momal

Which artist had the stronger body of work in each decade of her career? Consider all (studio/official) albums released during that period and vote for the decade you think was stronger overall. Madonna vs. Beyoncé — decade by decade. or

DMF, never heard of the other two.

Well, duh. Insane run of hits and she was pushing big numbers albums wise too.

None. All of them have had big solo hits (many of them became classics). They've been there, done that. Collaborating with others is nothing to be ashamed of.

or Both are among their most iconic songs/videos (personally, Toxic is more iconic than BOMT imho). Which one wins overall?

Good music, talent.

Nope, both songs are bops. And people shading J.Lo here as if she isn't bigger than Kylie in every single metric: she sold more pure albums, she is more consumed overall in SPS numbers, gets more daily streams on Spotify/Youtube even though Kylie has like 2x more albums. Kylie has to be the most overrated pop girl on this forum because her numbers are the floppiest of them all overall, barely 40 million SPS. Albums like TFM and 1989 did those numbers alone.

Which one wins in terms of talent in 2026? Take into consideration vocals, writing, producing, performing, dancing, acting, stage presence etc.

They're often described as pop artists most obsessed with chart performance: Mariah is known for her single discounts, remixes and numerous #1 hits, while Taylor stands out for her multiple release variants and strategic rollout and promotion tactics. Which of the two seems more focused on chart success? Take their entire careers into consideration. or

They are often mentioned as pop girls with most longevity among their peers. Take into consideration albums, singles, streaming, catalog sales, touring success. Which one has been more successful so far?

According to Chartmasters, which this site loves to cite very often, he is at 130,070,000 CSPC. That's more than Britney with 127,380,000, Beyonce with 114,777,000 and Lady Gaga with 104,398,000 CSPC. He's about to overtake Rihanna and her 139,370,000 CSPC as well. There are also many other artists like Adele, Shakira, Ariana Grande, Katy Perry , Janet Jackson, Aretha Franklin etc. who are behind him in this formula. The question is: does this list hold any prestige or importance in the grand scheme of things when considering overall career? Can we really say he is bigger than these ladies given his massive streaming numbers? Discuss.

They were both massive in the 90s and reached their peak during that decade, but which one peaked higher and owned the entire decade? Also, who achieved better longevity? or

It will always be Crazy In Love.

They are not known as energetic performers a la Beyonce, J.Lo, Gaga, Madonna, but which one puts on a better show? Is it Mariah with her powerful and emotive voice or Taylor with her storytelling and guitar/piano playing?

I didn't count their soundtrack singles or side projects, just the singles from their official studio albums. Didn't include popstars like Billie, Olivia, Sabrina, Dua, their music is still too recent. Sorry if I forgot someone, no enough space. What do you think, which one is the biggest classic among these choices?