Title...

Edited April 22, 20242 yr by mercurialworld

somewhere between 6 and 7.4

Definitely lower than reputation's revisited score, 8.5.

I'm suspecting between 6 and 7.

Between 6.5 and 7.5 

I don't think that they're allowed to give her a panning so no 

 

Music criticism is in shambles 

No, I think they'll give it a 7.0-7.5

They gave Ed Sheeran at his peak a 2.7 for an album that's on par with TTPD quality wise. It would be iconic if they pull a similar stunt. Taylor doesn't deserve it but Ed didn't either. She's getting a 7.0

Offcial score is coming out in 5 hours too  

Edited April 21, 20242 yr by Blue Rose

Between 4.0 and 6.9.

I don't think they're allowed to give a significantly low score. Nobody wants to mess with her or her stans.

not that i personally think it's this bad but i feel like they will give it a 4.7

no. 7-8, what was their midnights score 

They're not going to pan it, but I can see a lower score than her past few albums.

7.0

Nobody cares what the GQ music column has to say. 

Probably 7.0

4.5 

Their takeaways article reads positively, and with Sputnik music giving it a 90 anything can happens tbh

 

https://pitchfork.com/thepitch/takeaways-from-taylor-swift-new-album-the-tortured-poets-department/

Edited April 22, 20242 yr by Blue.

Personally, I'm getting strong 6.4.

I'm sure OTHs are perched and refreshing the website for it

 

2 minutes ago, The Music Industry said:

I'm sure OTHs are perched and refreshing the website for it

 

Is an OTH like a Taylor Swift opp?

 

Just now, mercurialworld said:

Is an OTH like a Taylor Swift opp?

 

Obsessed Taylor Swift Haters 

 

Tbh the funniest/most interesting thing to do would be to just not review it at all. But since they're a Condé Nast column now that's not gonna happen. My prediction: boring middle of the road review that is critical enough to seem genuine but doesn't result in any bomb threats being sent to the basement 

Anything above 4 will be an atrocity. She needs a good downfall era to realize her mistakes and dump that producer she has been using since 2020

The album is split even between people that hate it and people who love it. A polarizing album indeed. Adele's least-liked album on there is the one that broke first week records so perhaps they will do the same to TTPD?

Edited April 22, 20242 yr by NoName