Which one do you prefer?

 

The 6 week #2 peaking single "Shake It Off" blocked by her own "We Belong Together" and Kanye's "Gold Digger" or the two week #1 "Touch My Body"

 

 

 

By the time you get this message, it's gonna be too late
So don't bother paging me 'cause I'll be on my way
See, I grabbed all my diamonds and clothes
Just ask your momma she knows
You're gonna miss me, baby
Hate to say I told you so

Touch My Body devours.

 

Shake It Off and it's not even close

 

the shake it off singer.

I love both but prefer Shake It Off, all of the Mimi singles are so good

Shake It Off is okay, while Touch My Body is a bop. So the latter wins.

Let's ask @suburbannature 

Just now, Kayseri Mantisi said:

Let's ask @suburbannature 

Lets not.

 

This 

 

 

Shake It Off is timeless and could still come out today with slight changes. It easily devours Touch My Body, which was only the third best single off Einstein.

Touch My Body>>>>>

Touch My Body. 

SIO is a great breakup song, easy breezy, but TMB feels so playful and catchy.

Love Touch My Body but Shake It Off is just that girl; both are great examples of the mightiness of Mariah's PEN because she can write a catchy song but it's going to be catchy AND well written

They’re both SO good. I think the slight edge goes to Shake it Off though, what a masterpiece  

Shake It Off

Shake It Off is just slaps every time so that

TMB is also 10/10 tho 

Touch My Body is a lot of fun, and the video is great, which isn't something a person usually says about a Mariah Carey video.  But this one is spot-on. 

5 minutes ago, spree said:

Touch My Body is a lot of fun, and the video is great, which isn't something a person usually says about a Mariah Carey video.  But this one is spot-on. 

If they missed the entire Emancipation and Butterfly eras, Heartbreaker, TMB, Obsessed, etc maybe? 
 

only artist to win an international Video Vanguard for a reason, I fear.

Oof both are so good. I don't think I can choose.

Touch My Body is the only Mariah song I liked while it was current, so definitely that.

 

 

Overall they’re pretty tied but lately SIO