-
Why are only Black women referred to as local?
R&B music being significantly more popular in Asia(particularly Japan, Philippines, Taiwan, and South Korea) and Africa than Europe and Latin America is a blind spot for many pop fans and part of the reason why many R&B adjacent artists like Janet and Mariah get downplayed. And, even then, they ironically sold millions more actual CDs in Europe compared to the current MPG girls who get a trillion streams globally and lots of social media followers but their pure sales numbers are terrible compared to the supposed "local" artists of the past decades. Hell, Whitney and Mariah sold MILLIONS MORE CDs in Europe than Britney and Lady Gaga but you will never know this from online discourse. People nowadays judge popularity off of personal anecdotes, Spotify streams, Stan Twitter engagement, and gay bars/clubs than any other metrics.
-
Which acclaimed female performer has never really wowed you?
Okay....I'm going to get slammed for this but I sort of agree with the caveat that I think MJ's performances peaked in the 70's and 80's and declined drastically in the 90's and early 00's. 70's and 80's era MJ definitely lived up to the hype as an all time great performer. But, in the 90's, he was winging it like crazy with the blatant lip syncing, sounding out of tune a good portion of the times where he did sing live, rehashing the exact same moves he did at Motown 25 and the Victory/Bad tours, limiting his 90's set list(the lack of "Remember The Time" was criminal), getting stiffer with his move set, and barely putting much creativity in his production. The HIStory tour in particular just might be one of the most overrated tours in pop history because that's when all the issues I named were amplified but people still praise it because it's MJ. He seemed to be on the path of getting back to perfecting his performances again for the This Is It tour but, sadly, it didn't pan out. But yeah.....give me 70's and 80's MJ any day over the performer he devolved into over time.
-
What are stans trying to prove with these redundant posts about Beyoncé streams?
It's mainly Monsters or Navy fans that do this(surprisingly, not Swifties too much unless it's a back and forth). But this is why streaming should be considered one of MANY metrics to measure an artist's success. Beyonce has proven to be a major success in the CD era. She may not have a Diamond album or anything but she still sold millions of CDs worldwide and still sold many hard copies in the 2010's with even Lemonade outselling other 2016 albums worldwide according to IFPI Global Recordings Report. Modern stans, however, overvalue streaming success on Spotify and Youtube above all. Even Apple Music isn't considered good enough. All metrics must be factored in though or else you'll get kids treating Janet like a "nobody" while ignoring how she has a Diamond album that hasn't been certified yet and one of the best-selling artists oat in Japan and South Africa.
-
Janet Jackson's streams on Spotify are borderline unacceptable!!
You can say a similar thing about Prince. The reality is that not all pop stars or legends are destined to have great streaming success. But, regardless, these 2 still sold MILLIONS of physical CDs worldwide in a highly competitive era of music. Streaming didn't really take off until 2015 and it's a very modern phenomenon. Even Madonna's streams, while better, aren't as amazing as you'd expect from the Queen of Pop and I've seen Stan Twitter drag her for that too. But streaming and buying singles/albums digitally is a new phenomenon that's mostly blown up in the last 15 years and you can't really use that ALONE to judge legacy or popularity because it more so reflects how many people 35 and under consume music and how viral older hits stay viral via playlists, ad/movie/TV placements, and Tik Tok algorithms. At the end of the day, touring is probably the best way to gauge success for the relevance of older legends. You can't use MPG standards for everyone while using ONE standard while completely ignoring the standards of physical mediums from their eras. You have to factor in both.
-
Most overrated album of the year so far?
I'm a Madonna fan who enjoys the album a lot but I can somewhat see what you're saying. The album is definitely a "back to the roots" album where she didn't really experiment or try to be polarizing like she did with Madame X. But I think with all the bashing and ageism Madonna goes through, she needed a safe great dance album to get back in people's graces before possibly experimenting more on a future project.
-
Taylor Swift has "RUINED MUSIC" & the "Apotheosis of MEDIOCRITY"
It's not new. A lot of MPGs go through that cycle on the Internet. There was a time where Gaga and Beyonce were getting trashed all the time on pop forums. It was brutal too. The very Stan phrase "pop emergency" originated from pop forums trashing Gaga's Artpop rollout. And, of course, we know how Katy became a punching bag for years to come post Witness.
-
Taylor Swift has "RUINED MUSIC" & the "Apotheosis of MEDIOCRITY"
If we're being real, Drake had a far bigger impact on the sloppification and playlistfication of modern music. When he attached Hotline Bling to Views at the last minute to boost his sales/streams, that was the start of it. And when he was put out that bloated double album in 2018, it was the nail in the coffin. And many mainstream artists tried to copy his formula for streaming success. At least Taylor still made cohesive albums with a central theme even when they were long(TTPD) or bad(Lover, TLOASG).
-
Are Lana and Beyoncé to blame for Ellamania?
The real answer is that the Country fandom adjusted to streaming over the years. That's it. They were already a huge market in terms of CD buying and concert attendance but, now, they've gotten used to streaming their faves as well. Morgan Wallen was already smashing during the Biden era so Trump plays no role. Younger Country fans are just using Spotify and Apple like everyone else.
- Katy Perry only spends a total of 12 weeks Hot 100 this decade, how?
- did drake kind of eat a bit on janice stfu
-
Ella, Olivia and Taylor set to have the 3 biggest Hot 100 hits of 2026, surprised?
It was a rather dry year for hits so this doesn't surprise me.
-
Rihanna is more versatile as an artist than Gaga. Surprised?
Rihanna is versatile the same way Drake is versatile. I'll leave it at that.
-
Can Taylor Swift revert her current reputation?
I highly doubt that lol. But this can be said about just about any celebrity tbh. Even Madonna probably has many people irl who view her as an "old hag" or "washed up" even with Confessions 2 out. That doesn't mean she doesn't have many supporters and fans though. Almost every famous celebrity has their share of haters or people indifferent to them. It comes with the territory. But Taylor almost objectively has the biggest fanbase in pop right now. We are past the age of artists having Beatles and pre-Dangerous era MJ level universal love regardless of the artist. Even Beyonce has her share of people who think it's "gay" to listen to her music(straight guys) and people who associate her with the occult or witchcraft(MAGA and Christian types).
- Can Taylor Swift revert her current reputation?
-
Beyoncé and Mariah release and write with The Dream despite rape allegations. Why?
This is false. Many actual witnesses have claimed that the Carters had a strictly business/socialite relationship with Diddy just like every other celebrity.