Britney:

 

Rihanna:

Rihanna for shut up and drive alone 

This is tough but "If that's lovin that you want" gives Rih the slight edge.

Britney 

Britney and it isnt close 

Britney across the board 

Rihanna only because she didn't release Perfume 

Do Something >>> anything Rihanna’s ever released 

 

Britney for me

Britney

 

btw, stop comparing Britney to other pop stars, she will always win. 

 

 

 

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

 

Brit: 3

Rih: 5 

 

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

 

 

Rih: 5

Brit: 4

Rihanna for kiss it better alone.

This is giving set up! 
 

Rihanna..

2 hours ago, Venice B said:

Rihanna only because she didn't release Perfume 

I love them both so I tried comparing song by song & it was a tie with 4 each lol so I'm gonna go with this answer too, perfume was awful.

rihanna for kiss it better alone

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

 

 

Britney, Rihanna's second singles are probably my least singles of her

Perfume is a mess, never liked it; Slumber Party deserved better, one of her best songs in years and the video is flawless.

Edited March 11, 20242 yr by ReachOut

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

 

Rihanna

Edited March 11, 20242 yr by RihannaLoverrr

l

58 minutes ago, ReachOut said:

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

. 

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

 

 

Tbh its kinda a tie, and I say this as a Rih stan 

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

Britney by lightyears but Shut Up and Unfaithful are so good

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

 

 

A tie, but Rih wins overall because she doesn't have a second single as weak as Perfume or Slumber Party

Sometimes vs If It's Lovin' That You Want

Lucky vs Unfaithful

Overprotected vs Shut Up and Drive

Toxic vs Hard

Do Somethin' vs What's My Name?

Piece of Me vs You Da One

Circus vs Stay

Til the World Ends vs Kiss It Better

 

Riri 7 - Brit 3