4Real

Confessions II

So bad she made the follow-up even worse so this would look like a masterpiece in retrospect but sadly for her it didn't work

Eldest Daughter is the worst cuz she's serious about it

And when she charmingly says "honeyyy"

The fate of ophelia Opalite Elizabeth Taylor Father Figure Patient Zero Ruin the friendship Wish list Pink Clouding Honey Babylon

Wish List is cute, if you ignore the lyrics. Another bop is Honey. It's very corny, like a Lover track, and we know Lover = quality

The critical reception to this is definitely a revaluation of the OG album + the audacity of hers to release a deluxe for it (even tho the tracks aren't necessarily bad except for one), combined with the constant releasing and the idea that her creative fluids aren't that strong anymore because of it (which is probably true). Taylor would never get a red rated album on metacritic, regardless of its quality, if she didn't release music yearly.

Finally arranged a Chopgirl 10-track playlist that i can listen to once a while, stan card renewed

The fate of ophelia was her last hurrah

I don't even completely hate the songs, i just don't see how this was a necessary release, especially when she had the perfect setup for debut tv/20 years anniversary. Unless she will still release that but it feels like this one just ruined the vibe.

She is so overrated

I'm not deleting any songs from any playlists sorry, but i don't even listen to her that much nowadays anyways

Opalite aged like spoiled milk in Mercury but you spilled with the rest

I'm kind of a Billie hater but BOAF is so much better than that other song. Talent lost.

Competition is very low so no

Physical is the least gayconic out of these but i could never get the appeal of Dancing on my own

It can't be a true smash without a real smash hit

The fun of Red is that it's all over the place, in a way that it never gets boring, with (almost) every sing being perfection. WANEGOD, IKYWT and 22 are her best pop singles

A quick country soundtrack single vs Olivia's "SMASH" hit. Come back when she gets a song as big as Ophelia (in her 12th album 19 years into her career)

Lack of competition

Tew bad they can't give the gurl in your avi a hit since 2021

Atrlers giving MAGA antivaxx levels of denial in this thread IKIIKY simply is a smasha

It's just the beginning of the end for her

The grammys better show her this amount of love as well

All i can see with this list is that Taylor is very underrated