Chromatica for all...

Both of these solid albums were panned by their success-obsessed fanbases for not generating diamond singles and are divisive to this day because of mentally ill manchildren's collective inability to let go of the past. Interesting comparison.

 

 

Chromatica for all but Witness is grossly underrated, it might have a better shot as an album if the tracklist wasn't so bloated. 

Edited October 10, 20232 yr by Century

Chromatica clears effortlessly. 

As much as I loathe to say it, Witless is the better album and has the better singles. Cosmetica does have the better cover, but that hardly means much when the competition was designed in a lab to be as unsettling as possible 

I think Witness isn’t a bad album. Just because it didn’t smash people drag it.

 

I enjoy more songs on Witness. Katy for all!

Chromatica for all. There are like 4/5 songs from Sh*tness that I sorta like and the cover is tragic. 

Chromatica is a genuinely enjoyable album with only a few skips. I’ve never understood the hate it gets.

 

Witness, on the other hand, has a handful of good songs, and a bunch of confused songs that aged poorly the second they were released 

Chromatica for all.

So random 

 

Witness is absolute garbage. Let's be real for a second

Edited October 10, 20232 yr by ahauntingnearu

Chromatica is the better album and I voted Witness for better singles but I was only thinking of the 3 first cuz the other songs... idk ha

 Off course Witness 

Roulette + Witness + Bon Appetite + Act my age + Chained to the rhythm 

I actually revisit some Witness tracks

I can’t remember the last time I listened to Chromatica, most of it was a complete miss to me

48 minutes ago, BletaRexher said:

I actually revisit some Witness tracks

I can’t remember the last time I listened to Chromatica, most of it was a complete miss to me

Replay, Rain On Me, Babylon and Alice too? Most people who hate the album still end up calling those 4 songs fantastic lol 

 

 

Witness for all, like another writer said I haven't touched Chromatica since it came out

Witness is more listenable to me.

 

Swish Swish is an underrated bop.

Chromatica duh 

Chromatica washes

Both are among the worst "MPG" albums ever released.

Chromatica is a 5 and Witness is a 4… a 5 still beats a 4. Witness edges it out for singles due to “Bon Appetit” though.

Witness is pretty boring overall but has some stand out tracks (the 3 main singles, witness, roulette). I'm a OChromaticaH tho, #NotMyGaga. 911 is a career high and RoM, Sour Candy and Replay are cute tho, also the cover is great.

Chromatica

Chromatica wins for me. Witness has some good songs, it's just in dire need of some trimming.

I don't use Chromatica anymore but I do still listen to Witness instrumentals so...

 

Chromatica has the better album cover.

4 hours ago, smoore95GAGA said:

Chromatica is a genuinely enjoyable album with only a few skips. I’ve never understood the hate it gets.

 

Witness, on the other hand, has a handful of good songs, and a bunch of confused songs that aged poorly the second they were released 

Maybe people are hanging their pandemic baggage on it idk, it's her best critically received album for a reason