UseYourIllusion2002

Lana > 2008-2011 Gaga > like four Sabrina songs > the rest can go

My Sins Are My Savior and Good For The Soul being so low no taste

I def feel like Alejandro affected her. The video was so weird and sexual for literally no reason. BUT, the song was all over the radio, and it peaked at #5 on the Hot 100, so it still succeeded. I wonder how much bigger it could've been with a summer themed music video? Born This Way wasn't "too gay" for the GP. It was everywhere. But, it did fall off pretty quickly. Judas underperformed for the time, but I don't think the controversy really made it to the conscious of the GP. I'm going to vote for Alejandro.

@D.M.F What's your answer?

It's not bad, just delete the collabs with Swae Lee & Quavo and release IDSIF as the lead.

Yes but I just turned 23 this month, so I hope it stays this way from here on out.

That user didn't even mention Mariah yet you find a way to bring her up with your long ass lists nobody gives a f*** about.

Katy Perry Dark Horse > Birthday > This is How We Do > Witness > Smile > 143 > Bandaids/Watch It Burn

Not alive.

Where's Man's Best Friend?

I was talking about The Fame & The Fame Monster. But they're still on par for the most part, since Teenage Dream was at 3m by 2019 and Born This Way was at 2.4m.

Congrats? The album still sold despite it being teens who bought it? What kind of stupid ass response is this

A lot of you guys are forgetting that Teenage Dream has super mediocre album sales, even back for 2010. It barely scanned 3m copies WITH the rerelease in the United States, at a time when Gaga, and to a higher extent, Taylor and Adele were pushing far more copies. Even Susan Boyle lol. Katy's album sales were on par with Rihanna's & Kesha's, nothing to write home about considering the 6 #1 hits. Yes, chart wise Teenage Dream had bigger hits since back in 1999, Jive wasn't focused on producing multiple #1 hits. They were more focused on album sales, which Britney sold 14m in the United States alone.

You truly are a waste of space and thought on this forum, and probably in your own personal life. You are probably so unliked in real life, that you have to take out your frustrations on here towards your alleged favorite artist. For you to think Rebel Heart is leagues better than Confessions II is delusional and f*cking dumb.

This period of her career is so fascinating to me. She was arguably the biggest pop star at the beginning of 1992. She was coming off the heels of Truth or Dare/Blond Ambition/The Immaculate Collection, had a #1 hit literally three months before Erotica was released, and was in A League of Their Own. Even Erotica started off strong, with the lead single debuting at #2 on the Billboard Radio Songs Chart - a record it still holds today, and the Sex Book was selling like crazy. But the moment that book was released I definitely think she wanted to soften her image, since Bedtime Stories was originally called Redemption. I think she felt the need to redeem herself with the public, since the 1993 backlash was hard on her. I also think the label had a play in it, hence them taking some creative control back. I mean, they rejected the original photoshoot for the Bedtime Stories album (which I prefer), and they chose the first two singles. I'd love to hear some of the Shep Pettibone demos that she scrapped, including Secret. A shame we never got it last year when The Untold Chapter was released.