21 hours ago, Album Leak said:

She's not a main pop girlie I fear. Believe me I'd rather do a rate with real TALENTED girls but as an introduction to Finnish music it's better to start with the basics instead of bringing out the true legendary indie diamonds.

Then those 10s and 11s will be given to Malla (please tell me she's a MFG - a Main Finnish Girl)

53 minutes ago, Florence Belch said:

Then those 10s and 11s will be given to Malla (please tell me she's a MFG - a Main Finnish Girl)

I'm afraid not. The playlist has 87 songs though so I'm sure we'll find at least a few artists deserving of high scores.

Edited April 8Apr 8 by Album Leak

Maybe we need to revive talks about that 1979 rate, 'cus...

Just now, Graves said:

Maybe we need to revive talks about that 1979 rate, 'cus...

The winner is Love Will Never Do (Without You) by Janet

@Ace Reject so, the 4th Diva's rate won't happen at all since we had a rate with Janet and Madonna's 4th album?

@Ace Reject just to check, I had permission for the Dua discography rate right?

A little after Watch It Burn (new KP single) comes out I wanna do the Katy Perry rate. @Ace Reject thots?

24 minutes ago, Saddy said:

@Ace Reject so, the 4th Diva's rate won't happen at all since we had a rate with Janet and Madonna's 4th album?

the first two albums by janet don't exist

49 minutes ago, Saddy said:

@Ace Reject so, the 4th Diva's rate won't happen at all since we had a rate with Janet and Madonna's 4th album?

49 minutes ago, Saddy said:

@Ace Reject so, the 4th Diva's rate won't happen at all since we had a rate with Janet and Madonna's 4th album?

Yep! Again, RN1814, LAP, and Daydream have all be rated twice - no need to rate them a third time! (In the Zone has too, and 4 will soon be rated again...)

But if you wanted to do one with all the others? In fact:

4th albums rated twice (let's leave them alone for now)

Like a Prayer

Janet Jackson's Rhythm Nation 1814

Daydream (The Christmas music should not be considered, no?)

In The Zone

4*

4th albums rated just once

Let's Get to It

Falling Into You

Afrodiasiac

Bionic

Red

Bangerz

Artpop

Queen

No Shame (Lily)

Sweetener

Heaux Tales (Jazmine)

30

Scarlet (which you yourself rated!)

4th albums never rated

My Love is Your Love (Whitney's soundtracks don't count as studio albums!)

Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie (Alanis)

Dónde Están los Ladrones? (Shakira)

Mary (MJB)

Breathe (Faith Hill)

C'mon, C'mon (Sheryl)

Up (Shania)

More Than a Woman (Toni)

Rated R (!!!!!!)

Honeymoon

Witness (!!!)

If I Can't Have Love, I Want Power (Halsey)

Virgin [but @supaspaz will soon have something to say about that...]

So you may have to shift things about for a 4th Album Rate!

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

If I Can't Have Love, I Want Power (Halsey)

she's taking it

After I wrap up Ayu (should be around June sometime), I'm thinking I might want to dip my toe into a UK pop rate. A smaller scale version of Makes The Woman perhaps.

7 minutes ago, Graves said:

After I wrap up Ayu (should be around June sometime), I'm thinking I might want to dip my toe into a UK pop rate. A smaller scale version of Makes The Woman perhaps.

This will be the PERFECT way for @RJF to make his ATRL rate debut!

1 hour ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

A little after Watch It Burn (new KP single) comes out I wanna do the Katy Perry rate. @Ace Reject thots?

Discography or Essentials?

4 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Discography or Essentials?

I think discography is fun but idk if the rest of ATRL would be down.

Maybe only essentials first (like top 40 most streamed songs)

3 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

I think discography is fun but idk if the rest of ATRL would be down.

Maybe only essentials first (like top 40 most streamed songs)

Well, essentials would be everything but the singles! So we could have something INTERESTING.

The second idea you suggested has never been done as a rate... tbh I don't like how streaming focused we're becoming...

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

Well, essentials would be everything but the singles! So we could have something INTERESTING.

The second idea you suggested has never been done as a rate... tbh I don't like how streaming focused we're becoming...

oopz.

Well then full discography would be the most fun IG, just like how its done with other pop girl rates (Gaga, Ari, RiRi). I already have a list of all Katy songs.

14 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

This will be the PERFECT way for @RJF to make his ATRL rate debut!

I was actually thinking we could do something akin to that 2008 Out of Control / Catfights idea you toyed with. a while back, Just with better year.

2003 has GA and Babes with better albums. Golfrapp too. And one other? (NOT Holly Valance… maybe Sophie?)

I wanna put myself down for an (international) female duos rate, probably around mid-June(ish)?

I've also had a few ideas kicking around in my notes for some international MTW ideas

1 minute ago, Graves said:

I was actually thinking we could do something akin to that 2008 Out of Control / Catfights idea you toyed with. a while back, Just with better year.

2003 has GA and Babes with better albums. Golfrapp too. And one other? (NOT Holly Valance… maybe Sophie?)

SORRY to those who wanted her in 2003 Makes the Woman Part two...

but..

Neon Nights/Three/Sound of the Underground/Trip The Light Fantastic just makes so much sense. SO MUCH sense! (throw in a Goldfrapp or a Jamelia if you're nasty!)

And then we could have the Missy/Kim/Monica v. Hilary/Stacie/Michelle 2003 MTW Part Two of my dreams!

34 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

4th albums never rated

My Love is Your Love (Whitney's soundtracks don't count as studio albums!)

Mary (MJB)

Breathe (Faith Hill)

Rated R (!!!!!!)

1998MTW, 1999MTW, and 2009MTW would like a word!

1 minute ago, Ghibli said:

I wanna put myself down for an (international) female duos rate, probably around mid-June(ish)?

I've also had a few ideas kicking around in my notes for some international MTW ideas

Shirley and Pepsi included? Shakespeare's Sister?

Just now, conatus said:

1998MTW, 1999MTW, and 2009MTW would like a word!

I mentioned many of those albums with trepidation....

@Saddy maybe you should just go on and host 2017 Makes The Woman - "shockingly," Witness, Rainbow, and REPUTATION have never been rated.

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

Shirley and Pepsi included? Shakespeare's Sister?

well erm they'll be one 80s UK act present

2 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

SORRY to those who wanted her in 2003 Makes the Woman Part two...

but..

Neon Nights/Three/Sound of the Underground/Trip The Light Fantastic just makes so much sense. SO MUCH sense! (throw in a Goldfrapp or a Jamelia if you're nasty!)

And then we could have the Missy/Kim/Monica v. Hilary/Stacie/Michelle 2003 MTW Part Two of my dreams!

Yeah, good call with Dannii and Jamelia. Some flavor there (and Dannii). I definitely saw it as like a little sister for Connie's rate.