current ranking

1. Roommates

2. Weather for Tennis

3. Holiday Party

4. Tell Me That Won't Happen

5. Mature

6. Future Tripping

7. We Don't Talk

8. Adult Size Medium

9. Growing Up

10. The Optimist

11. You, From the Honeymoon

On 2/23/2026 at 9:05 PM, rcksluke said:

album is at

But there's less buzz than BIBO @NoAngelus said

On 2/23/2026 at 9:30 PM, SafeAndSound said:

And pushing for a top 5 debut in the UK (already her best position ever there), she is so back. Let me try and get the Walmart edition real quick. You there, @NoAngelus ?

First of all why are you quoting me as some kind of a gotcha moment when I've been rooting for her?

Second of all, numbers are absolutely amazing and so high i hope she debuts at #3 but let's do the math (if you can't get out out of equation)

Variants obviously helped even if we assume every fan who bough BIBO bought at least 2 variants we have our first week sales. Unfortunately streaming IS showing that there is no hype since both singles are already back at doing barely 150k streams per day and we are still in first week. Album will struggle to reach Sparks' streaming numbers by the end of the year, let alone BIBO's total streams.

So yeah, I'm still right even if you hate it because at the end of the day streaming is unfortunately only indicator of success these days and album will drop out of charts in week 2... so should I quote you back when it fails to outlast BIBOP and outstream it?

Like I said, high debut week and tour is already huge success.

She's unlucky she peaked busy week because those numbers could've landed her #1 in other weeks or at least sure fire top 3 debut

my order has been refunded so i can go back to stanning

Okay the Call me Daddy interview was actually really good!

I think a big part of the success playing into this comeback is because Hilary's really grown into herself. I mean, most of her career has been subjected to other people telling her what to do. Which explains why she's felt so uncomfortable in previous musical eras.

And now she's found a sound that works for her, she's making deliberate career choices, but most importantly, she's making music she wants to make. And that confidence just radiates off of her.

Who can take a ten year hiatus, come back from that, outdo the first week performance of your last album and double that, not to mention the public and critical reception to the music?

This truly is a career highlight for her

15 hours ago, SchmoodRing said:

Someone @ Matthew Koma to get to her record This Heart (Is Mine) asap

Said no one ever lol

If she wasn't a gay icon before this album solidified it

The irony considering the way her life went and had gone if anything that album became unintentionally biographical

Can you somehow reach out to her and get her to release these officially. Petition for This Heart (Is Mine)

I mean it was leaked and never officially properly mastered or released so of course it's gonna sound like unpolished demos lol

The irony considering that's a sound that she loves and has been wanting to make and what we essentially got with Luck Or Something 😆

it is better than her last album - really sparks?

5 minutes ago, NoAngelus said:

First of all why are you quoting me as some kind of a gotcha moment when I've been rooting for her?

Second of all, numbers are absolutely amazing and so high i hope she debuts at #3 but let's do the math (if you can't get out out of equation)

Variants obviously helped even if we assume every fan who bough BIBO bought at least 2 variants we have our first week sales. Unfortunately streaming IS showing that there is no hype since both singles are already back at doing barely 150k streams per day and we are still in first week. Album will struggle to reach Sparks' streaming numbers by the end of the year, let alone BIBO's total streams.

So yeah, I'm still right even if you hate it because at the end of the day streaming is unfortunately only indicator of success these days and album will drop out of charts in week 2... so should I quote you back when it fails to outlast BIBOP and outstream it?

Like I said, high debut week and tour is already huge success.

She's unlucky she peaked busy week because those numbers could've landed her #1 in other weeks or at least sure fire top 3 debut

no, you were absolutely wrong, even if you hate it. Idk why you're doubling down looking dumb...but whatever floats your boat.

7 minutes ago, NoAngelus said:

First of all why are you quoting me as some kind of a gotcha moment when I've been rooting for her?

Second of all, numbers are absolutely amazing and so high i hope she debuts at #3 but let's do the math (if you can't get out out of equation)

Variants obviously helped even if we assume every fan who bough BIBO bought at least 2 variants we have our first week sales. Unfortunately streaming IS showing that there is no hype since both singles are already back at doing barely 150k streams per day and we are still in first week. Album will struggle to reach Sparks' streaming numbers by the end of the year, let alone BIBO's total streams.

So yeah, I'm still right even if you hate it because at the end of the day streaming is unfortunately only indicator of success these days and album will drop out of charts in week 2... so should I quote you back when it fails to outlast BIBOP and outstream it?

