50 minutes ago, Alessandra said:

how come you did not mention all saints? i was ready to give my 11 to all coked up.

actually, i probably wouldn't participate coz (and i know it is a sin to say this on atrl, and ace will probably ban me) i generally hate girls aloud.

They seemed more fit for a different generation... competing with Spice Girls, DC, TLC... etc.

2 hours ago, Graves said:

My initial thought was just the aughts, but feel free to drive that idea wherever you like.

I have no interest in listening to Little Mix or Fifth Harmony.

The Aughts works - you get to include AS and DC3 then!

1 hour ago, Graves said:

They seemed more fit for a different generation... competing with Spice Girls, DC, TLC... etc.

true. they'd be in much better company.

maybe for the girls from the 00s you can add the ghastly atomic kitten. i remember getting dragged by their fans in a previous rate. like, how can anyone with an ounce of taste claim that their covers of eternal flame and the tide is high are anywhere close to the originals.

"Atomic Kitten fans"...?

4 minutes ago, conatus said:

"Atomic Kitten fans"...?

https://forum.popjustice.com/forums/comeback-corner.16/

2 minutes ago, conatus said:

"Atomic Kitten fans"...?

apparently a couple of them exist.

btw, have you watched that bbc "documentary" on when girl groups ruled the world? that ugly cow kerry catona gets a lot of screen time on it.

1 minute ago, Alessandra said:

apparently a couple of them exist.

btw, have you watched that bbc "documentary" on when girl groups ruled the world? that ugly cow kerry catona gets a lot of screen time on it.

I haven't, but that doesn't surprise me. I doubt she has much else going on to fill her time with. She must have been so happy to talk about the last time her career had any kind of promise.

6 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

https://forum.popjustice.com/forums/comeback-corner.16/

Such a fascinating place because what do you mean someone was in there yesterday posting about... Darren Hayes?

15 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

The Aughts works - you get to include AS and DC3 then!

Is this only counting the aughts stuff they put out then, 'cus... in that case I might as well have thrown in Danity Kane anyway. Old Saints have about four singles this decade.

15 minutes ago, conatus said:

I haven't, but that doesn't surprise me. I doubt she has much else going on to fill her time with. She must have been so happy to talk about the last time her career had any kind of promise.

they make it sound as though she was bound to be an mpg™. that nasty lil' trumpette never stood a chance.

there are some good interviews with mel blatt, some of the girls from eternal, heidi from sugabaes 2.0, and more.

15 hours ago, California said:

just crown Girl Overboard the winner already

no other chop girl group managed to top it

On The Metro

Girl Overboard

Every Now And Then

Memory of You

oh gods aloud

On 3/16/2026 at 12:14 PM, Eeveelution said:

The concept of prime Girls Aloud/Sugababes being rated alongside Gnarly

it'll be funny me thinks.

@Eeveelution you should host Kelela her Discography Rate one day.

@Ace Reject am I cool to start the second Ayu rate next week? I know there's a few going on already, but the deadline would be a late May affair and tbh I don't think there's that much overlap in the potential voting bases between this and UOG rates anyhow, so...

2 hours ago, Graves said:

@Ace Reject am I cool to start the second Ayu rate next week? I know there's a few going on already, but the deadline would be a late May affair and tbh I don't think there's that much overlap in the potential voting bases between this and UOG rates anyhow, so...

Yes!

Okayyyyyyy, thanks mother.

Someone should host a Fiona Apple discography rate with her debut turning 30 this year tbh. We're not due to a new album for another 10 years anyway.

The one from 2016 had horrendous results so I'm not sure if it would be better this time around

Researching and making a Finnish Divas throughout the Decades (from 70s onwards) playlist for a potential rate I can hold in late 2026/sometime in 2027. Just asking if I can actually hold it one distant day if I actually decide to go through with it. I know @Florence Belch will at least be joining.

Edited April 7Apr 7 by Album Leak

10 minutes ago, Album Leak said:

Researching and making a Finnish Divas throughout the Decades (from 70s onwards) playlist for a potential rate I can hold in late 2026/sometime in 2027. Just asking if I can actually hold it one distant day if I actually decide to go through with it. I know @Florence Belch will at least be joining.

The little chisusters will be joining of course

34 minutes ago, Album Leak said:

Researching and making a Finnish Divas throughout the Decades (from 70s onwards) playlist for a potential rate I can hold in late 2026/sometime in 2027. Just asking if I can actually hold it one distant day if I actually decide to go through with it. I know @Florence Belch will at least be joining.

Considering I'm going to Helsinki later this year I'll be there

4 hours ago, Suilen said:

The little chisusters will be joining of course

So here's how Ikävä can still win...

5 hours ago, Indie Go Mind said:

So here's how Ikävä can still win...

Now how is Ikävä ever going to win against this though

12 hours ago, Album Leak said:

Researching and making a Finnish Divas throughout the Decades (from 70s onwards) playlist for a potential rate I can hold in late 2026/sometime in 2027. Just asking if I can actually hold it one distant day if I actually decide to go through with it. I know @Florence Belch will at least be joining.

I'll always be ready to listen to some international bangers, count me in babe

Hope Viitasen will be there, she needs my 10s and 11s

Edited April 7Apr 7 by Florence Belch

52 minutes ago, Florence Belch said:

I'll always be ready to listen to some international bangers, count me in babe

Hope Viitasen will be there, she needs my 10s and 11s

She's not a main pop girlie I fear. Believe me I'd rather do a rate with real TALENTED girls but as an introduction to Finnish music it's better to start with the basics instead of bringing out the true legendary indie diamonds.