DevilsRollTheDice
ATRL Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Topic: ROSALÍA: "Taylor is a master at songwriting and WD is one of my most played ever"
Everything posted by DevilsRollTheDice
-
Taylor Swift
I've always known the tea on I Slayed It, I Slew You, but I've REALLY been connecting with it since the CMAs. Beautiful song and so pleasantly meta with it being her return to country. Been listening to the Spotify release of the performance nonstop. It also makes me think people are doing WAY too much about her voice. Yes, it sounds a little raspy and there's clearly some damage from Eras, but she still sounds nice! In fact, I wouldn't even really say she sounds worse. Mostly just raspier. While I'm concerned for the long-term health of her voice, this certainly isn't a Mariah situation yet. Speaking of, those users pretending to not know what you meant in the other thread had my eye twitching @PoisonedIvy .
- Patient Zero: a hit or a flop?
-
Seriously, what has happened to Taylor's vocals?
This is some bizarre narrative that has spread on here recently. Like Gaga and Ariana, she uses some live pitch correction. She also consistently lip syncs some parts (the Blank Space chorus comes to mind), but most of Eras was sung live. Basically every vocal climax was sung live. Endless videos of variation on Don't Blame Me, WANEGBT, Shake It Off, Ready For It climaxes and so many others. There are also plenty of videos of her making mistakes, talking, messing up lyrics, going flat from time to time, and choosing alternate melodies all over the show. If you watched lots of Eras, you can also just clearly hear differences night to night and as her voice started to become more strained in Europe. It's also just…extremely easy to hear when she isn't singing lol. Even in the proshoots. I'd say 70/80% of Eras was sung live (with pitch correction). That's a hell of a lot of singing. The scope of the show itself and the schedule makes it one of the most demanding shows in history. It also uses her entire range and every part of her voice. My background is in musical theatre and Broadway performers experience damage with far less singing over 9 month contracts. That's just…so much singing. People don't realize how demanding it is. She was also recording new music throughout. You could have perfect technique and would still have problems from the sheer volume. Our chords simply aren't built to withstand that. Taylor's pitch and range haven't been damaged. She did the …Ready for It? adlibs during the third to last Eras show (she's done them live fewer than 10 times). But her voice is raspier and sounds a bit thinner. I hope she'll recover in time. I know this place is a Taylor snark, but the physical demand of Eras on her voice was unbelievable. It's actually crazy she didn't cause more damage.
-
Patient Zero: a hit or a flop?
The song has done well in the USA. Context matters. It's a deluxe bonus track. TOTC (which has Luminate data) currently anticipates it to be tied for 13th on American streaming (minus Christmas songs) in week 8. obsessed and Twilight Zone were already in the 90s. PZ is currently 900k weekly streams behind stupid song and Olivia is on tour in the USA (currently the best form of promo in music) and experiencing a high cultural moment . People will scream that a dying awards show debut 2 months ago somehow makes it akin to a lead single (I guess The Dead Dance is a super lead single) and that one day of promo in September somehow explains its solid US streaming numbers in November. It's also number 1 on pop radio callouts which is quite difficult to get. It's a cute moderate hit in the USA. Compared to other recent post-release deluxe singles, it's done extremely well. Some of Taylor's peers haven't seen 7 weeks in the top 10 with any solo song, let alone a deluxe bonus track, in nearly 15 years. I believe it has the highest points week of the year, too. Worldwide, it's a bit of a flop, I'll give it to the OTHs. But still outperforming basically every comparable song released this decade.
-
Taylor Swift
- Taylor Swift
People on here don't really understand what they're saying when they try to drag Taylor's vocals, she's completely on pitch. With that said, I do think Eras damaged her voice somewhat. It's crazy how much this website has run with the narrative that she was lip syncing most of it when you can plainly hear she was not. The only egregious lip syncing is during the 1989 set and she still sings plenty of it live including all the vocal climaxes. Her pitch is fine, she just sounds hoarse. I hope she can fully recover. I feel like you can even hear it on studio vocals throughout parts of Showgirl. Also ridiculous to imply that she damaged it because of bad technique. If anything, it's startling that she didn't do more damage. Eras was an absolutely insane feat. Many Broadway performers damage their voices during 9 month contracts with technically perfect singing. Eras was 2 years, using her entire vocal range and every part of her voice, and a one woman show for 3.5 hours. I even think you can clearly hear the difference in her voice between the two professional recordings. The rasp is much more pronounced at the final show. To be clear, I think she sounded solid. But something has changed. You can hear it in her speaking voice, too.- Rank the Vocal Abilities (at their peaks) of the Top 10 Best Selling Female Artists
- Taylor Swift
I hope this rebuilt relationship culminates in...something! Still nearly impossible to believe she'll pass up on Debut TV for Debut 20. I am warming up to the idea of country TS13, but it will be frustrating when people try to drag a country album's performance on this website. But if she were to deliver country excellence I really wouldn't care! Fearless 2.0 with a very country/pop feel would honestly be incredible. IKI,IKY def has that sound.- Taylor Swift
Honestly such a simple and beautiful mashup! Makes perfect thematic sense. Man, it's been a while- Taylor Swift
When Our Song came on I LOST it girls- Taylor Swift
I AM CRYING Lovely and nostalgic performance- Discussion surrounding genocide in Xinjiang province of China
- Taylor Swift
- ChartMasters: Lady Gaga Enters Top 10 Selling Female Artists (Credited)
The album equivalent units encompasses everything. Beyonce's song sales are considered for that. The reason the song was mentioned by that user is because they are a component of equivalent album sales, they are not exchangeable or equal. Beyonce's "record sales" are meaningless in this conversation. That's not what we're comparing. Absolute record sales is not what CMs measures. "Record sales" treat album and singles units as the same thing. When Taylor updates her American certifications for singles, she'll be flirting with one billion record sales, instantly becoming the "best selling" artist in history, surpassing The Beatles, using that measure. CM, like most everyone else, understands that album units and individual single units are not equivalent. Single units are part of album units, but it's not 1:1.- ChartMasters: Lady Gaga Enters Top 10 Selling Female Artists (Credited)
You're comparing two completely different things. These are album sales equivalents. Beyonce's single certifications contribute but album sales equivalents =/= single sales. Chartmasters numbers are also not "made up" . They're very well sourced. I don't think it's surprising at all that Gaga's solo career is going to surpass Beyonce (or already has) given the pretty significant difference in worldwide success.- Which singer is most similar to your own voice?
