blueberries

autoplay

Because they have their own MPGs Ayumi and Utada are easily top 10 biggest 2000s female popstars worldwide from their Japanese sales alone

no, it's about having timeless catalog and talent kate bush is a legend yet she's never had blockbuster sales

an indefinite long hiatus, she's getting overexposed and in a negative way

annoying karen

It's Taylor's fault, Jack Antonoff is a stellar producer yet TTPD was considered a disappointment.

i don't think her career is over but any chances of building a loyal and big fanbase ended when she chose to get rid of her disney girl image in the worst way in 2013, it worked at the time but in the long run it only turned off people who grew up with and looked up to her

300k

Madonna tried to come for Mariah first and got clocked Xtina was always bitter and pressed

b-b-but tmz!!!11, she kissed madonna, shaved her head etc

ciara rebecca black britney spears

they said the same about katy perry in her 3rd album

Gaga had smash hits for 3 decades Britney was only "good" at charting in 2008-2011 That's like comparing Mariah Carey chart history to Ashlee Simpson's

never heard of it and they said taylor's hits are unknown

the bruno drag doesn't work anymore he released an album and it failed to outdo mayhem

i'm so glad i lived through her debut era, now that pop music is boring and lifeless i guess it was an once in a lifetime thing

i'd rather a yearly release as long as the albums are good but for me an album every 2-3 years is ideal i hate when artists take like 4+ years to release an album at their peak, it's not about quality and taking their time anymore it's just laziness

Mariah, Taylor and Gaga Beyoncé is the opposite, idg why people are mentioning her but whatever

i'm surprised it didn't drop out at least she got a #1 album in 3 different decades which is nice

that janet album is doing 64k daily streams right now, they should listen to it more instead of hating on artists that didn't stop being relevant in yestermillennium

as much as it hurts you guys need to let it go and accept that katy perry is undeniably over, constantly bringing up a 16 year old era is embarrassing sorry

i'm just kikiing at the fact that even if you take away the debut week she still ended cowboy carter

rock steady if her no doubt stuff counts, her solo albums are horrid

isn't baby boy known for being one of the worst selling #1's? not surprised at all