Petals, Caution and Bedtime Stories, all 3 great albums but which one do you think is the best?

Bedtime Stories is one of the best albums of all time.

Caution underrated queen

Caution, easily

Bedtime Stories has grown on me over time and has some career highlights like the title track, but I'd still have to go with Caution because it's more consistently great.

Petal = Caution > Bedtime Stories

caution CLEARS

it's her second best album

Be serious. Only 1 of these has Secret on it

Bedtime Stories...... you did not deserve this

Inside of Me alone clears any reason for the other two albums to exist, and I say this as a Mariah stan...

Inside of Me alone clears

caution CLEARS followed by Petal then Bedtime stories it's lace with filter.

I'm afraid Björk made several points and due to her involvement alone, Godtime Stories clear by miles

The one with Love Tried To Welcome Me, Sanctuary, Inside Of Me and Secret.

The run from Love Tried to Welcome Me until the end of the album alone clears the other two.

Is this a joke?

10 minutes ago, tiagol88 said:

The run from Love Tried to Welcome Me until the end of the album alone clears the other two.

Finally someone appreciates this run one of her best!

Bedtime Stories clears.

1 hour ago, naval23 said:

Be serious. Only 1 of these has Secret on it

Medoner ate with this one, insanely good

Caution for me, it still gives me that sweet and chill euphoric feeling from the day it was released

Bedtime = Caution>petals

I love Caution, but Bedtime Stories clears. Secret alone seals the deal, but that album also houses Survival, Love Tried To Welcome Me, Forbidden Love, Human Nature and Take A Bow.

Critically and objectively it is Caution.

GML

TD

C

8thG

ANN

5 of the greatest R&B songs ever made are on this album.

BTW... Caution is (by far) Mariah's LEAST streamed album... (when Glitter still existed, Caution did half of what Glitter was doing).

The best song ever made: