Which of these moderate hits by two of the biggest pop girls of our time is the bigger?

 

Yes, And? had the bigger first week and a higher peak, but as a regular top-40 radio listener (for whatever that's worth as a metric of size...), Karma felt like it was decently big for several months, and I literally never heard Yes, And? after it's second or third week. 

"Karma"

Jojo Siwa's Karma, I fear 

Alicia's karma hands down

Girl which Karma

 

anyways, voted Karma because anything is bigger than No, But!

Yes and, especially globally 

Even though yes, and? debuted at #1, Karma still feels like a bigger hit than it. yes, and? only spent 13 weeks on the Hot 100 while Karma spent around 30 weeks. It's also a bigger radio hit as both Top 40 and HAC stations play it still. 

Don't think I have ever heard yes, and in public, but Karma is everywhere.

Yes,and? 

My Kink is Karma

karma i fear. yes, and was a nonevent and only made noise for, like, a day. the eras tour gave karma legs.

Karma spent more weeks in the top 10 (I think it spent 8 weeks if I'm not mistaken). 

Karma

 

i hear it getting played in public while yes, and on the otherhand…