Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.
ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

1989 vs evermore

Treacherous
in Base

1989 vs evermore 99 members have voted

  1. 1. Better album overall?

  2. 2. Better lead single?

  3. 3. Better album cover?

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

  • ATRL Moderator

31AidebZFEL._SY580_.jpg

 

516GkQniSIL._SY580_.jpg

 

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

  • Replies 44
  • Views 1.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

 

 

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

Evermore sweetie...

 

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

  • ATRL Moderator

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

1989: 10, Evermore:6

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

For the polls:

evermore

evermore

1989

 

Track by track: 

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

 

1989: 5

evermore: 10

tie: 1

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

Evermore for everything, it’s her best album overall.

 

1989 is okay but I think is middle/bottom tier in her discography 

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

 

 

The way it's not even close :jonnycat:

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

 

4/13

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

 

 

Well that was easy

Evermore for all!

Not that dated (literally) Tumblr'd 1989 album cover winning the poll though :biblio:

Better: Evermore

Lead: Willow

Cover: 1989. It's just way too iconic. 

 

2/3 for Taylor's best forgotten album :emofish:

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

 

13/16 :jonnycat:

 

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie (can not and will not choose)

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

 

1989: 8
evermore: 9

evermore sweetie... but let me do this anyway...

 

 

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me


 

8 minutes ago, Michael196 said:

evermore sweetie... but let me do this anyway...

 

 

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me


 

IWYW over happiness? clm over TL? lss over IKP? Closure over Wonderland? rwylm over New Romantics? girlie....

Welcome to New York | willow

Blank Space | champagne problems

Style | gold rush

Out of the Woods | 'tis the damn season

All You Had to Do Was Stay | tolerate it

Shake It Off | no body, no crime

I Wish You Would | happiness

Bad Blood | dorothea

Wildest Dreams | coney island

How You Get the Girl | ivy

This Love | cowboy like me

I Know Places | long story short

Clean | marjorie

Wonderland | closure

You Are in Love | evermore

New Romantics | right where you left me

Go to topic listing

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications
Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.