Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
New Music Out Now!!! 🎧💿

Storm653

ATRL Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Storm653

  1. R&B music being significantly more popular in Asia(particularly Japan, Philippines, Taiwan, and South Korea) and Africa than Europe and Latin America is a blind spot for many pop fans and part of the reason why many R&B adjacent artists like Janet and Mariah get downplayed. And, even then, they ironically sold millions more actual CDs in Europe compared to the current MPG girls who get a trillion streams globally and lots of social media followers but their pure sales numbers are terrible compared to the supposed "local" artists of the past decades. Hell, Whitney and Mariah sold MILLIONS MORE CDs in Europe than Britney and Lady Gaga but you will never know this from online discourse. People nowadays judge popularity off of personal anecdotes, Spotify streams, Stan Twitter engagement, and gay bars/clubs than any other metrics.
  2. Okay....I'm going to get slammed for this but I sort of agree with the caveat that I think MJ's performances peaked in the 70's and 80's and declined drastically in the 90's and early 00's. 70's and 80's era MJ definitely lived up to the hype as an all time great performer. But, in the 90's, he was winging it like crazy with the blatant lip syncing, sounding out of tune a good portion of the times where he did sing live, rehashing the exact same moves he did at Motown 25 and the Victory/Bad tours, limiting his 90's set list(the lack of "Remember The Time" was criminal), getting stiffer with his move set, and barely putting much creativity in his production. The HIStory tour in particular just might be one of the most overrated tours in pop history because that's when all the issues I named were amplified but people still praise it because it's MJ. He seemed to be on the path of getting back to perfecting his performances again for the This Is It tour but, sadly, it didn't pan out. But yeah.....give me 70's and 80's MJ any day over the performer he devolved into over time.
  3. It's mainly Monsters or Navy fans that do this(surprisingly, not Swifties too much unless it's a back and forth). But this is why streaming should be considered one of MANY metrics to measure an artist's success. Beyonce has proven to be a major success in the CD era. She may not have a Diamond album or anything but she still sold millions of CDs worldwide and still sold many hard copies in the 2010's with even Lemonade outselling other 2016 albums worldwide according to IFPI Global Recordings Report. Modern stans, however, overvalue streaming success on Spotify and Youtube above all. Even Apple Music isn't considered good enough. All metrics must be factored in though or else you'll get kids treating Janet like a "nobody" while ignoring how she has a Diamond album that hasn't been certified yet and one of the best-selling artists oat in Japan and South Africa.
  4. You can say a similar thing about Prince. The reality is that not all pop stars or legends are destined to have great streaming success. But, regardless, these 2 still sold MILLIONS of physical CDs worldwide in a highly competitive era of music. Streaming didn't really take off until 2015 and it's a very modern phenomenon. Even Madonna's streams, while better, aren't as amazing as you'd expect from the Queen of Pop and I've seen Stan Twitter drag her for that too. But streaming and buying singles/albums digitally is a new phenomenon that's mostly blown up in the last 15 years and you can't really use that ALONE to judge legacy or popularity because it more so reflects how many people 35 and under consume music and how viral older hits stay viral via playlists, ad/movie/TV placements, and Tik Tok algorithms. At the end of the day, touring is probably the best way to gauge success for the relevance of older legends. You can't use MPG standards for everyone while using ONE standard while completely ignoring the standards of physical mediums from their eras. You have to factor in both.
  5. I'm a Madonna fan who enjoys the album a lot but I can somewhat see what you're saying. The album is definitely a "back to the roots" album where she didn't really experiment or try to be polarizing like she did with Madame X. But I think with all the bashing and ageism Madonna goes through, she needed a safe great dance album to get back in people's graces before possibly experimenting more on a future project.
  6. It's not new. A lot of MPGs go through that cycle on the Internet. There was a time where Gaga and Beyonce were getting trashed all the time on pop forums. It was brutal too. The very Stan phrase "pop emergency" originated from pop forums trashing Gaga's Artpop rollout. And, of course, we know how Katy became a punching bag for years to come post Witness.
