Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Hilary Duff - 'luck… or something'

Locks Mar 1, 2027

Featured Replies

  • ATRL Moderator
32 minutes ago, Cherish said:

Why does mother hate Outlaw so much she made it a Fanjoy exclusive? gaycat7

The mean-mugging red-lace bra runner knew Outlaw was too powerful for the GP so she sacrificed it to preserve the careers of her peers I fear. Ms. HilCharity Duff indeed jamming

These mine versions are HITTING tonight. How in the world does Wake Up still sound as fresh as when I first heard it years ago intoit

  • Replies 7.6k
  • Views 319.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • The autopen thing is such a first world country problem lmao sorry but it's funny

  • Something don't sit right with me with people who solely care about dance pop Hilary. Like do y'all listen to any other types of music? This album is like a mature metamorphosis and I don't see how a

  • Yasin
    Yasin

    Weren't you the one making predictions last week and hoping she wouldn't chart? How did you feel when you saw her scoring her sixth top 5 album in a row with 83k? It looks like your autopen campaign d

1 hour ago, ItsRic said:

I think she's done with sparkly gliterry pop and her material will be more singer-songwriter kind of pop because This Heart was supposed to be the start of that and she finally accomplished that with this album. I don't see her going back tbh. I too miss it but she mentioned several times that this album needs to "sound like me" so this is her. And this is her sound.

Weather for Tennis actually sounded like an ELIO song to me when I first heard it so maybe that's the kind of pop we'll be getting, which fortunately I'm very into.

She's also aware that she has a predominant gay fanbase that are gonna want bops. At one point her music was bubblegum pop, pop rock, dance pop, edm pop, now folk indie song ? Sort of what Sabrina Carpenter is doing now. I think with the right material, influence she would give us a banger. This is a woman who has come around to claiming This Is What Dreams Are Made Of 20 years later so who knows and who would've ever expected her to revisit Metamorphosis ever and so fondly? Or make a musical return ever? Never say never with Hilary. Matthew Koma and her did work on Confetti, Breathe In Breathe Out and Arms Around A Memory together and they're pure pop perfection. Matthew also did alot of Carly's early music which was still pop and good. Pop is very versatile and doesn't always equate to it being untz untz

7 hours ago, Plasticdoll said:

Girl calm down. People are allowed to state their opinion over it. I don't like this era of shaming other fans if your opinion doesn't align with theirs or if you're not constantly praising every single damn thing.

"They show up out of no where" not everyone was on ATRL 20 years ago. There were various platforms for Hilary fans and some of us weren't even online as we were literally kids.

We are all enjoying the new music along with the upcoming tour, but we also don't need to be delusional and can call out her team.

If you want to "call her team out", fine, do whatever makes you feel better. But what's the point of spamming this thread multiple times a day about the autopen?

This thread has nothing to do with that, and most of us honestly don't care. Don't you have bigger concerns in your life than whether Hilary used an autopen?

Her job is to sing, not to sign autographs. Complaining because your "favorite" artist didn't hand-sign your copy, especially after returning to music following an 11-year break instead of enjoying her new music and celebrating her success, just seems unreasonable. It is unnecessarily negative and immature.

15 hours ago, Yasin said:

The negativity of some people here... Never seen them in any of her threads for 20 years, when we were just a few in here waiting for any music-related news from her, any picture in the studio... And then they show up from nowhere, complaining about autopen instead of enjoying the masterpiece which is luck or... something. What's the point of making multiple posts about autopen here?

Get yourself together and stop complaining like a spoiled child. If you don't like the album for what it is, ask for a refund and stop spamming this thread.

We get your point, she is a fraud with 0 sense of ethics. We're are very pleased with that and we are enjoying her music 🎶 🎉

She is a fraud, and I officially returned and received a refund. I hope others are able to return theirs before Billboard posts their weekly numbers. Will laugh when it drops thousands tbh. It's what she deserves gif.

5 minutes ago, on the line said:

She is a fraud, and I officially returned and received a refund. I hope others are able to return theirs before Billboard posts their weekly numbers. Will laugh when it drops thousands tbh. It's what she deserves gif.

chill-not-that-deep.gif

19 minutes ago, on the line said:

She is a fraud, and I officially returned and received a refund. I hope others are able to return theirs before Billboard posts their weekly numbers. Will laugh when it drops thousands tbh. It's what she deserves gif.

Haters.mp3

Lies.mp3

Mature.mp3

15 hours ago, broolprop3 said:

I always thought danger was about Joel and it was her response to the age difference that she got backlash

i need to find that documentary interview where she said it was about her friend dating an older man.

so pretty much Stranger & Danger were written on other peoples perspective. we love a songwriter.

