Yes, AND

For the record, I don't actually care that she Is lipping. I knew this whole show would be mostly lipped, what's annoying is people crowing about things being 100% live when her actual voice sounds nothing like what you're hearing. The song Courage, is where her real voice is now. And that's still been polished in studio.

The performance of Courage, while still likely lipped, is representative of her current voice in studio. Its completely different tonally to the voice you hear on TPOL or All ɓy myself. It's clear they used old tracks but just lowered the keys.

Rihanna has never written a note or a word in her life.

They did the same for all the flop songs from 143 lol

Yeah it's clear she's using tracks for most of it. Even something like Por que te maime encore is definitely mostly lipped, even though it sounds live its still a track.

I guess I missed when beyonce released 3 albums on consecutive Fridays.

She's not the first..

People unironically claiming that Celine sung All by myself high note live ... in 2026, like be fr

That's bottom energy I fear.

Obviously lipped but she sold it well

The Olympics was clearly pre recorded. That isn't even a discussion. And I doubt she's doing the power of live belt live when she's been lipping almost that whole song for 25 years.

She could add them as bonus tracks

There's a clip of I'm alive, which sounds live. My heart will go on vocals I felt like I'd heard them before

Congratulations to the boatmates.

The album that kick started the dance phase.