exposure that capitalized on, but now brat is having a cultural resurgence and will possibly play a big role in another countries presidential season.

brat sweetie...

Brat is what atrl thought CC would be. Tjis is what iMpACt truly looks like

I love both, but I think CC takes it. Pretty much everyone I know was talking about CC when it dropped and we've seen many non-country artists now going country + a resurgence of black country artists achieving a commercial boom. By contrast, brat was only discussed among queer people I know until Kamala's campaign highlighted it for the GP. But overall, I think the GP is still more cognizant and impacted by CC. 

Edited July 25, 20242 yr by jakeisphat

Bigger CC

Better Brat

Impact. Tie

As Fox News would say, you just dont understand the essence of brat summer  

 

bigger: Cowboy Carter by default. BRAT may overtake if given enough time.

 

better: BRAT.

 

more impact: BRAT.

 

 

Many albums are bigger, better, and more impactful than Cowshit Carter. 
Brat for all tho!

Cowboy Carter is bigger with 27 songs, although I didn't finish it, so I don't know if that means much.

Brat for all the others.

brat for all and whoever says otherwise is lying 

BRAT for all. Critics and the GP agree, hence BRAT getting its biggest streaming day since release week yesterday

 

Brat has more impact and I prefer it but saying that it's a "bigger" album than Cowboy Carter is just objectively false lol. 

the way it's Brat for all 

 

poor Bey

Well, Brat of course.

5 hours ago, shookspeare said:

CC is excellent but lbr there are many skips, BRAT on the other hand is all killer no filler. it also saved American democracy

 

HOW THE HELL CAN YOU CALL IT EXCELLENT AND THERE ARE TOO MANY SKIPS IN THE SAME TIME?  

 

Are some of you aware that no one is going to kill you when you say something negative about Beyonce?  Especially when she DESERVES?? 
 

——————————

 

Clown carter is one of the worst releases of the year. She was damn edgy and nasty for the "they don't like me because i'm black :( " while being a fkng billionare. 
she doesn't promote the terrible album because it better left unheard because the more people hear it the more hate it would get. 
 

Brat is just genuinely Charlie so it fits her style. Its a good album because she knew what she was doing.