21 minutes ago, DuffStan said:

Haters.mp3

Lies.mp3

Mature.mp3

I'm not surprised this is the response from a Hilary Duff stan.... lololol.

This dreadful experience with the Duff has just fortified how elite Taylor is and how much more enjoyable it is to be her fan receiving legitimate signed merch and yearly new releases.

Some artists should just stay... #soyesterday.

1 minute ago, on the line said:

I'm not surprised this is the response from a Hilary Duff stan.... lololol.

This dreadful experience with the Duff has just fortified how elite Taylor is and how much more enjoyable it is to be her fan receiving legitimate signed merch and yearly new releases.

Some artists should just stay... #soyesterday.

The same Taylor Hilary has inspired? Okay baby

9 minutes ago, drivers license said:

i need to find that documentary interview where she said it was about her friend dating an older man.

so pretty much Stranger & Danger were written on other peoples perspective. we love a songwriter.

Stranger is confirmed to be about her mom's perspective. I don't know if believe her when it comes to Danger 👀

Just finished Call Her Daddy, some funny things mentioned, Hilary said she went to the Freaky Friday premiere on purpose and Chad Michael Murray had invited her. She also said how she saw Lindsay in a club once and Lindsay asked her if they were good and then they had a shot together. Ha, fued over.

I actually think this is pitched really well for her sonically. The production and vocals sit somewhere on a spectrum between EMOTION and the 1989 vault.

I get why some people find that a little underwhelming and reductive, but I think this album lets her carve out a timeless pop niche which it'll be exciting to see her build on.

Any news when we're getting that Hilary Duff Documentary on Disney Plus

She literally had luck or something. Happy for the deserved success. She secured her hundreds of vacations for the upcoming years too.gaycatina1

1 hour ago, DuffStan said:

The same Taylor Hilary has inspired? Okay baby

Stranger is confirmed to be about her mom's perspective. I don't know if believe her when it comes to Danger 👀

there was something on twitter about this autopen discourse thing being mostly a certain group of weird Swifties. that response above is certainly telling! coffee

you're telling me someone with such hate for an artist ordered an album? it's giving bot behavior

Edited by Pikachu

50 minutes ago, Exzime. said:

Adult Sized Medium is so good heart

I cry everytime

To the people who keep coming in here and complaining about autopen, can you all file a complaint or something and just stop, we get it but it's annoying as hell and there's nothing anyone in here can do.

I bet Taylor Swift pays people to learn her signature and sign copies with her haha

I mean, let's be real, it's impossible to sign that amount of copies without getting a muscle problem in the hand.

Artists are human, remember when you had to write a lot in elementary school? Your hand gets sore. And you don't even write that much.

People are so entitled. She didn't charge more for an auto pen sign.

42 minutes ago, Roger said:

I bet Taylor Swift pays people to learn her signature and sign copies with her haha

I mean, let's be real, it's impossible to sign that amount of copies without getting a muscle problem in the hand.

Artists are human, remember when you had to write a lot in elementary school? Your hand gets sore. And you don't even write that much.

People are so entitled. She didn't charge more for an auto pen sign.

It is not entitled to expect to receive what you were sold. Advocate for better for yourself, sis, because you deserve it too.

I hope for the next album shell return to her older sound rather than this "folk pop" sound (that's how I view it)

4 hours ago, Yasin said:

If you want to "call her team out", fine, do whatever makes you feel better. But what's the point of spamming this thread multiple times a day about the autopen?

This thread has nothing to do with that, and most of us honestly don't care. Don't you have bigger concerns in your life than whether Hilary used an autopen?

Her job is to sing, not to sign autographs. Complaining because your "favorite" artist didn't hand-sign your copy, especially after returning to music following an 11-year break instead of enjoying her new music and celebrating her success, just seems unreasonable. It is unnecessarily negative and immature.

Spamming? About 20 other users have commented about it on this thread. it seems like you want the thread to be a dictatorship where you can't talk about it. it literally went viral on the internet and it is album related. There has been conversation back and forth between users on the topic, I wouldn't consider that spamming. you honestly seem overly sensitive and dramatic. If you want to live in a fluffy sugarcoated fantasy land, good for you.

It's honestly wild how we have fans in this thread trying to gaslit and guilt trip others into thinking otherwise.

I've already said the music and the rest of the era is amazing several times. Now move on.

Edited by Plasticdoll

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.