44 minutes ago, HeavyMetalAura said:

Is she, though? In the past ten years, since 2014, we've gotten:

 

2 jazz albums

1 folk-inspired pop album

1 folk-inspired soundtrack album

a bunch of one-off singles like Hold My Hand, Sweet Sound of Heaven, Don't Let me Be Misunderstood, Your Song, etc

..... and Chromatica. 

 

She may be known as a dance pop artist primarily, but in a literal sense, she hasn't been one since 2013.  For the past decade she's released more folk/country inspired pop and jazz than dance music. 

 

I still don't want her to ditch dance pop, but it makes perfect sense for the fans who've stuck around this long to not be that interested in it anymore. It's not like she's been catering to us. 

The vast majority of Gaga’s hits are dance pop. Shallow, ARUTW, and MR are the exceptions. Hasn’t everyone been complaining about jazz since LFS? If we only get a proper dance-pop album every decade then this base is gonna dwindle fast.

6 minutes ago, Dawn the Jockey said:

NURSE!

 

 

He’s so annoying  if anything the fact that she added instruments like the saxophone to a track is almost a confirmation that something is coming this year  

No one will be buying a rock album from her be serious rn

It better be pop with rock elements 

5 minutes ago, chosensparkles said:

Is that THAT MEMBER personal account?

  Hide contents

NURSE INDEED

 

I’m waiting for the anonymous Reddit post 

When Gar serves her WTF Do I Know 

 

 

 

10 minutes ago, Dawn the Jockey said:

NURSE!

 

 

8 minutes ago, DonnieDarko said:

Every Gaga album is better than PH. Yes, even ARTPOP and Joanne.

 Respectfully I disagree 

Btw, Ariana was just dropping studio pics and still released her lead and announced her album 

2 minutes ago, Enzo said:

No one will be buying a rock album from her be serious rn

It better be pop with rock elements 

This is simply false, changing genres can be very profitable. Look at what Ray Of Light did for Madonna 

Also, no Plastic Hearts slander will be tolerated

BURNS, Watt and Gaga herself as lead producers with additional production by Gesaffelstein and Jorge Elbrecht we hea

 

3 minutes ago, ToniGaga96 said:

This is simply false, changing genres can be very profitable. Look at what Ray Of Light did for Madonna 

Why do people think Rock is so far off for Gaga? lol 

She's always had that rocker vibe to her, if anything country was a bigger shock than rock 

34 minutes ago, Kimi said:

girl no, country and very soft rock. literally not folk at all

I wouldnt call ARUTW country/soft rock… but whatever

4 minutes ago, Enzo said:

Also, no Plastic Hearts slander will be tolerated

In not shading it, it is better than certain dance pop album from 2020 but imo gar could do something even better 

The fact that BURNS alone produced Replay, his mind it amazes me sometimes, I hope he's actually involved in LG7 

some of yall just want another ARTPOP and it shows.

 

1 minute ago, toy soldier. said:

Why do people think Rock is so far off for Gaga? lol 

She's always had that rocker vibe to her, if anything country was a bigger shock than rock 

I totally agree, the monster ball was very “rock” for a pop show 

I would love for BURNS to be involved. He’s clearly one of the very best producers that worked with her ever since the start of her career.

 

Edited February 4, 20242 yr by DonnieDarko

Dance pop is regarded as dated sound these days. Most of the successful/critically accalaimed record of last years are alt pop (Troye, Pink Pantheless, New Jeans, Taylor, Tate)

Thats why I was hoping her to gets away from dance pop route but this rock route is baffling frankly

3 minutes ago, toy soldier. said:

Why do people think Rock is so far off for Gaga? lol 

She's always had that rocker vibe to her, if anything country was a bigger shock than rock 

This. She's had at least one rock/rock-leaning song in every one of her albums since The Fame.  And her many public performances and songs with rock groups demonstrates that she has the chops to deliver great rock music. 

 

At this point the only shocking genre changes Gaga could do within the realm of popular music is R&B or hip-hop.

9 minutes ago, ToniGaga96 said:

This is simply false, changing genres can be very profitable. Look at what Ray Of Light did for Madonna 

It’s not 1998 anymore though.

 

1 minute ago, Si Hoo said:

Dance pop is regarded as dated sound these days. Most of the successful/critically accalaimed record of last years are alt pop (Troye, Pink Pantheless, New Jeans, Taylor, Tate)

Thats why I was hoping her to gets away from dance pop route but this rock route is baffling frankly

None of these artists have iconic hits besides Taylor. 
 

now why are yall dragging plastic hearts in here

 

 

I agree Gaga doesnt need to do exactly the same but Im always here for some rock, pop/rock, dark/rock (shes gonna invent this and yall will be gagged)

Gar has always been influenced by rock one way or another, wether it is sound, visuals or the way she performs 

6 minutes ago, toy soldier. said:

Why do people think Rock is so far off for Gaga? lol 

She's always had that rocker vibe to her, if anything country was a bigger shock than rock 

this exactly. 

 

50% of what makes her GAGA is the edgy-rock influence she brings to her music AND live performances.

One thing is certain - she’s not doing a rock/country/americana album, we’re safe. Joanne was cute for what it was but yeah, if she’s leaning towards some rock’ish sounds then I think she will definitely mix it with her signature sounds. I really don’t think people should be scared of her going the pure rock route. 

Edited February 4, 20242 yr by DonnieDarko