Quote

The pop star returns with a restrained, slightly scattered, but emotionally generous album that cycles through the collapse of one relationship and into the hopeful beginning of another.

 

Full review

That's fair and much better than I expected.

There was no way they would rate it higher than Sweetener.

Edited March 11, 20242 yr by Jamie Starr

Lower than Positions? I'm going to pull a Halsey at them. BS.

I expected a 7.0, so this is good 

Lower than Positions? A joke

this is her worst score since yours truly lmao

i can see why they gave it this though

deserves higher

Wait they gave k bye for now the live album a higher rating, they going to hell 

Great score 

this is about exactly on the mark 

Expected. “Lower than positions?!!!” uhm the second half of positions is her career high so

makes no sense why this is the worst score she’s gotten since her debut but hey 

7+ for a pop album from p4k is great tbh no issues 

:p

Very unserious, but also expected. I hate how predictable they have become.

 

There was no way they were gonna rate it higher than Sweetener, but should have been a 7.7 at least.

Edited March 11, 20242 yr by State of Grace.

Lower than I expected tbh

This will get reappraisal in a few years and p4k will give this a 9.0+ 

They gave My Everything a 7.7 but ES gets a 7.2? Not surprised Sweetener remains the highest rated since it's still her most experimental, left-field album and critics love that. 

 

Sweetener - 8.1

thank u, next - 7.9

My Everything - 7.7

Dangerous Woman - 7.6

Positions - 7.4

k bye for now (live album)- 7.4

eternal sunshine - 7.2

Yours Truly - 6.5 

this is a little surprising to me, as it's a far more cohesive album than My Everything, and far more balanced when it comes to highs and lows than Positions. this is her second lowest score and that's just really bizarre to me cause it feels like possibly her strongest project

deserved a 7.9 at the very least ……. less than TUN is crazy honestly

It's a fair rating

I have it as a 7/10 

She deserved more :( 

This is just stupid tbh.

this is a crime 

 

Quote

Drawing inspiration from the 2004 Michel Gondry film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind—a surreal romantic comedy in which people can elect to have unwanted memories erased as a form of therapy—