I'M THAT GIRL / I Feel So Free
COZY / Good For The Soul
ALIEN SUPERSTAR / One Step Away
CUFF IT / Bring Your Love
ENERGY / Danceteria
BREAK MY SOUL / Read My Lips
CHURCH GIRL / Everything
PLASTIC OFF THE SOFA / Love Sensation
VIRGO'S GROOVE /Love Without Words
MOVE / Bizarre
HEATED / School
THIQUE / Fragile
ALL UP IN YOUR MIND / My Sins Are My Savior
AMERICA HAS A PROBLEM / Betrayal
PURE/HONEY / The Test
SUMMER RENAISSANCE / L.E.S. Girl

Confessions clears with ease

I haven't heard Confessions II but I can confidently say it's not better

Bizzare alone >>>

Both my queens, I own both albums (one is actually on its way), attended RTW (will attend C2 if she happens to tour 🥺), it's not ok, I don't **** with it, both STELLAR ALBUMS

Edited July 2Jul 2 by Mickie

Ask me again in two or three weeks.

It's going to be VERY hard to beat Renaissance.

dont do this to me

Heated vs School is musical Sophie's choice. I will not be participating.

they are both their best albüms

Not choosing x. My favorite faves

You can be both

Meet in the middle, dance all night

Will report back at midnight.

I'm confident these are the best dance albums of the 2020s though.

this is genuinely a hard question, and there may be a lot of recency bias with me.. but they are equal

I will say I had more of an emotional reaction to Confessions ii, fragile made me tear up. But Renaissance has higher peaks... But Confessions has VISUALS...

Yeah I'm sticking to "both" as an option

Rena but C2 was surprisingly good

Confessions ofc

This is my favorite Madonna album in like 2 decades butttt Renaissance is on a league of its own

Love Ren, but it's CII for me. Every song is incredible.

I'm not gonna even vote coz both are serving Pop bibles with different meanings >> Bey is celebrating black club culture and M is her roots

Both better than brat!

Confessions II is Madonna's best in a while but Renaissance clears with ease

I'M THAT GIRL / I Feel So Free
COZY / Good For The Soul
ALIEN SUPERSTAR / One Step Away
CUFF IT / Bring Your Love
ENERGY / Danceteria
BREAK MY SOUL / Read My Lips
CHURCH GIRL / Everything
PLASTIC OFF THE SOFA / Love Sensation
VIRGO'S GROOVE /Love Without Words
MOVE / Bizarre
HEATED / School
THIQUE / Fragile
ALL UP IN YOUR MIND / My Sins Are My Savior
AMERICA HAS A PROBLEM / Betrayal
PURE/HONEY / The Test
SUMMER RENAISSANCE / L.E.S. Girl

Which dance album wins?

I'm That Girl vs I Feel So Free

Cozy vs Good For The Soul

Alien Superstar vs One Step Away

Cuff It vs Bring Your Love

Energy vs Danceteria

Break My Soul vs Read My Lips

Church Girl vs Everything

Plastic Off The Sofa vs Love Sensation

Virgo's Groove vs Love Without Words

Move vs Bizzare

Heated vs School

Thique vs Fragile

All Up In Your Mind vs My Sins Are My Savior

America Has A Problem vs Betrayal

Pure/Honey vs The Test

Summer Renaissance vs LES Girl

I'm That Girl vs I Feel So Free

Cozy vs Good For The Soul

Alien Superstar vs One Step Away

Cuff It vs Bring Your Love

Energy vs Danceteria

Break My Soul vs Read My Lips

Church Girl vs Everything

Plastic Off The Sofa vs Love Sensation

Virgo's Groove vs Love Without Words

Move vs Bizzare

Heated vs School

Thique vs Fragile

All Up In Your Mind vs My Sins Are My Savior

America Has A Problem vs Betrayal

Pure/Honey vs The Test

Summer Renaissance vs LES Girl

Love both. I do probably like Confessions II a little more, personally, so I'll abstain.

Edit: what the hell, I'll try.

I'm That Girl vs I Feel So Free

Cozy vs Good For The Soul

Alien Superstar vs One Step Away

Cuff It vs Bring Your Love

Energy vs Danceteria

Break My Soul vs Read My Lips

Church Girl vs Everything

Plastic Off The Sofa vs Love Sensation

Virgo's Groove vs Love Without Words

Move vs Bizzare

Heated vs School

Thique vs Fragile

All Up In Your Mind vs My Sins Are My Savior

America Has A Problem vs Betrayal

Pure/Honey vs The Test

Summer Renaissance vs LES Girl

With a caveat that all of these are very close.

Edited July 31Jul 31 by ____Summer

Confessions II for all. It's a masterpiece.