Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
New Music Out Now!!! 🎧💿

Tm4074

ATRL Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Tm4074

  1. I hope the tour documentary/concert film is much better than the Sweetener Tour movie. It was good but it had no narrative and lacked any insight.
  2. She didn't post about her nominations for ES or Positions. She was particularly pissed about ES not getting in the general field because she shaded the Grammys in an interview shortly after nominations when she was promoting Wicked. She actually did some minor Grammy campaigning for ES too which is rare for her in a post Sweetener world so she wanted those major nominations. Interviewer asked her what is more exciting a potential Oscar nomination or a Grammy nomination and she gave a response essentially dismissing the Grammys lmao. Yeah it's baffling she gets her first music video nomination for HTIMYLM. Meanwhile NTLTC was paid dust. Unfortunately that year was before the committees were abolished in the GF and it was confirmed by the CEO that Sweetener and NTLTC had enough votes to be in the top 8 for AOTY and SOTY, but the committee removed her for a Grammy fave with significantly fewer votes. It makes no statistical sense Pharrell won Producer of the Year for Sweetener and it won Pop Vocal Album but was absent from the GF. Even without the confirmation from the prior CEO it was obvious that was some f*ckery by the committee. She has the worst luck and timing with these things.
  3. Yeah that was a huge surprise. She was probably next in line for AOTY , ROTY and Pop Solo nominations. If she put effort into a campaign and had a slightly stronger commercial performance (a second hit, stronger album performance overall) she would have got those nominations. She had surprisingly decent support outside of pop (Best Music Video, SOTY and Immersive Album nominations) for one of her weaker album eras.
  4. She acknowleged the nominations. Last time she did that was TUN and she attended. I think she's going to the show.
  5. She got a GF nomination and six total so she might show this time! We'll see.
  6. Peaked #55 Everyday 838,168,689 341,424
  7. Not really. Petal is outperforming Charmbracelet in every metric. Charmbracelet didn't have any top 40 hits, all the singles flopped. Petal has a legit #1 hit that is still in the top 10 in its 23rd week and the second single peaked #4. Charmbracelet peaked #3 on the album chart and charted for only 22 weeks. Petal peaked #1 and will certainly outlast Charmbracelet. Charmbracelet is only certified platinum for selling 1.1 million copies in the US. For an album released in 2003 that is pretty low. Petal will surpass that in total units. Charmbracelet only went #1 in South Korea and top 10 in only 4 countries. Petal peaked #1 in 20 countries. A better comparison would be Rainbow if we are going to compare it to a Mariah album. Artistically and critically I guess we could call it her Charmbracelet era but commercially Ariana is in a much better spot than Mariah was in 2003.
  8. Neither. Both aren't in the position Mariah was in during Glitter and Charmbracelet. Taylor and Ariana had #1 albums and a huge hit. They are just overexposed and oversaturated in the media which is causing backlash. I guess you can compare being a punching bag for the media/public and weaponizing mental health concern for entertainment then Mariah/Ariana's situations are comparable to an extent.
  9. Oscar voters in the music branch don't like her for some reason. She had submitted a few times before with good enough soundtrack songs that were moderately popular and never got the nomination despite making some precursors. Billie, Rihanna, Beyoncé, The Weeknd, Adele, Gaga, etc. all got nominations or wins in the Best Original Song category but they never throw Taylor a bone. She is over-campaigning too which could backfire. The music branch is small and insular, it's not like the actors branch. That's why Diane Warren gets nominated every year for a song only Diane Warren herself has heard lmao. She's lucky this is a song attached to Toy Story 5 which could work in her favor.
  10. It's not shade it's realistic. Being a fan doesn't mean giving blind praise. I don't want her to fail and a theatrical concert film will fail at the box office. What evidence is there to support this being commercially successful? Even Gaga didn't put her Mayhem Ball concert film in theaters and that tour grossed over $400m. If this a small limited run for a weekend in theaters then fine but a full theatrical release is stupid.
  11. Girl don't do it. Actual superstars with huge budgets aren't guaranteed successful box office runs for their concert films (ex: Billie). What makes her team think a niche millennial nostalgia act that was retired from music for decades until now and isn't known for her live performance skills will do well in theaters with a concert film? I love Hilary, she was a huge part of my childhood but let's be realistic here. This should obviously be a streaming release. Hilary as an actor hasn't been a box office draw since her teen years. As an adult she's been exclusively a streaming actor.
