2 minutes ago, Graves said:

Yeah, good call with Dannii and Jamelia. Some flavor there (and Dannii). I definitely saw it as like a little sister for Connie's rate.

Wow what has Danielle Jane done to you?!?!?!?

THIS MUST BE.... POP! 2003 STYLE.

55 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Yep! Again, RN1814, LAP, and Daydream have all be rated twice - no need to rate them a third time! (In the Zone has too, and 4 will soon be rated again...)

But if you wanted to do one with all the others? In fact:

4th albums rated twice (let's leave them alone for now)

Like a Prayer

Janet Jackson's Rhythm Nation 1814

Daydream (The Christmas music should not be considered, no?)

In The Zone

4*

4th albums rated just once

Let's Get to It

Falling Into You

Afrodiasiac

Bionic

Red

Bangerz

Artpop

Queen

No Shame (Lily)

Sweetener

Heaux Tales (Jazmine)

30

Scarlet (which you yourself rated!)

4th albums never rated

My Love is Your Love (Whitney's soundtracks don't count as studio albums!)

Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie (Alanis)

Dónde Están los Ladrones? (Shakira)

Mary (MJB)

Breathe (Faith Hill)

C'mon, C'mon (Sheryl)

Up (Shania)

More Than a Woman (Toni)

Rated R (!!!!!!)

Honeymoon

Witness (!!!)

If I Can't Have Love, I Want Power (Halsey)

Virgin [but @supaspaz will soon have something to say about that...]

So you may have to shift things about for a 4th Album Rate!

also some 4ths from alternative queens of the 90s-00s

tori's from the choirlgirl hotel (y kant tori read was a group effort)

sarah mclachlan's surfacing

björk's vespertine

pj's is this desire

fiona's the idler wheel...

sinéad's universal mother

gwen's bouquet (xmas albums don't count)

too bad we don't have black alternative divas (that i can think of)

Edited April 11Apr 11 by Alessandra

49 minutes ago, Alessandra said:

also some 4ths from alternative queens of the 90s-00s

tori's from the choirlgirl hotel (y kant tori read was a group effort)

sarah mclachlan's surfacing

björk's vespertine

pj's is this desire

fiona's the idler wheel...

sinéad's universal mother

gwen's bouquet (xmas albums don't count)

too bad we don't have black alternative divas (that i can think of)

All these 10s, and then there's Gwen

This legit HAS to happen, I wanna witness the whole Bouquet serve OUT before any other album has a song eliminated

we need Vespertine and Witness in the same rate

1 minute ago, Florence Belch said:

All these 10s, and then there's Gwen

This legit HAS to happen, I wanna witness the whole Bouquet serve OUT before any other album has a song eliminated

that was my reason for including it. we need someone to take the lashings (and she deserves them)

57 minutes ago, Alessandra said:

also some 4ths from alternative queens of the 90s-00s

tori's from the choirlgirl hotel (y kant tori read was a group effort)

sarah mclachlan's surfacing

björk's vespertine

pj's is this desire

fiona's the idler wheel...

sinéad's universal mother

gwen's bouquet (xmas albums don't count)

too bad we don't have black alternative divas (that i can think of)

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame nominee Melissa Etheridge's Yes I Am as well (the one with the 'hits.')

Songs of Mass Destruction (Annie Lennox)

This Way (Jewel)

Universal Mother (Sinead)

Four The Record (Miranda) ( @conatus )

New Amerykah Part One!!!

The Light of the Sun (Jill)

We could keep going! Don't get us started!

5 minutes ago, California said:

we need Vespertine and Witness in the same rate

When we get the wrong Witness and watch ourselves discuss what's better between Unison and Roulette

Choirgirl and Is This Desire will be in 1998 MtW (which is deffo happening).

2 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame nominee Melissa Etheridge's Yes I Am as well (the one with the 'hits.')

Songs of Mass Destruction (Annie Lennox)

This Way (Jewel)

Universal Mother (Sinead)

Four The Record (Miranda) ( @conatus )

New Amerykah Part One!!!

The Light of the Sun (Jill)

We could keep going! Don't get us started!

we certainly could:

shawn colvin's a few small repairs

paula cole's courage

liz phair's self titled

natalie merchant's the house carpenter's daughter

ani difranco's puddle dive

though a rate like this would probably be called this was flop: was anyone even downloading this from napster

This competition to make the rate with the least participants in history.

Also I've been listening to a lot of Full Moon lately and I think we should do a Brandy discog rate sometime soon. I think we did a singles rate back when Beggin and Pleadin' was new-ish (...10 years ago ) but idk she's ever had a full rate?

13 minutes ago, Graves said:

This competition to make the rate with the least participants in history.

My time to shine

1 hour ago, Graves said:

This competition to make the rate with the least participants in history.

Is there an actual record holder in ATRL with this one? Like was there a rate that was completed with only 5 raters or something? And vice versa, what's the rate with the highest turnout?

Edited April 11Apr 11 by Indie Go Mind

5 hours ago, Graves said:

This competition to make the rate with the least participants in history.

You all make jokes about this, but there was a rate back in the day with five participants, if I remember correctly, and the host powered through with the results.

5 hours ago, Graves said:

Also I've been listening to a lot of Full Moon lately and I think we should do a Brandy discog rate sometime soon. I think we did a singles rate back when Beggin and Pleadin' was new-ish (...10 years ago ) but idk she's ever had a full rate?

to strike while the iron is hot. I still want to host a Darkchild/Rodney Jenkin's Producer's Rate.

1 hour ago, supaspaz said:

You all make jokes about this, but there was a rate back in the day with five participants, if I remember correctly, and the host powered through with the results.

that makes me so sad

On 4/9/2026 at 7:25 PM, Saddy said:

The winner is Love Will Never Do (Without You) by Janet

now in Multi Winners Club too

@Ace Reject Can this be added to the ongoing rates list?

Miley, Demi Selena and ARI winner is ... Every Girl You've Ever Loved - Miley Cyrus

thanks @Ace Reject for letting me do this :) shout me out whenever i can do that NOW rate :D

Is there enough people for a PJ Harvey Rate? We could make a discog rate in 2 parts, rating 6 albums for each part (or 5 if we want to ignore the John Parish records)

Kind of don't feel like applying for this promotion so which rate do we want next

Just now, conatus said:

Kind of don't feel like applying for this promotion so which rate do we want next

international T-Rex 3

4 minutes ago, conatus said:

Kind of don't feel like applying for this promotion so which rate do we want next

wait whatever happened to that cute 2025 electronic albums you had planned at one point

Just now, California said:

wait whatever happened to that cute 2025 electronic albums you had planned at one point

Was thinking about that one the other day. Is there still an audience for it? What's going on with Pinkpantheress? Can I swipe her?

5 minutes ago, conatus said:

Kind of don't feel like applying for this promotion so which rate do we want next

Faye Wong classics rate