36 minutes ago, SashaDevachelli said:

Y’all insulting people and saying you have lives and yet here we all are, on a dead pop music forum either defending her actions or complaining about them, as far as I’m concerned, we’re ALL on a sinking boat, so there’s no reason to act nasty

the people saying they have lives are being called “brown-nosers”, “bootlickers”, and “cult members” because they aren’t outraged…who’s rly being nasty here? 

Edited December 26, 20223 yr by yonsé

I hope they have something planned for the 20th anniversary of DIL next year. I can see them referencing it for the RENAISSANCE era.

13 minutes ago, Beyhive6711 said:

I'm so tied of *-ChriZ-*  BS. Dont you have a life or a job?

Im here to entertain u. Be grateful, stanning Bey is like waiting for death to come knocking at ur door

 

4 minutes ago, G'Day said:

The fact that people here are bragging about having careers and men yet they’re STILL on this trash website defending a woman they don’t know and have never met. Shouldn’t you be with your man or working?

 

Parasocial relationships take many forms and anyone who has an account on a pop forum has some sort of parasocial relationship with the person who they stan. Stop thinking you’re special or exempt!

 

 

 

19 minutes ago, suneclipse121 said:

This is fact 

It is SO obvious.  

2 minutes ago, XtunaStan said:

All in all. I'm just glad seeing how a big part of our fanbase is ready to drag her and hold her accountable at the most minimal sign of offense. Says a good lot about our morals and how it set us apart from other stanbases (Garbz, Dr. Rape stans, etc)

There is a point you have made. We must remember that this is a woman that filmed herself on a sinking police car in the Deep South. This as part of her art, her music. She politicized herself; no one, neither Chart Hive nor Art Hive, projected that onto her. Her statements and stances are her own. And so her politics, specifically her class politics, are open to criticism by fans most of all. The same goes for Kylie too, btw. Kylie’s almost entirely apolitical but should know better anyway. Gay men have kept her lights on for a decade or more lmao. As for Madonna, if I’m not mistaken she’s only performed in the UAE once and it was a tour date (remember those?) ten years ago. She turns down private parties because… she’s Madonna. Not the most humble of our stars, not a girl who’s above making money, but a girl who understands that sometimes turning down a paycheck is a bigger flex than taking one. 

 

tldr: Beyoncé is a troll and a menace! She’s great tho! Happy New Year to all factions of the Hive!

13 minutes ago, yonsé said:

the people saying they have lives are being called “brown-nosers”, “bootlickers”, and “cult members” because they aren’t outraged…who’s rly being nasty here? 

 Not them getting their feelings hurt but they throw vitriol in here all day.  yeah, I’m gonna say it again; lives are needed. 

28 minutes ago, XtunaStan said:

All in all. I'm just glad seeing how a big part of our fanbase is ready to drag her and hold her accountable at the most minimal sign of offense. Says a good lot about our morals and how it set us apart from other stanbases (Garbz, Dr. Rape stans, etc)

Not true, it’s actually humanizing cause some of the hive acts like they aren’t like every other fan base that turns a blind eye to their fave. Or regular person that overlooks their friends/families questionable choices and actions 

8 minutes ago, Mitsouko said:

There is a point you have made. We must remember that this is a woman that filmed herself on a sinking police car in the Deep South. This as part of her art, her music. She politicized herself; no one, neither Chart Hive nor Art Hive, projected that onto her. Her statements and stances are her own. And so her politics, specifically her class politics, are open to criticism by fans most of all. The same goes for Kylie too, btw. Kylie’s almost entirely apolitical but should know better anyway. Gay men have kept her lights on for a decade or more lmao. As for Madonna, if I’m not mistaken she’s only performed in the UAE once and it was a tour date (remember those?) ten years ago. She turns down private parties because… she’s Madonna. Not the most humble of our stars, not a girl who’s above making money, but a girl who understands that sometimes turning down a paycheck is a bigger flex than taking one. 

 

tldr: Beyoncé is a troll and a menace! She’s great tho! Happy New Year to all factions of the Hive!

 

Well said, can’t have it both ways. 