  7. If we're being real, Drake had a far bigger impact on the sloppification and playlistfication of modern music. When he attached Hotline Bling to Views at the last minute to boost his sales/streams, that was the start of it. And when he was put out that bloated double album in 2018, it was the nail in the coffin. And many mainstream artists tried to copy his formula for streaming success. At least Taylor still made cohesive albums with a central theme even when they were long(TTPD) or bad(Lover, TLOASG).
  8. The real answer is that the Country fandom adjusted to streaming over the years. That's it. They were already a huge market in terms of CD buying and concert attendance but, now, they've gotten used to streaming their faves as well. Morgan Wallen was already smashing during the Biden era so Trump plays no role. Younger Country fans are just using Spotify and Apple like everyone else.
  9. She's going to link up with The Weeknd, Bruno Mars, Ariana Grande, Drake, Morgan Wallen, Justin Bieber, SZA, Bad Bunny, Blackpink, Lil Baby, Playboi Carti, and Ella Langley for the singles for her upcoming country pop-trap album "Mrs. Trudeau."
  10. Not the biggest fan of the song but it's an undeniable hit. Drake will always make the catchiest music in hip hop(as far as male rappers). That's always been for forte.
  11. It was a rather dry year for hits so this doesn't surprise me.
  12. Rihanna is versatile the same way Drake is versatile. I'll leave it at that.
  13. I highly doubt that lol. But this can be said about just about any celebrity tbh. Even Madonna probably has many people irl who view her as an "old hag" or "washed up" even with Confessions 2 out. That doesn't mean she doesn't have many supporters and fans though. Almost every famous celebrity has their share of haters or people indifferent to them. It comes with the territory. But Taylor almost objectively has the biggest fanbase in pop right now. We are past the age of artists having Beatles and pre-Dangerous era MJ level universal love regardless of the artist. Even Beyonce has her share of people who think it's "gay" to listen to her music(straight guys) and people who associate her with the occult or witchcraft(MAGA and Christian types).
  14. Offline, Taylor is very much a well-liked artist and person. At most, people just get tired of the media exposure but that's it. Everything you just said applies to Nicki Minaj and Kanye West more than Taylor lol.
  15. This is false. Many actual witnesses have claimed that the Carters had a strictly business/socialite relationship with Diddy just like every other celebrity.
  16. The tricky thing with Taylor is that her "damaged reputation" and "infamy" is very much a chronically online phenomenon just like with the numerous conspiracies about Beyonce. Overall, all Taylor needs to do is put out a much better album than TLOASG and stay out of the limelight and a lot of the online negativity will dry out very fast. Stan Twitter and OTHs will continue to hate but they'll sound more delusional constantly trashing her all the time. In many ways, pop stars with "polished" images and good PR like Taylor and Beyonce are ESPECIALLY controversial in pop/stan spaces online to the degree where people have to LIE on them to manufacture controversies. Taylor has NEVER publicly supported Trump and Travis is a Liberal yet her haters will label them MAGA and Far Right. Taylor has never been exposed as an actual racist and has stood up for POC many times yet she's casually labeled a vile racist. And she gets far more hate and criticism than Rihanna for being a billionaire capitalist. There's no winning with Stan Twitter types when it comes to Taylor but they don't matter in the grand scheme of things. At the end of the day, Taylor has never flopped to the extent of Katy, Xtina, Lizzo, etc. and her controversies aren't close to being as bad as Nicki's, Chris Brown's, Justin's, Drake's, Kanye's, MIA's, Courtney Love's, Azalea Banks's etc. so there really isn't a true "PR Crisis" with Taylor outside of overexposure tbh.
  17. Honestly, with all the blatant disrespect Madonna was getting from the Moonwalkers especially after the biopic, I can't help but have a smile on my face. Granted, I NEVER disliked Madame X like so many people did. I think people underrated it and wrote it off as a "trendy" album because of the features even though it was still Madonna in her creative zone. But I'm glad Confessions 2 is getting the props it's getting. Now, the Moonwalkers who dragged Madonna should start being honest about their messiah's pre-OTW solo albums and post 80's solo albums before coming for the Queen.
