or

Both are among their most iconic songs/videos (personally, Toxic is more iconic than BOMT imho). Which one wins overall?

Toxic for all.

Bad Romance was a fad from the 2000s she has more iconic singles than Bad Romance; for starters any single from The Fame.

Toxic is more iconic, but I still voted for bad romance

Had you asked for the best song, I would have said Toxic, but it's Bad Romance for all these three questions.

Edited June 3Jun 3 by Loca

toxic for the more catchy factor but they're almost pretty equal

That Kylie's song

Milennials and older: Toxic

Gen Z and younger: Bad Romance

solid gold trashcans racing down a diamond street

I'd say this is just an age thing. Voted Bad Romance because I'm a mid-90s baby.

Edited June 3Jun 3 by DevilsRollTheDice

Bad romance clears

Toxic

7 minutes ago, DevilsRollTheDice said:

I'd say this is just an age thing. Voted Bad Romance because I'm a mid-90s baby.

sorry if I'm missing the logic here, but what does this mean?

1 minute ago, Breathe On Moi said:

sorry if I'm missing the logic here, but what does this mean?

Both songs are enormous hits. The one that seems more iconic to any individual (given that this is entirely a subjective measure without any objective criteria) will likely be affected by your age. I was 8 when Toxic was smashing and not checked into pop culture. I love the song, but it doesn't feel "iconic" to me in the way Bad Romance does which was released when I was 13 and paying much closer attention to things that were cool/popular.

Toxic for all, be serious

what a crime this legendary songs reached at #2 and #9

Toxic for all

Is the water wet?

Toxic for all.

both iconic as ****

Toxic I'm so sorry sweetie..

Bad Romance for all, be serious

I love both but Toxic was a cultural reset

I mean, Toxic easily and I'm a mid 90s baby too

In the real world it's Bad Romance. Its sold more and was a much bigger hit.

The MV had famous notable success outside of vibes (fastest to 1bn on Youtube) and won a Grammy for the MV and VOTY at VMAs.

Although I'd guess an X Stan set this up though for liddos to fight against britney

Edited June 3Jun 3 by Mr. Stratus

Bad romance X3 sweetie

Bad Romance:

-2x Grammy and 7x VMA winner

-Named MV of the century by Billboard

-13M downloads

-Parent album 20M pure sales

-#1 in most markets of the world

-Biggest MV on YouTube history at the time

-4.9B YouTube Music + Spotify

-First female song to go Diamond in the US

To:xic

Edited June 3Jun 3 by Fame Romance