1. Renaissance

2. Beyoncé 

3. Lemonade

4. 4

5. The Gift

6. B’Day

7. IASF

8. DIL

9. EIL

 

18 minutes ago, Mitsouko said:

There is a point you have made. We must remember that this is a woman that filmed herself on a sinking police car in the Deep South. This as part of her art, her music. She politicized herself; no one, neither Chart Hive nor Art Hive, projected that onto her. Her statements and stances are her own. And so her politics, specifically her class politics, are open to criticism by fans most of all. The same goes for Kylie too, btw. Kylie’s almost entirely apolitical but should know better anyway. Gay men have kept her lights on for a decade or more lmao. As for Madonna, if I’m not mistaken she’s only performed in the UAE once and it was a tour date (remember those?) ten years ago. She turns down private parties because… she’s Madonna. Not the most humble of our stars, not a girl who’s above making money, but a girl who understands that sometimes turning down a paycheck is a bigger flex than taking one. 

 

tldr: Beyoncé is a troll and a menace! She’s great tho! Happy New Year to all factions of the Hive!

Not me coming back to more fights.

20 minutes ago, Mitsouko said:

There is a point you have made. We must remember that this is a woman that filmed herself on a sinking police car in the Deep South. This as part of her art, her music. She politicized herself; no one, neither Chart Hive nor Art Hive, projected that onto her. Her statements and stances are her own. And so her politics, specifically her class politics, are open to criticism by fans most of all. The same goes for Kylie too, btw. Kylie’s almost entirely apolitical but should know better anyway. Gay men have kept her lights on for a decade or more lmao. As for Madonna, if I’m not mistaken she’s only performed in the UAE once and it was a tour date (remember those?) ten years ago. She turns down private parties because… she’s Madonna. Not the most humble of our stars, not a girl who’s above making money, but a girl who understands that sometimes turning down a paycheck is a bigger flex than taking one. 

 

tldr: Beyoncé is a troll and a menace! She’s great tho! Happy New Year to all factions of the Hive!

Very well written

 

2 minutes ago, G'Day said:

Why are that album by The Carters and that various artists soundtrack in this ranking?

 

1. Renaissance

2. Beyoncé

3. B’Day/4

4. 4/B’Day

5. Lemonade

6. Dangerously in Love 

7. IASF

The Gift is good enough to be apart of this and it’s better than some girls studio albums. I added EIL out of pity.

Any ranking that doesn’t put I Am Such Sh*t at the bottom is automatically wrong

Just now, SashaDevachelli said:

Any ranking that doesn’t put I Am Such Sh*t at the bottom is automatically wrong

Sweet Dreams single-handedly carries that album I’m afraid.  The other album has ‘Daddy’ and deserves to be at the bottom I’m sawry.

7 minutes ago, Starshine said:

Sweet Dreams single-handedly carries that album I’m afraid.  The other album has ‘Daddy’ and deserves to be at the bottom I’m sawry.

Not an unlisted / hidden track being the catalyst 

Best album: 

Rennie > 4 > ST > Lemonade > Bday > DIL > IASF

 

Best era:

IASF > 4 > Lemonade > Bday > DIL > ST > Rennie

 

Overall:

 

4 > Lemonade > IASF = Rennie > BDay = ST > DIL

 

Edited December 26, 20223 yr by *-ChriZ-*

Couple things:

• Beyoncé slayed in her Tiffany blood diamonds, tbh it's one of her best campaigns to date (if not THE best... competing with H&M)
• Beyoncé should absolutely get her coins in Dubai, there's not really much a popstar can affect about LGBT laws worldwide
• Beyoncé will need to remove Kanye from the opening sequence of "Party" when she performs it live
• Beyoncé will need to substitute "Balenciaga" with "Dolce Gabanna" when she performs "Summer Renaissance" as the closer on the Club Renaissance World Tour.

You're all assholes. Just in different ways. 

17 minutes ago, Kassi said:

Couple things:

 

• Beyoncé will need to substitute "Balenciaga" with "Dolce Gabanna" when she performs "Summer Renaissance" as the closer on the Club Renaissance World Tour.

Do I have some news for you

 

1 hour ago, G'Day said:

The fact that people here are bragging about having careers and men yet they’re STILL on this trash website defending a woman they don’t know and have never met. Shouldn’t you be with your man or working?

 

 

 

I'm not sure I've ever met anyone with a fulfilling, successful life that has to lord over everyone else how great it is. Besides, I can be very happy in my life and still criticize Beyonce, a woman who does not know me and never will. 

Spoiler

If she posts the whole performance on youtube then I’ll forgive this act of homophobia

 

5 minutes ago, ShouldersSideways said:

Do I have some news for you

 

OH no! What is it now?

 

Just now, SashaDevachelli said:

  Reveal hidden contents

If she posts the whole performance on youtube then I’ll forgive this act of homophobia

 

seeing AHAP choreo is worth losing a few rights