  18. Katy and Xtina are interesting because they had a normal pop cycle of staying hot for 3-4 albums before falling off. However, their inability to hit a new stride or bounce back like many of their peers given their huge peaks is what makes their downfalls feel so tragic. They've tried soooo many times to have a comeback but nothing has worked. Xtina even tried to cling to newer Latin artists for relevance and Katy did a song with Chief Keef and that didn't work. At least Britney bowed out gracefully after Glory flopped and Lorde continued making great music for more niche music fans post Melodrama. Xtina and Katy haven't done either well.
  19. Quiet as kept, Lizzo herself ended up admitting this by tweeting how she thrived off a radio airplay and got screwed over by streaming and algorithms. Mind you, Lizzo blew up in the streaming era and was a major celebrity when she was dominant.
  20. Madonna. Let's not get caught up in recency bias or only using "streams" as a metric. If you take away her tons of features for other major artists like Drake, Eminem, Kanye, Jay, Calvin Harris, DJ Khaled, etc. then Madonna very clearly has the bigger solo hit catalog than Rihanna. Even rappers have made songs based on Madonna songs like Holiday Rap and Jay-Z naming a song "Justify My Thug." And Vogue is one of the most iconic pop songs ever and it's a soundtrack song. Rihanna or Mariah are still 2nd in command though. Don't get it twisted.
  21. Katy actually has a pretty normal pop star career life cycle. It's not the norm for artists like Madonna, Beyonce, Taylor, Gaga, Adele, Lana, Rihanna, Janet, etc. to have 15-20+ year runs. Their careers are anomalies in the pop world. Look at Doja Cat and Dua Lipa for example. They both had 2 massive pop albums that dominated the landscape but Radical Optimism and Scarlet were falls from grace compared to the previous 2 albums. And people are still stunned with their inability to recapture the FN and Planet Her dominance today. Katy did very well for 8 years(2008-2015) but she didn't really stick out enough to have the same cult or diehard followings as certain other pop stars which lead her to having a normal pop star run where you're hot for 1-4 albums and then, as Porky Pig says, "That's all folks!"
  22. I know there's a big "R&B vs Pop" debate but I feel Usher in 2004 should be here too.
  23. Despite people clowning Beyonce's streaming success, she does better than people think. People get so caught up in "Spotify Monthly Listener" stats which are heavily dependent on playlisting and autoplay that they can't see how consumed Beyonce's music actually is. She's even one of the best selling artists in singles sales. Not bad for a woman who's been active in music for 3 decades. Shakira deserves lots of props too.
  24. Taylor is hated online more than real life. Online, she rallies all the other fanbases against her like Thanos vs The Avengers: Monsters, Army, BTS fans, Livies, Billie fans, Beliebers, Drake fans, Kanye fans, The Hive, The Navy, MJ fans, Ariana fans, Adele fans, Barbs, etc. I've seen literally all of them call a truce and tag team to drag Taylor online lol.
  25. I mean....I guess. I'd still argue that Rolling Stone, Pitchfork, and BBC have more impactful reviews than him bu as a celebrity, I suppose he's the one. But it has less to do with him being a "good critic" and more to do with him taking full advantage of Youtube and social media as a platform for building up his profile in the last 16 years. Other notable critics like Robert Christgau preferred to keep a low profile outside of their music reviews and they didn't have social media at their disposal. Fantano's actual music criticism is pretty surface level stuff though. As a Latino, I can tell you straight up that 85% of his reviews of Latin music are disposable because the guy literally couldn't even identify blatant bachata influences on different artists. Instead, calling it "Latin jazz fusion" lmao. Also, he sometimes uses a ton of word salad instead of getting his point across directly. It's like he wants to desperately be seen as a "music intellectual" instead of embracing the fact that he's closer to a Nostalgia Critic, Angry Video Game Nerd, and Jeremy Jahns than he is to an actual professional critic. I honestly enjoy Fantano more when he lets his personality shine in his livestreams instead of his usual schtick of being the pedantic, stoic critic like he does in his normal reviews. Fantano is the most relevant critic only because he was one of the first to take advantage of social media to propel himself into Internet celebrity status. You could make the same argument for Simon Cowell being the most important music critic of the 2000's, especially when American Idol actually launched stars.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.