MDNA is bad for her standards but let's still have the tiniest bit of respect for the queen of pop 

I prefer Lotus by far. This and Unapologetic were my soundtracks to the fall of 2012

I honesty don't think Lotus is as bad as people make it out to be it was just bad for Xtina standards. 

I love lotus but it's not a good album

Mdna isn't fantastic either but better

MDNA isn't actually as bad as people make it out to be. Girl Gone Wild, I'm Addicted, Gang Bang, Some Girls, Love Spent, Masterpiece and Best Friend are all great songs. 

 

Lotus was AI pop music before AI was even a thing 

Please… MDNA is so much better than that microwaved mixtape slop called Lotus. Not even Xtina took that album seriously.

Lotus, easily.

 

Outside of Make The World Move, all the songs of Lotus are at least listenable. The majority of MDNA is just a headache inducing mess.

just a fool alone is better than that mess

I don't remember even one songs from Lotus

On the other hand I remember how bad the songs on MDNA are. So MDNA wins, cut at least I remembered it. 

The one that has Falling Free and Masterpiece

Lettuce is healthy. MDMA is bad for your health.

MDNA has "Falling Free."

Legend Of The United States has "Red Hot Kinda Love."

Difficult because Lotus has the hymn that is Your Body, but MDNA has the hymn that is Beautiful Killer

 

Mdna is much better 

MDNA by far. Yeah some songs were messy but somehow it kinda works sonically.

As body of work Lotus just goes all kinds of ways, and I still hate whoever did the vocal production on some of these songs

MDNA

 

Trump wasn't a thing the last time I've listened to "Lotus"

Edited November 25, 2025Nov 25 by ttsmu

Both are BAD but MDMA is more listenable 

 

Miles Away is already bigger and better than entire Xtina's discography and I'm being generous. 

MDNA >>>