Perfect Celebrity

as a miley stan who would adore to see her live, i kinda don't care that she said this? i don't really see it as insulting or anything. i mean i'd rather her do a residency than nothing at all which seems to be the only other option here

if you guys actually do have a problem with surrogacy that you would like to share then i would advise going to spaces where that is appropriate instead of demonising a random woman who you dont know on a pop music forum and making her the face of it. we also don't know if she had a surrogacy or not, and if she did we also don't know her reasons why. time and place!

wow this is amazing news!! i know she will be an excellent mother. so happy for her

xtina purely for the atrl kii's

didn't she literally say she was connected to bey too in that exact sentence?

reading this knuckles deep into a packet of biscuits with a cold can of pepsi

all these stella lefty threads

you guys are gonna hate this girl into a career just like you did with- TRAIN PASSES BY

actually screamed when they announced this on the news, i'm so upset and in shock. RIP Dolly you were such a gem and we were so lucky to have a soul like hers on this earth

if you had read what i'd said then you'd see i was asking if you're ADMITTING that it was one of the biggest, not asking for your opinion on whether or not it is or isn't

so you admit abracadabra is one of the biggest solo female songs of 2025?

the fact she has performed every song from TFM since the tour for it ended except for this hymn... shes sick and twisted!

a "greatest hits of all" rate could be fun, no? a bunch of greatest hits albums pit against each other to see which artist has the most beloved hit songs feels like it could be a really fun bloodbath. i'd be interested in hosting it but i have dyscalculia so i may struggle with finding out the average score and i'm not quite sure how hosting a rate works what do you think?

YES madonna and kylie the queens im so happy for them! hope we can get a proper live performance of this song soon!

cher's abba cover album was made because she was in mamma mia 2 which was a massive movie and pretty much had that promoting it. 8 weeks is not that much longer than 5. it also didnt go number 1 unlike confessions 2 tony bennett did an entire cover album with lady gaga who at the time was still a newish, younger artist. his last solo album before that was released in 2004 and charted at number 65, and his solo album after that was released in 2015 which charted at number 96. his album before cheek to cheek (another collaboration album) went number 5 and charted for 11 weeks. this was an entire cover album full of already iconic jazz hits. elton john's album was also ENTIRELY collaborative, with hold me closer and cold heart both being different parts of his already iconic songs mashed together. it also had hype as the first britney single released post conservatorship. you conveniently left out that unlike all of the albums you've listed (with the exception of cher's 2013 album which was released 13!!! years ago now) madonna released an album entirely of NEW music. it is still charting in the UK which is her biggest market, and it still managed to go number 1 without a major streaming hit. it IS much harder for older artists to chart well nowadays, especially with ORIGINAL music, no matter how you try to spin it

was about to comment miley cyrus but then remembered something beautiful happened

so many conflicting feelings about this. i think her taking a step back is for the best but i can't help but feel like she has been bullied into hiding for possibly having an illness. some of the comments ive seen about her have been nightmarish. people acting like her being sick is a moral failure and comparing her body to nasty pictures in the name of "concern" and "activism". mass bullying a random woman you've never met on the internet is not going to cure an illness!

ariana has done it again! what an amazing album. her ear for melodies is unparalleled

regardless of what you think of bts, they are in the right here. they could've been quiet about it and swept pretty much asian category based on popularity alone and it's pretty obvious they wouldve won at least one grammy in the category. having an asian category seems unnecessary and confusing, how could a k-pop song and a bollywood song be nominated in the same category? would olivia rodrigo be nominated in the category too simply because shes part asian? it's pretty clear that they only made this category as an excuse to not nominate a plethora of other asian acts in the "main" categories and they obviously expected everybody to shut up and accept the scraps they were thrown.

im pretty sure she said in an interview last year that she was given a big budget but spent it all on the clothes

i think deep down we all know the true answer

i was actually really pleasantly surprised with this! the way she addressed the drama in the songs gagged me, i just wish some of the songs were longer and not under 1 minute

ooh thats interesting... you say that something beautiful flopping was a wake up call for her, what do you mean by that? is she planning to do lots of promo for this next era? i remember in a few interviews during SB era she said something along the lines of that she wanted this era to be her last one where she cares about commercial success and then after that she can do whatever she wants. obviously the commercial success didnt happen so im assuming shes aiming for one last hurrah before doing whatever she feels like?

your username is an old song of hers from 2008 wait... does that mean she will be rerecording some old stuff?

wasn't one of the first responses in this entire thread a monster saying how gaga has peaked?