Both ballads about the loss of a loved one, with circus themed videos and were released as the 2nd singles of their 2006 eras I'm Not Dead and Back to Basics

 

But which one do you prefer?

 

Which one is more iconic?

 

Which video do you prefer?

 

 

 

 

 

 

I don't think either of them are 'iconic' but Hurt is a better song by miles and Who Knew is more well known.

I can’t split them, they are both the peaks of the artists discography. The Hurt music video is much much much better however.

Who Knew wins by every metric. 

Johnny Cash's Hurt > Who Knew > Xtina's Hurt

i prefer Hurt because of the video but wow, these two were really having a mid off in the 2000s 

Hurt for all again 

 

WK is great too tho

Who Knew for all. Amazing song.

 

Hurt is cute too.

4 minutes ago, shyboi said:

i prefer Hurt because of the video but wow, these two were really having a mid off in the 2000s 

sis these were quality songs of the 2000s 

Who Knew for all

 

but I do like Hurt too!

Idky but Who Knew has always been an irritating song 

Hurt

 

It features Legendtina's legendary vocals

Hurt >>>> don’t know the other girl

Both top tier, Pink is my fave so Who Knew

Hurt is so powerful and gut punching. Like a cautionary tale to speak to your estranged loved ones, before it's too late (or come out to them). 

Who Knew is more catchy and passive, but not as moving.

6 hours ago, shyboi said:

i prefer Hurt because of the video but wow, these two were really having a mid off in the 2000s 

Girl please p!nk has had 20 years of longevity and acclaim others can only dream of for a reason. Who knew is a classic (the other one totally forgotten)

I love both songs but I think I prefer Who Knew.

Hurt for all

Both Who Knew and Pink are extremely annoying, so going up against one of Xtina's best is not going to pan well for them I fear

 

 

Hurt for all.

 

I’ve never liked Who Knew.

Hurt >>>>

The best song of all time - Who Knew

I love Hurt but Who Knew clears!

Who Know is a beautiful song, but Hurt is on another level. Christina was onto something during Back To Basics.

I'm quite surprised by the results. I mean, "Hurt" is one of the most beautiful and stunning ballads of the century, the power it has, oh my God... WK is cute.