  12. Don't need to be on camera to practice self-awareness
  13. 1.6m daily streams is pretty low for her signature album and her biggest commercial success
  14. Hannah Montana is an albums artist. Miley Cyrus is not. According to Chartmasters she doesn't have a single album 10M+. Bangerz was a moment but it faded pretty quickly and its recurrent streams aren't impressive. Without Hannah Montana being included in her total units she would be in Selena Gomez territory.
  15. Cynthia performed with her at one of the London shows on her tour just two months ago so yeah we have seen them together since promotion ended.
  16. ATRL users calling their behavior insane and weird when there are daily meltdowns on here when someone criticizes your fave.
  17. In terms of my personal enjoyment it's #4 in her discography for me behind thank u next, Sweetener and Positions. If I'm judging from a critical/artistic standpoint (storytelling, focus, production, melodies, cohesion, innovation, identity, etc.) it's only above My Everything for me. My Everything is last because it's a playlist album, it has standout individual songs though. She took all the wrong notes from the praise of ES. She kept the same collaborators which fostered redundancy and stagnation. She decided to make WCBF the album but the issue is WCBF did everything she was doing on petal much better. The whole "fame is a prison and f*** the fans" concept was already done really well on ES. Petal is also missing the vulnerability of ES. If she actually executed the feral concept by showing anger and rage in her performance and lyrics, the album would have been significantly better. Going for vague lyricism isn't what was needed. Her songwriting style that people love from her is being specific and direct. There was very little of that on petal. She needs to let her guard down and stop worrying about what the loser internet brigade is going to say. For her next album, whenever that is, she needs fresh collaborators that will push her creatively. She has reached the creative peak of her collaboration with Max and Co. Ditch the mainstream by-the-numbers pop producers and do some experimental r&b and soul or something. That's a style and genre she loves and is a fan of outside of being an artist.
  18. She doesn't have one. Needs to have a signature sound/identity to have a quintessential album. Demi has never found her niche, she just jumps on trends when said trends are winding down. She's a singles artist and B-list one at that.
  19. She keeps adding tattoos to her hands/wrist and just got a new one on her collar bone during tour… so no.
  20. I would suggest getting your eyes and ears checked
  21. This was expected. There were rumors he was going to choose himself. Hopefully this is the end of Roc Nation controlling the halftime (their contract is up after this year, no?) and someone else takes over moving forward. Only two halftime shows being headlined by women this decade? Whatever. Jay Z has some huge hits and is a legend but he needs high profile guests and huge production. Won't come close to one of the best halftimes. He's not a performer in the same way.
  22. I would love a collab between them but this doesn't seem like a collab tease but a UMG glitch/update or something like that. If this is happening to other artist websites it's more likely the latter.
  23. TUN the streaming blueprint for pop music. #6 on this list and it was released 7 (almost 8) years ago. The only other 2010s albums on this list are Lover and IOP, both much lower than TUN. Billie for being such a streaming juggernaut, her biggest streaming debut being HMHAS and barely making this list is surprising. Her streaming dominance is probably more global than US-centric.
  24. Yours Truly and My Everything were pre-streaming. Streaming wasn't officially added to the BB200 until November 2014 and it had a much smaller impact back then. Claiming Ariana wasn't a MPG because she didn't have a #1 song until 2018 and had hit collabs in 2014 to defend Gaga and discredit Ariana is ironic considering Gaga hadn't had a solo #1 since 2011 - 15 years ago. Is Gaga a washed up legacy act then? Is Bad Romance not a huge smash because it was blocked from #1? Problem infamously missed the #1 debut by less than 1%. All of Ariana's lead singles debuted in the top 10 from Yours Truly to Sweetener then all her leads started debuting #1 after that. All her leads from her debut album to her most recent 8th album have debuted in the top 10. She is literally the only artist to achieve this feat in chart history. Even flop Focus debuted in the top 10 at #7. That is MPG behavior. I wouldn't cite ATRL or Stan Twitter if I'm looking for facts lmao

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.