Between releasing her debut mixtape In Case We Die in February, 2012, and her most recent record Quantum Baby in August, 2024, Tinashe has amassed one of the most impressive discographies of the century, in my honest opinion.

 

It's time for you to rank these masterpieces from your favourite to your least favourite. Any additional commentary is more than welcome.

 

4 mixtapes and 7 studio albums.

 

Edited September 6, 20242 yr by °ColdFire°

Nightride

Songs for You

Aquarius

333

In Case We Die

BB/Ang3l

Joyride

Quantum Baby

Reverie

Black Water

Amethyst

 

The fact that I would not have a problem listening any of them at any time speaks for itself. 

I know I'm being a bad stan but I haven't gotten around to Quantum Baby in full yet and I also haven't listened to the mixtapes in full to be honest.

 

So...

Songs For You: what a body of work. my favourite by far so eclectic - it's warm and fun in parts and introspective in others. it is filled with finesse.

333: the singles and their videos ate so much and it's got lots of gems.

Aquarius

Nightride

BB/Angel

Joyride

BB/ANG3L

Nightride

Quantum Baby

333

Aquarius

Amethyst

Black Water

Songs for you

Don't care for the others

Why do people like Songs For You so much? I just genuinely don't get it

It's been a minute since I heard the mixtapes, but...

 

Songs For You

Nightride

333

Aquarius

Amethyst

In Case We Die

Joyride

Quantum Baby [Tentative Position!]

BB/ANG3L

Black Water

Reverie

Edited September 6, 20242 yr by Graves

BB/ANG3L

333

Nightride

Aquarius

Quantum Baby

Songs for You

(cliff)

Joyride

 

Haven't listened to the mixtapes. I think BB/ANG3L and 333 are kinda tied, but I gave BB/ANG3L the edge because I listen to it a lot more since it's shorter.

1. Songs For You

2. Aquarius

————————

3. Nightride

4. 333

————————

The rest.

I'm not sure how I'd rank them but amethyst and nightride will always be her best albums 

nightride

aquarius

amethyst

songs for you

333

 

the rest.

Nightride

333

Aquarius

BB/Ang3l

Songs for You

Amethyst

In Case We Die

Reverie

Black Water

Quantum Baby

Joyride

 

333 and Nightride alternate for #1 but I'd probably give to it the latter because it's a less bloated album.

Nightride

Songs For You

333

Black Water

Aquarius

Amethyst

BB/ANG3L

Quantum Baby

In Case We Die

Reverie

Joyride

1 hour ago, massenlight said:

Why do people like Songs For You so much? I just genuinely don't get it

I think that's the album that a lot of people on here discovered her with/properly got into her + it's tied into her narrative of taking back control after all of her label drama. It's got a heavier pop influence than her earlier stuff too.

 

OT:

Nightride

Aquarius 

Reverie

Black Water

BB/Ang3l

333

Songs for you

Joyride

Amethyst

In Case We Die

Quantum Baby

 

I can't remember how Amethyst or In Case We Die sound apart from Chainless (bop), and Quantum Baby is the weakest project I've heard from her unfortunately. I basically love everything else (maybe only half of Joyride).

Edited September 6, 20242 yr by glitch

Songs For You

333

Nightride

Aquarius

BB/ANG3L

Quantum Baby

Joyride

 

Haven't listened to the mixtapes 

Nightride 

333

BB Angel / Songs For You

Gonna go with Quantum Baby for now, I can't get enough

This is difficult because Tinashe's discography is strong and varied.
There are moments when I prefer Nightride, some days I blast BB/ANG3L, and others where I want to listen to In Case We Die.

Honestly, the only two releases that didn't blow me away was Songs For You and Quantum Baby.

Aquarius
In Case We Die
Nightride
BB/Ang3l
Black Water
333
Amethyst
Songs for You
Quantum Baby
Reverie
Joyride

BB/Ang3l

Nightride

333

Aquarius

Quantum Baby

Amethyst

In Case We Die

Reverie

Songs for You

Black Water

Joyride

Im a bad fan and i have only listened some of them

So,

333
Nightride
Joyride
Quantum Baby
BB Angel
Songs For You
 

Songs For You

Aquarius

Amethyst

 

the rest 

Nightride

Aquarius

Songs for You

BB/Ang3l

333

 

Reverie

Black Water

Quantum Baby

Amethyst

 

Joyride

In Case We Die

 

Amazing discography! I like everything.

 

 

Songs for You

Nightride

333
Aquarius

BB/ANG3L

Quantum Baby

In Case We Die

Amethyst

Black Water

Reverie

Joyride

accidentally ended up voted SFY but 

 

Nightride

In Case We Die

Songs for You

Quantum Baby

BB/Ang3l

Amethyst

333

Aquarius

Black Water

Joyride

Reverie

 

and they're all so perfect 

I must be the only fan that kinda prefers Joyride to Nightride  y'all doing Joyride dirty. 

 

Anyway, my fav album is Songs For You. Then 333, Joyride, Aquarius and BB/Angel would round out my top 5.

 

Also, does no one use the Comfort and Joy EP? 

Edited September 7, 20242 yr by Soda Pop Queen