Like I said, high debut week and tour is already huge success.

She's unlucky she peaked busy week because those numbers could've landed her #1 in other weeks or at least sure fire top 3 debut

In what world is streaming the only metric for success? You're just being a negative nancy

IN MY IMA-GI-NA-TION

10 minutes ago, 50thStateofMind said:

no, you were absolutely wrong, even if you hate it. Idk why you're doubling down looking dumb...but whatever floats your boat.

Streaming is on my side so deal with it. Fans pulled through by mass buying variants, there is still no hype outside of them since album won't reach total streams of Sparks within its first year of release... And streaming grew like 1000% in last 11 years.

2 minutes ago, Golden said:

In what world is streaming the only metric for success? You're just being a negative nancy

Are you seriously asking that in 2026 when 99,999999999% of albums that are charting beyond first week sales are charting only based on streaming?

1 hour ago, rcksluke said:

So is it dead on Pop?

2 hours ago, on the line said:

Absolutely wild how people are giving her a pass for lying, doubling down on the lie, and then even tripling down on the lie. Not a kind of person I want to stan at all so happily, good ******* bye.

And yet nobody cares about your autopen situation. We're here just to enjoy the music and that's it. Your just being inssuferable.

My top 5 so far

1. Holiday Party

2. Weather for Tennis

3. Roomates

4. The Optimist

5. Growing Up/We Don't Talk

28 minutes ago, headztrong said:

my order has been refunded so i can go back to stanning

girl not now.. I would of stanned regardless.

Edited February 25Feb 25 by Plasticdoll

14 minutes ago, NoAngelus said:

Are you seriously asking that in 2026 when 99,999999999% of albums that are charting beyond first week sales are charting only based on streaming?

Okay we get it you have a weird fixation on streaming but luckily most of us are a little smarter than that

1 minute ago, Golden said:

Okay we get it you have a weird fixation on streaming but luckily most of us are a little smarter than that

Are charts based on you being smart or actually streaming figures?

Is streaming indicator of what people are listening?

Is it doing better than BIBO? The answer is unfortunately no.

16 hours ago, SchmoodRing said:

Someone @ Matthew Koma to get to her record This Heart (Is Mine) asap

I want that so badly.

3 hours ago, broolprop3 said:

I'm so sick of you people attacking Hilary for auto pen

It sucks that she did this but cmon give the girl a break

Do you really think Taylor is

Signing Every album with the millions

She Sells a week

Leave Hilary alone She drops a new album every 10 years

We don't know if this is Atlantic doing not her

Because. Her roll out was similar to Taylor

So maybe this is the new way albums will be released

Them crazy Tay Tay fans always comparing and champion her in the dumbest things. It's OBVIOUS that an artists with huge sales won't be able to sign that amount of times, no human can, it's painful and tiring.

I think an autopen feels less scammy that hiring people to learn a signature and sign for Taylor (or any other artist with a huge fanbase).

Besides Hilary is too busy being a mom and a singer to even know if their team are selling autopen vinyls or not, she trusted her team and sadly they did the wrong decision.

3 hours ago, Afterglow said:

Girl that would break Netflix' already unstable servers but that would probably end up being another career high for the both of them. A Broad City-esque show but about them being frenemies would kinda slay idk

Totally.

Anything with them would be a stellar hit.

Call Her Daddy one of the best interviews of her career and it's getting tons of press and good numbers BUT I want Hilary to really do an interview that's a deep dive on her career and past projects.

8 minutes ago, Stepfon said:

Call Her Daddy one of the best interviews of her career and it's getting tons of press and good numbers BUT I want Hilary to really do an interview that's a deep dive on her career and past projects.

I would love an interview like miley did when Something Beautiful came out and she talked about all of the albums

I wish she could do what Björk did years ago, a podcast show with every episode talking about each album.

I want her to invite producers from her past album to talk about the making of every album.

this album is so good

9 minutes ago, Roger said:

I wish she could do what Björk did years ago, a podcast show with every episode talking about each album.

I want her to invite producers from her past album to talk about the making of every album.

wow, that would be great!
It would even help her remember all that stuff she always complains about having forgotten.

Hilary Duff on Her Influences, Taste, and Returning to Music | Marie Claire

Hilary saying she wants to collab with Alanis! Atlantic, make it happen!

Nice album, not better than Dignity and BIBO though.

Faves for now:

Roommates

Holiday Party

Growing Up

The Optimist

Mature