https://www.metacritic.com/music/confessions-ii/madonna

Slant (90)

Pitchfork (81)

Rolling Stone (80)

The Telegraph (80)

The Independent (80)

The Guardian (80)

New Musicial Express (80)

Mojo (80)

Edited July 11Jul 11 by Angelshark

legend

Deserved. She is just incredible. We are far from the MDNA/Rebel Heart/Madame X debacle now...

START the count I knew this era was going to be a massive serve since the beginning

All reviews have been 4/5 stars thus far.

The best album from her since Confession

Up to 84 with 5 reviews

the acclaim...

a dream... literally a dream

deserves 90+ and i haven't even heard it!

I hope this album will be just a start for a new inspired imperial phase from here.

Fantano and Pitchfork better keep themselves in check.

Her RAY OF LIGHT

It should be around 88-90.

deserves +90 tbh. legendonna.

Madame X was 70 on metacritic btw

Stop the count (except for 5/5 reviews in case)

Deserves 100

it better hold up. but i just know pitchfork is going to wait to be the very last review and push the score down. they did it with repel charts and madame eXcellence can't ******* stand them

84 with five 80 score reviews?

1 minute ago, SweetOreosOfHeaven said:

84 with five 80 score reviews?

https://metacritichelp.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/14478499933079-How-do-you-compute-METASCORES?

1 hour ago, Angelshark said:

https://www.metacritic.com/music/confessions-ii/madonna

The Telegraph (80)

The Independent (80)

The Guardian (80)

New Musicial Express (80)

Mojo (80)

How does she have 84 when all 5 have a score of 80?

1 minute ago, MonsterFandom said:

How does she have 84 when all 5 have a score of 80?

and some opinions weight more than others!

1 minute ago, Angelshark said:

and some opinions weight more than others!

It's a slow day today for some