1 hour ago, chris1991 said:

I don't want to say anything because we are in senates times but this isn't good. Kinda free falling.

I will say it doesn't hold up as well as Beautiful Chaos. BC was kinda pop perfection, even mean girls.

BC pop perfection?

And sorry, mean girls ? really?

2 hours ago, chris1991 said:

I don't want to say anything because we are in senates times but this isn't good. Kinda free falling.

I will say it doesn't hold up as well as Beautiful Chaos. BC was kinda pop perfection, even mean girls.

WILD: 1-6-11
Beautiful Chaos: 4-15-24-48

It's holding up well compared to Beautiful Chaos first weeks and it's definitely not free falling. It's actually a very stable chart-run for an album, even more impressive with it being an EP.

Edited September 10Sep 10 by lipes

Oh wow oh wow, Adela with a song in the Top 10 and a 2nd song in Top 40 while Katseye keeps tumbling down the charts. I wonder if their label will stop the labubu music/lyrics seeing them flop on streaming compared to a rejected solo from the same show. This album is terrible and I'm glad nothing is sticking with the meme music.

Also I'm trying to imagine the gays in this thread going to a concert and being surrounded by 7 year old girls screaming pinky up! Is there no shame?

Imagine thinking that the EP is free falling when it's just barely out of the top 10, or the other saying that WILD didn't have a hit when Animal peaked at 4 and Hottie Frutti at 6.

The concept of not being able to celebrate one's success without talking bad about something you don't like seems to be pretty new, huh.

2 hours ago, Gaia said:

Oh wow oh wow, Adela with a song in the Top 10 and a 2nd song in Top 40 while Katseye keeps tumbling down the charts. I wonder if their label will stop the labubu music/lyrics seeing them flop on streaming compared to a rejected solo from the same show. This album is terrible and I'm glad nothing is sticking with the meme music.

Also I'm trying to imagine the gays in this thread going to a concert and being surrounded by 7 year old girls screaming pinky up! Is there no shame?

why are you here?

the way all 3 of their EPs are actually still charting on the BB200 for a 3rd week in a row

oh this generational girl group thank you kids

17 hours ago, foxfoxal said:

BC pop perfection?

And sorry, mean girls ? really?

You can laugh all you want, BC has a better score from Pitchfork.

Considering the complete basicness of Animal and the lack of spine of its songwriter, can we erase the track from their discography and stream PINKY UP and Hootie Frutti?

This era felt hot for one week I expected way more, especially seeing how Animal and Hootie are literally freefalling on Spotify Global as we speak

Can they please hurry and put Unloveu on streaming services? Easily their best song released.

1 hour ago, ZENO said:

Considering the complete basicness of Animal and the lack of spine of its songwriter, can we erase the track from their discography and stream PINKY UP and Hootie Frutti?

considering that it's about to become their 2nd top 10 on pop radio & likely campaigned for the scammys... prob not being erased any time soon (also what makes you believe the Pinky Up and Hootie writers are not spineless... like 99% of the industry )

1 hour ago, handsoffgabriela said:

This era felt hot for one week I expected way more, especially seeing how Animal and Hootie are literally freefalling on Spotify Global as we speak

it's lit a 5 track EP thats been out for a month, stable outperforming their previous 2.. combined. this era started back in April & they're currently on a sold out arena world tour. SNL in a few weeks. y'all are always unhappy

btw their 3 EPs have now spent an entire month charting simultaneously on the Billboard 200 (Wild remains top 20 and SIS/BC actually climbed this week)

anyway this is sending me

Edited September 15Sep 15 by okgo

Well, Lara's pinky is not the only finger up

Manon left off of Animal only for Ed Sheeran to get caught up in this mess...the lord really does work in mysterious ways

2 hours ago, ZENO said:

Well, Lara's pinky is not the only finger up

were they even following him?

1 hour ago, okgo said:

were they even following him?

Yeah, all of them unfollowed (minus Sophia).

I wonder if Animal will be kept on the set list (?)

Cancel "Animal", "Hootie Frutti", it's your time to shine sis!

pop radio's just not gonna back HF at all I fear.. plus the era will prob wrap as soon as the tour's done and they'll start recording (for the album?)

and not Lara's sister signing with HYBE but I thought they hated HYBE?? (#nootice how its Republic not Geffen tho ik both are UMG)

On 9/15/2026 at 5:32 PM, handsoffgabriela said:

This era felt hot for one week I expected way more, especially seeing how Animal and Hootie are literally freefalling on Spotify Global as we speak

Because Animal is faceless radio fodder and songs like HF which I think are interesting at least, always meant for short term shock value. The other 2 songs were always nonstarter cause 3/5 of the EP was always released and the songs are in actual kpop fashion were random chops to fill the EP but I know you meant the chart performance

I hope there is a LP but I can't even imagine what's it gonna sound like

On 9/15/2026 at 1:11 PM, toast said:

Manon left off of Animal only for Ed Sheeran to get caught up in this mess...the lord really does work in mysterious ways

Wait this tea!

On 9/15/2026 at 5:32 AM, handsoffgabriela said:

This era felt hot for one week I expected way more, especially seeing how Animal and Hootie are literally freefalling on Spotify Global as we speak

No I said the same thing before the EP came Out. Like 3 out of 5 songs were out before the EP was released or by the time it was released. They don't have much left to release. I think they still have appearances to make but over BC seemed to have a lot more longevity.

Also not Adela coming for their wig! She's killing it! Oh Hybe is mad!

no Sophia

They performed Animal and Hootie Frutti on SNL last night.

Again with the gaps for Sophia. It stopped being silly and now it's just not cute anymore.

There was also a skit but it's SNL, so it's never funny.

Edited Sunday at 11:34 AM5 days by KaledKalil

I think the performance was alright (though I've seen better/more energetic from them) but I wish someone else had sung Sophia's parts. It looked so weird, especially when they were playing Sophia's adlips. Surely for a live tv performance they could've rehearsed a modification. Still happy they got to do this iconic show and they truly have some of the best dancing abilities in a long time (aside from Tate probably)

they did so good and I don't mind them holding space for Sophia cuz we canNOT afford to lose her

People are always going to criticise them because the girls haven't had that huge smash hit yet. It's coming, all these EPs have been building the hype. It's a shame they got completely snubbed at the VMAs and didn't attend though.