vs

 

Honey but All For You is honestly just as excellent. 
 

Man what an incredible time in music..

Both are amazing. I absolutely cannot choose. 

Edited June 22, 20242 yr by Migs

Are y'all crazy i'm not choosing

janet for all

I also cannot pick at all.

Both iconic, but I give the edge to Honey bc it's peak Mariah and i'd put at least four other Janet eras above AFY (and someone to call my lover is my fav video of that era) 

Edited June 22, 20242 yr by liquiddiamonds

I love both, but Honey for all.

A4U

Honey
 

honey

All For You for all 3. It's also the much bigger song. Honey is cute though

 both excellent but honey >>>>>>>>>

all for you , much more remembered & bigger 

All For You is such a great song. Honey is good too.

Honey (Bad Boy Remix) > All For You > Honey

1. Single: Honey > All For You

2. MV: Honey 4K >>>>>All For You

 

3. 2024: Honey> All For You

All For You (Music)

 

Honey (music video)

All for You in all departments. Honey is good but yeez, the stans do the most with it. It ain't even Butterfly's best single.

I adore Janet, but Honey is just that *****.

AFY is just pop excellence.

#1 and #3 are the same question.

 

Anyway, Honey for all easily. 

Edited June 22, 20242 yr by Loca

All for you for everything. The sole comparison is offensive. 

Robyn's Honey >>>

I adore All For You but Honey is just that song. My favourite Mariah song along with Close My Eyes. So Honey to me is better by a small amount.

 

Both excellent videos, but Honey's video is by far Mariah's best. So again Honey.

 

And as for which aged best: both, there's no answer to that. I voted for All For You since I thought Honey was gonna win by a relatively large margin. I'm surprised to see that the results are pretty much equal, but All For You is easily wonderful too.