"Upload a few clips of you singing to chatgpt"- How strong is your country's global purchasing power? GTA VI edition
This is probably AI slop. What's the actual source for the data? Here is actual PPP data from the World Bank.- US Airplay Discussion
X (formerly Twitter)Talk of the Charts (@talkofthecharts) on XTalk of the Charts on XI'm looking at the extended projection for this week. Not sure if you can see since it's paywalled, but TOTC has access to Luminate. PZ is currently projected to be tied for 13 without Christmas. Even if there was a massive difference the prediction and the final (which would be unusual with TOTC), the gaps are small and top 20 on streaming in week 8 and number 1 on callouts is absolutely enough to justify excellent pop radio performance compared to other songs this year. If you restrict to pop song projections, she's 8 on streaming right behind stupid song.- US Airplay Discussion
Currently projected to be 12/13 this week (8th week) on the USA streaming minus Christmas songs. PZ should absolutely be topping based on the callouts and steady streams. But deluxe singles just seem to perform strangely/worse all around. In the context of deluxe singles, PZ has done very well in the US and is demonstrating much stronger longevity than songs like obsessed and Twilight Zone. Both were in the 90s on American streaming in week 8. Taylor hasn't lifted a finger since week 1. obsessed was being performed nightly. What's REALLY strange is Petal's performance. Setting aside how it is so sonically weird for pop radio, TOTC has her 43/45 for streaming on non-holiday songs this week. There are likely many other songs in the top 100 ahead of it. Obviously many songs that have topped pop radio this year have done so after their streaming peaks, but Petal has to be one of the most egregious examples. It's been out of the top 40 of American streaming for weeks. IKI,IKY was getting dragged left and right and spent something like 8 weeks in the top 10 of streaming and months in the top 40.- Taylor Swift
Her apartment disinterest in certifying is so psychologically fascinating lol. It's very much at odds with the image people construct for her. Rihanna, allegedly the epitome of indifference about her career, is constantly updating and acknowledging her own accomplishments. Taylor hardly ever updates (foregoing the Guinness record for best selling artist OAT!) and almost NEVER acknowledges her commercial success.- Taylor Swift
She stays playing in my face. The day she finally updates will be one for the ATRL history books. Instantly the best selling artist of all time. Constantly doing "Are Taylor's (American!) number 1s hits and 7 are already diamond with Shake It Off approaching double diamond. All without any TV units. Unserious website.- Instant skips: songs by your fav that you can't stand
- Taylor Swift: Most solo AOTY noms OAT
- Hot 100 | Final predictions (11/21): Texas #1 (x28), Boston #2, LC #14, AIWFCIY #18
Sometimes I can't tell if you're trolling "Entirely new version of an album" and it's a four-track deluxe. Unlike many others it doesn't even have physicals. Again, that insane logic makes all those aforementioned songs lead singles along with endless others. Ours was a lead single? Busy Woman? Flawless? Was Gut (spilled) an entirely new version of the album? I guess obsessed was a lead single, too. Twilight Zone. Even if you insist upon that obviously bad faith and contradictory logic, Taylor is still blowing all those songs out of the water- Hot 100 | Final predictions (11/21): Texas #1 (x28), Boston #2, LC #14, AIWFCIY #18
It's an equally rationale argument as calling Patient Zero a lead. What's Patient Zero the lead single to? The Life of a Showgirl? I guess The Dead Dance, obsessed, Busy Woman, Twilight Zone, and Flawless (remix) are all lead singles . Literally no one in the industry would claim that. Just y'all trying to drag a song that is performing objectively well. - Taylor Swift